News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by dang on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @11:53PM (#24416902)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24415282.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by Alupis on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @08:37PM (#24415356)
To compare a prison in the US to "labor camps" in China is intellectually dishonest.
[dead]
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by darkerside on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:28PM (#24415730)
It's a very incomplete comparison. What have the Uighurs done to merit their imprisonment?
[dead]
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:37PM (#24415789)
I mean, imprisonment itself is a pretty severe restriction. If you're proposing that even deserving criminals should be treated as well as you and I, I don't have a tremendously convincing refutation, other than to note that it implies much more radical changes than simply ending prison labor.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by darkerside on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:46PM (#24416390)
The conversation is about the treatment of Uighurs in China, and the US reaction to it, no? If anything, I'm reacting to an attempted derailment of the conversation by comparing it to the (flawed) prison system of another country.

Of all the problems to fix with the US prison system, forced labor is so far down the list anyway. And yes, I do believe in consequences for actions, as do most people over the age of 25.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by XMPPwocky on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @11:46PM (#24416847)
"I do believe in consequences for actions, as do most people over the age of 25."

Of course- there can be no well-considered arguments for things like prison abolition. No, even considering the idea of such a thing means you're too naive. When people break the rules, they need to have consequences- and, of course, those consequences must be "being locked in a cell". Nothing else is possible. Don't show me the data- don't show me the recidivism rates- don't show me the thinking. That's all just crazy. Grow up. Nothing can ever meaningfully change. We must only fine-tune our existing system- the structure, the heart of it all, is unquestionable, absolute, no less so that the divine right of kings. Can't you see that? After all of human history, we've finally figured things out. Don't question it. Moloch is powerful hungry, after all. We need to do what we've always done. Everybody agrees on that. Better things are childish fantasies. Don't dare question the hegemony, kid. Be realistic, we say, closing our eyes, developing new adaptive noise cancellation to blot out the sounds of the child in the basement, God have mercy we need to be realis

But maybe in a few years we'll, say, legalize weed. Would definitely keep a lot of non-violent people out of jail, and that's definitely something. Maybe by 2050 we'll have cut inmate labor by 10%. I think that's a fair compromise.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by darkerside on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @07:13AM (#24419732)
My views are a lot more nuanced than the straw man you put together here. I don't disagree with some of the things you've said. I was simply declaiming the false equivalency between incarceration of convicted criminals and the persecution of a purple based ENTIRELY on ethnicity. I get the the justice system is tilted in a similar way. It's a combination of personal and systemic racism. But matching people into concentration camps on trains is qualitatively different, and we can't lose sight of that.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by FpUser on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:28PM (#24415733)
Labor in US prison definitely can be considered as forced / slave. The actual conditions most likely are better than in China (or should I say not fucked up to the same degree) but it is still amounts to slave labor, especially as it relies on private prisons whose owners would do anything to get their money (Kids for cash scandal proves how far they would go)
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by Invictus0 on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @08:39PM (#24415368)
I'll allow that American prisons leave a lot to be desired but comparison to the Xinjiang camps is really quite inappropriate. Labor in American prisons is paid, optional, and conducted safely, while the Chinese camps are actively working to destroy a minority's cultural heritage through torture, rape, ideological brainwashing, organ harvesting, arbitrary imprisonment without a trial, forced relocation, forced sterilization, destruction and confiscation of property, and extreme levels of surveillance.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by strombofulous on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @08:55PM (#24415478)
Just to raise awareness about this (not trying to be nitpicky, sorry) labor in american prisons is typically unpaid (or might as well be, sometimes paying less than $1/hr) and not optional as the 13th ammendemnt specifically allows slavery as a punishment. JCPenny uses american prison labor to market their jeans as made in america, and I believe mcdonalds uniforms are made with prison labor. Netflix has a very good documentary on this, I'd recommend it (as long as you're willing to be very sad about it for at least a few days) https://www.netflix.com/title/80091741

For reference the 13th ammendment reads "Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction."

But the rest of your post is correct.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by Aperocky on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:22PM (#24415690)
> But the rest of your post is correct.

Won't say that, there are quite a bit of unsubstantiated claims in that message supported only by few individuals and organizations paid by the CIA.

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by ameen on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:48PM (#24415873)
There’s testimonies of actual Uighurs who have described what goes on in these camps- are they now CIA plants?
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by wonnage on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:39PM (#24416320)
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by godelski on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:30PM (#24415748)
Do you have evidence of this? Both of you made bold claims that citations would help with.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by berdario on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:00PM (#24415986)
Not as bold as the claims of millions of Uyghurs being detained:

https://twitter.com/RodericDay/status/1287411708374454273

Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by Aperocky on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:44PM (#24415840)
All of his claim can more or less be trace backed to Adrian Zenz, who is a 'Senior Fellow of China Studies' at Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation. If the name was not immediately telling, it was set up and paid for by the US government.
Re:U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjian... by tialaramex on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:13PM (#24415631)
I'll agree that American prisons aren't as bad as the Chinese practices but it's a very long way from what would be seen as reasonable in much of the world.

When you say paid for example, the prisoners aren't paid statutory minimum wage, and don't have access to outside prices, so both how much they get paid (often less than a dollar per hour), and how much things cost them to buy with this money are both controlled by the same people controlling their labour, a recipe for abuse.

As to "optional" many convicts don't seem to agree with you about how "optional" their labour actually is. Convict labour makes the private owners a lot of money, so from their point of view a prisoner who won't work is a problem and problem prisoners get punished. US prisons routinely use harsh psychological measures such as long periods of solitary confinement that would be considered torture elsewhere - without meaningful oversight.

And finally "safety" is very much in the eye of the beholder. The relevant US agency simply doesn't collect any safety data about prisoners, reasoning that since work is part of the punishment for a crime of which they were duly convicted† it doesn't matter if they're injured or die as part of that punishment... after all the US still has capital punishment, deliberately killing prisoners is actually part of the "justice" system.

† Of course one of many other things wrong with the US criminal justice system is that some of these people never committed a crime, the lack of a sane pre-trial bail mechanism in most of the US means if you're facing prosecution you have to plead guilty to get out quicker if you're poor...