News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by excalibur on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @08:51PM (#24415452)
The US condemns the use of forced labor to produce cotton.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by Zhenya on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @08:59PM (#24415517)
What's your point? Slavery was abolished a long time ago in the US. Any pressure to stop enslavement or forced labor of humans should be celebrated.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:45PM (#24415849)
> Slavery was abolished a long time ago in the US

No, it wasn't.

Chattel slavery was converted almost overnight into penal slavery, with largely pretextual criminalization of the exact same group previously subject to chattel slavery, a long time ago in the United States.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by Zhenya on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:19PM (#24416149)
You're right.

We can go buy slaves today in the US. /s

Yes, criminalization of legal acts to recapture the free labor is abhorrent. However, passing the 13th amendment and then fighting a civil war to enforce it at least creates an incredibly strong legal footing for defending people from forced labor.

Criminals paying back their debt to society is a different conversation in terms of the length and harshness of the penality.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:28PM (#24416234)
> We can go buy slaves today in the US

No, slaves you can buy as an individual is what you have with chattel slavery.

Slaves whose labor you can rent, or the product of whose labor you can buy, from the state who holds them as convicts (or that the state uses directly for it's own purposes under the same conditions) is what you have with penal slavery.

> However, passing the 13th amendment and then fighting a civil war to enforce it

That...didn't happen. In fact, the Republicans, despite being an ideologically abolitionist party, didn't pursue abolition as a policy, merely limiting (not even stopping) the geographic expansion of slavery, specifically to avoid splitting the union and provoking a civil war.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by refurb on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:10AM (#24417038)
I love these pendantic HN comments. Everyone else in the thread is referring to chattel slavery when they use the word "slavery", but you feel a need to point out how it isn't technically correct.

Great. We're all still talking about the same thing still.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @04:46AM (#24418814)
> Everyone else in the thread is referring to chattel slavery when they use the word "slavery"

And here I thought everyone was referring to an American practice analogous to the Chinese state forced labor of those who have been deemed harmful to society; while chattel slavery is, I suppose, loosely analogous there, I'd say penal slavery is actually a closer analogy.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by branweb on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:05PM (#24415564)
Don't forget forced sterilization: https://apnews.com/269b3de1af34e17c1941a514f78d764c The attitude of someone who reacts to this with "what about the antebellum south!" is beyond my understanding.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by Aperocky on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:36PM (#24415783)
So China had a one child policy that only applied to Han Chinese, which is the dominant ethnic group of the country.

Now they relaxed the requirement to 2 and applied it to everyone. Of course it's now immediately a genocide. The previous one, despite harsher limits and usage of the same methods, is evidently not.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by branweb on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:40PM (#24415811)
From the linked article: "The state regularly subjects minority women to pregnancy checks, and forces intrauterine devices, sterilization and even abortion on hundreds of thousands"

Maybe the article is mistaken? It seems like quite a bit more than just applying a one-child policy.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by Aperocky on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:51PM (#24415895)
> abortion on hundreds of thousands

There are 10 million Uyghurs in China. Abortion on hundreds of thousands is quite literally the abortion of the whole population. And hundreds of thousands will be able to attest to this. I have no doubt that China violated a bunch of human rights to enforce the 2 child policy, but calling it a genocide of the Uighur, and then exaggerating or filling in the data by imagination is rich given that it was harsher before and nobody voiced a peep just because it didn't apply to minorities.

I don't like what China is doing, it's probably entirely justified to sanction Xinjiang and the camps. Nobody should have their freedom restricted just because they were born different and believe in different things. But at the same time propaganda outlets manufacturing consent is also disgusting.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by branweb on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:07PM (#24416039)
It's not inconceivable that Uighur human rights abuses are being used for political purposes. Certainly a healthy dose of skepticism is not uncalled for. Yet the people who respond to such reports with outraged knee-jerk accusations of hypocrisy against the US because it had slavery in the 1860s or because it has forced labor in some prisons today--I don't understand that.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by Aperocky on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:14PM (#24416103)
I didn't bring up slavery or any US internal issues at all - it's entirely worthless to this discussion.

What I'm trying to say, is that truth matters. We can't just level unfounded claims because it's convenient, that's how you devolve into a nationalist flame war, with the military industrial complex giggling in the background.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by branweb on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:28PM (#24416225)
Totally agree that "US internal issues" bring nothing valuable to this discussion. Also agree that truth matters. I don't think that can be said enough these days. My comment about the discussion of slavery/prison inmates was referencing the root post of this thread, and some of the other responses.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by vkou on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:29PM (#24415742)
The thirteenth amendment explicitly permits subjecting prisoners to forced or unpaid labor, and this aspect of it is used extensively in the United States.

Slavery didn't end in 1865. It's still with us - just a bit out of sight, out of mind.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by wonnage on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:48PM (#24416409)
This is not stopping any enslavement or forced labor, in China or elsewhere.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by excalibur on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:23AM (#24417100)
> What's your point?

It is ironic and amusing.

</point>

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by jonathannat on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:08PM (#24415578)
When folks bring up China of today, other folks like to deflect by bringing up US of 10 years ago, 20 years ago, 50 years ago, or 200 years ago. And use the same social and moral context from those era to judge.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by jjcon on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:27AM (#24417118)
I have found too that people get mad if you happen to bring up Germany of 50 years ago though
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by kthxbye123 on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @08:59PM (#24415513)
So much so that we fought a titanic war with hundreds of thousands if not millions of casualties to end it!
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by everdrive on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:18PM (#24415662)
And it's right to. We fought a civil war over this. (and other issues, of course.) Please don't trivialize this topic with infantile tu quoque arguments.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by IIAOPSW on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:03PM (#24415551)
The US has consistently fought against using forced labor to produce cotton since 1861.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by piiswrong on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @11:10PM (#24416582)
blacks are vastly overrepresented in the prison population and NYC just forced them to bury COVID bodies with scarce protection.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by jjcon on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:29AM (#24417133)
No source, not relevant anyway
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by piiswrong on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @02:21AM (#24417838)
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by jjcon on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @08:45AM (#24420361)
Your source directly contradicts your claim

> prisoners have been digging graves on Hart Island for years

This isn’t really COVID related. Additionally, they are digging graves not necessarily burying bodies.

> is offering prisoners at Rikers Island jail $6 per hour... and personal protective equipment

So they get paid and have personal protective equipment.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by elil17 on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:00PM (#24415519)
Perhaps more relevant is the fact that there have been over a thousand instances of slavery in Florida tomato farms in the past decade
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by branweb on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:34PM (#24415774)
I dislike internet flamewars with glib calls for "source pls", but this seems like a pretty extraordinary claim to make with no substantiating evidence. Over 1000? According to who? I found this wapo article from 2012: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/fair-food-program-he... It says the justice dept prosecuted 7 cases since 1997. It says over 1000 people were affected. Are you counting each person as an instance?
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by matthewdgreen on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:18PM (#24416139)
Why wouldn't you count a human being held in slavery as an instance of slavery? I'm genuinely confused what you're getting at here.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by branweb on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:25PM (#24416201)
I'm not saying you shouldn't. I'm just trying to get some clarification on the original statement. The source I was able to dig up is from 8 years ago, and was reporting on incidents stretching back 23 years ago. The op mentioned 1000 instances in the past 10 years. I just want more info on what they meant.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by matthewdgreen on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:31PM (#24416249)
Ok, but you easily dug up an article that confirmed it. Even down to the number of people who were affected and the time period. But instead of just posting the source (which I do appreciate), you seem to now have a problem with the definition of the word "instance" as used to refer to the enslavement of a single human. What definition would you prefer that is more standard or appropriate?

ETA I am now reading article after article about this issue, and the fact that this particular industry seems to have cleaned up its act in 2012 doesn't make me feel better about any of it.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by branweb on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:48PM (#24416405)
Doesn't make you feel any better about the original claim or about the fact that the abuses took place?

To your first point: I have a problem with the unsourced claim that there have been 1000 instances in the past 10 years, which I could not find a source to confirm. To your second about which term I would prefer, I don't set myself up as an authority. But if the op meant 1000 people, he should have said 1000 people. I think it would be clearer than "instance." When I first read that, I wasn't sure if it means "a person" or "a case when a tomato farmer got busted." If the latter, then it would have been way more than 1000 people affected.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by matthewdgreen on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @11:12PM (#24416599)
A person being enslaved seems like a perfectly reasonable definition of an "instance of slavery." You turned up a source that seemed broadly consistent with this, and inconsistent with the "1,000 farmer busts" reading. Then you asked if the person was counting each person as an instance, which clearly they were. That's why I asked what the problem was.