e.g. it seems the SpO2 sensor on this Withings watch is an 'on request and then sit still for 10 seconds' type feature. No good for continuous monitoring.
The IFTTT integration did get busted but now that I'm on apple I care less.
I got around the approval delay for the Withings BPM Core by ordering the item from Amazon.fr and I suspect I will need to do the same for the Withings ScanWatch if I decide to get it. Not sure how/why the approval in EU is faster.
Also, if you use only one source of data (ie. the fat measurement of the scale) and do not mix different sources, accuracy is not that important. Since, if there is a systematic error in the measurements, it applies to all the measurements and the trend is always true, even if there is also a small randomness component.
The main selling point here is convenience. You can do a somewhat decent fat measurement in your bedroom. The Dexa can not beat that.
On the other hand, my model (one I bought in 2015), also supports heart rate and this is total rubbish. To the point that it might give me 120 bpm at rest, then go on and do a workout and immediately after the work out, it reports 70.
I would have said that too, but during the lockdown and stay-at-home period, it made a meaningful rise, and it fell back when I could go back to walking and doing sports. Fat percentage: made up? Probably not. Precise? Also probably not.
The delay seems to have come from the worry of the perception that it was being used for "diagnosis" of sleep apnea as that would put them in a different category with the FDA. You can imagine how direct access to the SpO2 sensor was a hot topic during the height of the pandemic of a repository illness. In short, the hardware is there, but corporate conservarivism kept it from being used or even exposed to the user.
I've bought a Withings Smart Scale (at that point they were briefly owned by Nokia). The scale is simple, clean, durable, featureful; the companion health app is one of the cleanest/effective specimins of UI I've seen in a while and has tons of integrations. I expect great things here and hopefully less fear about exposing the hardware readings of highly useful sensors.