News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gary Marcus's Kafkaesque critique of GPT-3 by toxik on Monday September 07, 2020 @04:01PM (#24402272)
I think there is a point to be had that GPT-3 is nowhere near human level in its responses, but is that really the bar to set? It seems extremely high.

This rebuttal asks if a human could continue the slightly nonsensical inputs, and I feel like we certainly could? “... tried to drink with his eyeglasses; his schizophrenia was particularly bad today.” While sharing a spoon with your neighbor is in the realm of what’s possible, it does seem very odd, seeing as there is no prior relationship established to this neighbor. I also wonder what would’ve happened if an actual neighbor had been mentioned before, i.e. a door neighbor. I think any human would then read neighbor as next door neighbor. Would the network pick up on this and specify seat neighbor?

Re:Gary Marcus's Kafkaesque critique of GPT-3 by mellosouls on Monday September 07, 2020 @04:32PM (#24402563)
I think there is a point to be had that GPT-3 is nowhere near human level in its responses, but is that really the bar to set? It seems extremely high.

Unfortunately the hype surrounding GPT-3 (and deep learning before it) wrongly implies we are making great strides towards AGI; it's inevitable people then ask for the evidence and set the bar so.

Re:Gary Marcus's Kafkaesque critique of GPT-3 by SpicyLemonZest on Monday September 07, 2020 @06:53PM (#24403627)
It's a high bar, but we've had "can carry on a shallow conversation" chatbots for a while, and I don't know that there's a clear intermediate objective.