Lots of these ideas are popping up right now because it's a very compelling idea which is demonstrated to work. And because climate change is driving massive growth in renewable energy (woot) we will desperately need massive amounts of energy storage in the very new future. The energy storage market is expected to grow massively year over year.
What does it cost to dig and maintain a 1.5km deep shaft?
I found is something around 8000-10000$ per meter. I can buy a whole lot of batteries for that.
This technology just does not scale since mgh always holds true.
Unlike flywheels where you get w^2.
Just making the wheel out of carbon fiber and making them go fast, squares the amount of energy you can store.
https://www.storage-lab.com/gravity-based-storage https://www.osti.gov/biblio/6517343
But mostly they won't be digging the holes, they will be using shafts left over from earlier mining operations.
https://minewiki.engineering.queensu.ca/mediawiki/index.php/...
Honestly i would have thought it to be more expensive.
At higher depths the ground pressure is enormous and you need a lot of bracing.
Then there is water management, air, transportation of the dug out material...
When there is rock you usually need blasting or gargantuan drills which i am not sure even exists in the required diameter.
And the much bigger issue is, you have to constantly pump out water that will inevitably fill the hole. And that only costs you money.
1) Pumps that can pump water 150 meters or a kilometer high are very expensive and require constant expensive maintenance.
2) Where will you pump the water to? Now you have to build huge storage tanks.
3) The water never stops flowing in. Sooner or later you will run out of storage space and your expensive hole will fill up with water.
There is no way, short of fusion that I know of. And fusion is not a valid answer in this context anyway (even if we had the tech for it).
But at that point, why wouldn't you just do a classic pumped-storage reservoir?
Furthermore, my most optimistic estimates show that underground solid mass gravity storage could compete with pumped hydro on cost anyways. One reason is that solid mass is about 2.5x heavier than water. If excavation is one of your biggest costs, this density is important.
Maybe if you are lifting the entire city. For perspective, take electric vehicles. Each moving EV is a mass being constantly accelerated at say 0.1G. So the weight in the graviticity system to power those EVs would have to be at least 10% of the mass of all the EVs active in a city.
This would be a really cool element in a sci-fi world
https://sipilpedia.com/tecorep-system-high-tech-demolition-s...
365000 tons × 9.81 m/s2 × 1 m = 1 MWh
which ought to at least be enough to provide short term backup power to the whole building.
Each unit can be configured to produce between 1 and 20MW peak power, with output duration from 15 minutes to 8 hours.
For reference, 20MW is ~4 large aerogenerators. A single nuclear PWR is 500-1000MW.
It can scale up to provide 1 GW of storage - enough to balance the load of an entire large city.
You'd need 50 of these installations for a single city, for 15 minutes of power, 1000 for the 8 hours.
Dig a very deep hole with a radius of 500 m, with a 500 m granite block that you can raise and lower in it to store and retrieve energy.
When the block is raised, toss trash into the hole. Then when the block is lowered to retrieve energy it also becomes the world's largest trash compactor.
Eventually, you'll get enough trash in the hole that even massively compacted you won't have enough room to make the energy storage from raising the block worthwhile.
You then have to dig another hole and move the block, leaving behind a full landfill that has more trash in it than a normal landfill of that size would have.
And it still does not answer how the construction and running costs are calculated.
Only if those are as low as claimed (which I highly doubt) something like this might be feasible.
This tech just does not scale well.
Digging holes is stupid expensive. Moving giant masses is not trivial and to double the storage capacity you need twice the weight or twice the height.
The energy density is way too low.
The only thing run by weights have been those old grandfather clocks. And even there the weights got replaced by springs and in the end batteries.
Lead-acid = 0.14 MJ/kg = 14.3 km
LiFePO4 = 0.58 MJ/kg = 59.1 km
LiNiMnCoO2 = 0.74 MJ/kg = 75.5 km
Sometimes I wish we lived in an alternative world with fully developed nuclear power. Think about the possibilities. And no global warming! :/
[1] Not accurate, obviously.
In the real world, you'd need the rocket itself (which in turn contains the rocket fuel) which adds weight, and you'd have a difficult time controlling power output so the rocket doesn't drift and lengthen/reduce the burn time -- but that's not the point.
The idea is that we want a unit that relates the mass of the fuel with its total energy, and one way to approach that is to consider how long the fuel could offset the force of gravity on that fuel, which gives you a cute unit of measure in terms of time.
An easy calculation shows how low the storage potential is.
Lets take a weight of 500 tones of steel, which would be 63.29 cubic meters.
Now sink those 500 tonnes into a hole a 100 meters deep that would make a rather lowly 0.1362 MWh of storage.
https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=500+*+1000+kilograms+*...
Not sure what the cost of digging a 100 meter hole where you can sink 63 cubic meters of steel in would be, specially since water management is needed too.
I am not convinced that it is worth it.