Re:Sid Meier: “I don’t think I could make Civilisation today”
by renewiltord on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:38AM
(#24417183)
Minecraft is the best game I have ever played in 25 years of playing games. Nothing like it. A masterpiece. Once in a generation masterwork. Created an avenue for creativity for a generation. It's for the history books.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Sid Meier: “I don’t think I could make Civilisation today”
by Merem on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @01:27AM
(#24417475)
Do you know Clonk? Minecraft is basically that, just in 3D and with some added things like a procedurally-generated world and stuff like hunger. But crafting, "blocks", extracting materials, mobs, multiplayer, creating new items, mechanics, scenarios etc for the game and so on were already there, many years before Minecraft.
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/14/Clonk-En...
https://cc-archive.lwrl.de/shots/7.jpg (with Stippel pack)
Seems like it's really hard to come by screenshots these days. Things like the Stargate pack with working portals, Goa'uld etc were just great.
Re:Sid Meier: “I don’t think I could make Civilisation today”
by HeadsUpHigh on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @04:09AM
(#24418586)
Some of the added things you mentioned plus the 3d aspect are vital to what minecraft is. The game starts in survival mode and slowly switches to building mode which is a very well executed and satisfying transition. The 3d aspect of it is important and so is the hunger. Hunger is the first bit of horizontal progression, then the rest comes from unlocking building resources and convenience. Vertical progression in comparison is quick and 99% of the mobs soon pose no challenge.
Re:Sid Meier: “I don’t think I could make Civilisation today”
by renewiltord on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @02:16AM
(#24417801)
Incredible. What a disappointment I did not come across these as a child. There's something to Minecraft, though, and I can't quite describe it.
Re:Sid Meier: “I don’t think I could make Civilisation today”
by Kiro on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @02:57AM
(#24418080)
Clonk is great but not comparable to Minecraft imo.
Re:Sid Meier: “I don’t think I could make Civilisation today”
by mcv on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @06:19AM
(#24419440)
I think Minecraft is the only game I could conceivably nominate as objectively the best game ever. It's not my personal favourite (I'm more a Paradox guy), but it's the only game in this over-saturated market that literally everybody knows. Even out of the box there's already a lot of different ways to play the game, and then there's mods and custom servers with plugins that open up such an endless world of possibilities that nothing else comes close.