> Real estate seems like a pretty important part of the economy...
You just answered your own question. Governments do not have a history of distributing scarce resources effectively. You need various market forces.
> the government artificially making housing more accessible for potential first time buyers creates a virtuous cycle where people can finally save money and the eventually spend that money to stimulate their micro economies
This is not what happens. As you said - it's artificial. Markets, like the internet, route around this sort of censorship. Any attempt to make housing artificially more affordable will have the effect of increasing demand (by design). When you increase demand, prices rise. And thus becomes unaffordable again. You can then increase the subsidies further to try to offset your original manipulation, which will only worsen the problem. This is precisely what happened in the 90s/early 00s and the result was the 2008 housing bubble.
To be fair, "various market forces" also don't have the best track record of distributing resources, especially scarce ones. Somehow those always end up being "distributed" into the same few hands...
I don't understand why people make wild claims that everything is distributed to only a few hands, thats preposterous. If you really believe that, you are poisoned by ideology.
You should spend some time in Appalachia if you think that's true.
And while it may just seem that the rich get richer, the poor have gotten far richer under capitalist systems than any other form of economy.
During communism, people with the only currency left - power - manage to get all the best things (which can be food, if everyone is starving, or luxury item, if people are not starving yet). In a free market luxury items eventually become common goods.
That's why most common people have a phone, a vacuum cleaner, a microwave, a tv.
Also, this thread is literally about how the housing market isn't a true market...it's a government run welfare program backed by the Fed. You're proving my point.
[0]: And they are always managed. Even "free"-markets are managed, since free-markets are not a natural state, at least not for long.
[1]: Capitalism itself is a vague word that can be used to describe any number of only superficially related systems. E.g., 1800s Britain was capitalist, and had working conditions so appalling that they made Marx's ideas attractive. Modern Nordic capitalism is quite different from that, but would also still be described as capitalism (except by Democratic Socialists who know nothing about Scandinavia and are trying to convince people that those countries are actually socialist).
Any market government gets into gets distorted.
Half-hearted government is a problem; education and healthcare both suffer in the US from trying to split the baby Solomon-style.
This is happening now more than ever with the Democrats seemingly deciding that the US Fed has the additional mandate of fighting systemic racism.
Real estate seems like a pretty important part of the economy and, more importantly, the government artificially making housing more accessible for potential first time buyers creates a virtuous cycle where people can finally save money and the eventually spend that money to stimulate their micro economies.