News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by softwaredoug on Sunday September 06, 2020 @01:18PM (#24392899)
As I wrote in the article, there’s increasingly not a shared identity or values between people in the same nation state. I think the burden of the proof needs to be on “why should nation states exist?” in that kind of environment. Especially considering how new the idea of a nation state is in history.
Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by anm89 on Sunday September 06, 2020 @01:58PM (#24393237)
My argument would be that the nation state exists as a useful tool/ mechanism for collecting and organizing power for people at the top. It justifies it's existence through might not right, so saying it shouldn't exist because it's not right misses the point.

It is there because they want it to be there and to get rid of it, you need to create something more powerful to overcome that other thing. This historically is possible but just turns into its own state.

Power vacuums are a very real thing though intangible.

But simply having the subjects of a state lose faith in it is not itself sufficient to topple it. I mean look at current congressional approval ratings in the US. They are approaching single digits but it means nothing because there is no real structure in place to challenge it.

I apologize if the initial post was condescending. It's a well written article but I still perceive it as naive to the larger structures which hold this stuff in place.

There's a great YouTube video (imo) on the topic of state level power dynamics if you are interested https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs

Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by jonemi on Sunday September 06, 2020 @02:59PM (#24393745)
How are differences in identity and values not the objective of diversity?

[edit] First comment on HN and thought I should add more context so it doesn’t sound like a rhetorical question. I’m asking because one of the values you refer to in the article is diversity and how it can be a uniting value among those who espouse it. I understand that to mean valuing differences among people, so I’m asking sincerely if the fact that we coexist with people of all varieties of identities and values fulfills one of the objectives of diversity. If I’m misunderstanding something, happy to be corrected.

Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by rapsey on Sunday September 06, 2020 @01:25PM (#24392955)
You are extrapolating something out of an extreme situation that only exists where you live. The US is in the early stages of disintegration/civil war/collapse. Who knows what is going to happen, but it is not going to be pretty.

Plenty of peaceful countries do have a "a shared identity or values" even across the conservative/liberal spectrum.

Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by softwaredoug on Sunday September 06, 2020 @01:29PM (#24392989)
Also Poland, Turkey, the UK, Germany, and every other country having issues with a radical right.

Even Canada

https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/canada-political-c...

The US w/ Trump may have its extremes, but this pattern is playing out in a lot of places.