News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by anm89 on Sunday September 06, 2020 @11:50AM (#24392166)
This comes off as painfully naive to me. The nation state does not exist because we learned it.
Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by drewcoo on Sunday September 06, 2020 @01:05PM (#24392801)
The nation state does not exist because of boundaries occurring in nature.

The nation state does not exist because it describes the places where different ethnic groups live.

The nation state does not exist to circumscribe natural regions of trade.

The nation state does not exist because someone's gods decreed it.

If it's not learned, then how exactly do you think the notion of the nation state came to be?

Is your problem that it's defined by powerful cabals via force? Is that your complaint? That we can't "unlearn" the point of someone else's gun?

In that case, I suppose I agree.

Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by dogma1138 on Sunday September 06, 2020 @02:24PM (#24393477)
>The nation state does not exist because of boundaries occurring in nature.

Open a map and see just how many borders both historically and today were mountain ranges, rivers and other terrain that served as a natural border.

>The nation state does not exist because it describes the places where different ethnic groups live.

For the most part it very much does. The few exceptions were this didn’t happen and the nation failed to develop a new national ethnic identity those experiments ended up in disaster, see Lebanon, The Balkans etc.

>The nation state does not exist to circumscribe natural regions of trade.

Historically this is very much how city states and later on nation states came to be, even during the imperial age this trade was a key factor in how administrative and autonomous regions came to be.

Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by rbecker on Sunday September 06, 2020 @01:32PM (#24393010)
> The nation state does not exist because it describes the places where different ethnic groups live.

It comes very close a lot of the time, or decays to that. See the 92% Han China, or the split of Czecho-Slovakia and Yugoslavia along ethnic lines. A split of you're lucky, genocide if you're not: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genocides_in_history

Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by emteycz on Sunday September 06, 2020 @01:53PM (#24393183)
About Czechoslovakia... You know there was a numerous ethnic minority of Germans before the aftermath of second world war, right? We pushed them out because of nation state ideology, which gained prominence after first and then especially second world war. Before then, people were Bohemians, and they spoke like and culturally were Germans, Austrians, Moravians, Czechs, Silesians, Slovaks, etc.
Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by rbecker on Sunday September 06, 2020 @02:43PM (#24393613)
"It comes very close a lot of the time" doesn't imply the fit is perfect, so minorities are to be expected.

And your implication that before WWI, different ethnic groups coexisting peacefully in shared states was the norm, couldn't be more wrong. Even in antiquity, there's examples of one ethnic group banding together to vanquish another, such as the ancient Hebrew genocides of Amalekites [1] and Canaanites [2].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amalek#Amalekites_in_the_Hebre...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canaan#Hebrew_Bible

Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by emteycz on Monday September 07, 2020 @02:52AM (#24397168)
What I was saying is that the 'closely matching borders' are a completely artificial thing. Not even 'more or less', it was completely off until the nation state ideology-fueled expulsion. It closely matched a different thing.
Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by softwaredoug on Sunday September 06, 2020 @01:18PM (#24392899)
As I wrote in the article, there’s increasingly not a shared identity or values between people in the same nation state. I think the burden of the proof needs to be on “why should nation states exist?” in that kind of environment. Especially considering how new the idea of a nation state is in history.
Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by anm89 on Sunday September 06, 2020 @01:58PM (#24393237)
My argument would be that the nation state exists as a useful tool/ mechanism for collecting and organizing power for people at the top. It justifies it's existence through might not right, so saying it shouldn't exist because it's not right misses the point.

It is there because they want it to be there and to get rid of it, you need to create something more powerful to overcome that other thing. This historically is possible but just turns into its own state.

Power vacuums are a very real thing though intangible.

But simply having the subjects of a state lose faith in it is not itself sufficient to topple it. I mean look at current congressional approval ratings in the US. They are approaching single digits but it means nothing because there is no real structure in place to challenge it.

I apologize if the initial post was condescending. It's a well written article but I still perceive it as naive to the larger structures which hold this stuff in place.

There's a great YouTube video (imo) on the topic of state level power dynamics if you are interested https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs

Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by jonemi on Sunday September 06, 2020 @02:59PM (#24393745)
How are differences in identity and values not the objective of diversity?

[edit] First comment on HN and thought I should add more context so it doesn’t sound like a rhetorical question. I’m asking because one of the values you refer to in the article is diversity and how it can be a uniting value among those who espouse it. I understand that to mean valuing differences among people, so I’m asking sincerely if the fact that we coexist with people of all varieties of identities and values fulfills one of the objectives of diversity. If I’m misunderstanding something, happy to be corrected.

Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by rapsey on Sunday September 06, 2020 @01:25PM (#24392955)
You are extrapolating something out of an extreme situation that only exists where you live. The US is in the early stages of disintegration/civil war/collapse. Who knows what is going to happen, but it is not going to be pretty.

Plenty of peaceful countries do have a "a shared identity or values" even across the conservative/liberal spectrum.

Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by softwaredoug on Sunday September 06, 2020 @01:29PM (#24392989)
Also Poland, Turkey, the UK, Germany, and every other country having issues with a radical right.

Even Canada

https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/canada-political-c...

The US w/ Trump may have its extremes, but this pattern is playing out in a lot of places.

Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by Ma8ee on Sunday September 06, 2020 @12:30PM (#24392483)
It’s a relatively new concept (in the history of ideas). it’s neither necessary or ubiquitous, so we can certainly do without it.
Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by funcDropShadow on Sunday September 06, 2020 @12:46PM (#24392640)
Yes, let's return to tribal states. Let the strongest be our chieftain. /sarcasm off

It is always easy to dismiss something, which is not perfect --- and what is perfect? But nothing is just removed from society. Something else always takes its place. So usually it is naive and bad idea to concentrate on what is going wrong. If you want to improve the world you have to concentrate on what should be done better and how should it be done better? In this case, what is the alternative to nation states that you envision? Kingdoms? Anarchism? A Star-Trek like utopia? A global communist state? Or simply a failed state, like Afganistan or Somali? If I look at this list, I see nothing that is even remotely as good as western nation states. Although, they have obvious flaws.

Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by robotron on Monday September 07, 2020 @07:46AM (#24398731)
So it should be beyond examination or critique?
Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by Ma8ee on Monday September 07, 2020 @12:56PM (#24400723)
I don’t think you know what a nation state is. If you did, it would be obvious to you that there are other alternatives.
Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @12:10AM (#24405113)
Your comment would be more useful if you listed some, instead of just mocking the GP for being ignorant.
Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by rapsey on Sunday September 06, 2020 @12:09PM (#24392303)
The OP assumes everyone is like him and enjoys meeting others from other cultures and gets along with everyone. Painfully naive indeed.
Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by softwaredoug on Sunday September 06, 2020 @01:24PM (#24392944)
It’s more the point that NOT everyone feels this way and we’re sorting those who like multiculturalism into cities more and more efficiently. So the political divisions are not between nation states but between increasingly aligned urban centers and everywhere else (the hinterlands.)
Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by rbecker on Sunday September 06, 2020 @01:34PM (#24393030)
*In the US. You won't find quite as much multiculturalism in the cities of India, China, Japan, Turkey, or most of Africa (including North Africa).
Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by softwaredoug on Sunday September 06, 2020 @01:36PM (#24393051)
That’s likely true, but I still feel the prevalence for cities to be relatively more cosmopolitan (for a variety of reasons) still holds. The incentives are for them to become more aligned with other cities than their own nations.
Re:Unlearning The 'Nation State' by minimuffins on Sunday September 06, 2020 @01:01PM (#24392764)
Why does it exist?