News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by jrockway on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @04:42PM (#2439180)
I've always wanted to write exactly this blog post. Keeping your salary confidential is great for big companies, but it benefits you in no way. You should be making what your coworkers make. If you make less, you're being fucked, plain and simple. The sooner you realize that, the sooner you can remedy the situation. Sadly, some people go their whole careers without doing so.

FWIW, my first programming job only paid $45,000 a year. What a ripoff.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by nostrademons on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @05:10PM (#2439316)
But it does benefit you, personally: by not having your information out there in public, you can claim whatever you want when you go into salary negotiations, and the hiring company has no way of knowing that you'd be perfectly happy with a significantly lower salary. Generally, whichever side has less information public about them is at an advantage in negotiations.

Unfortunately, this leads to a prisoner's dilemma situation where each individual worker would be better off if everyone shared their salaries, but each individual worker is slightly better off if they don't share their salaries.

FWIW, my first programming job only paid me $32k a year. But I was straight out of high school (no college), and I thought it was a princely sum because I was getting paid more than my Ivy-League grad high school teachers were getting.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by dopkew on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @10:11AM (#2442255)
When salary information is private, the employee has advantage while negotiating a new job, whereas, if the salary information is public, he has advantage while he is within the company.
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by mcantor on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @09:48PM (#2440337)
This argument is circular: "Keeping your salary private benefits you when negotiating a new salary"... which is difficult mainly because everyone's salary is private.
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by nostrademons on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @10:37PM (#2440476)
...which is the case with most game theoretical situations.

You don't get to choose the world you live in, you only get to choose the choices you make. If you want to move from one world to another, you have to figure out how to get the rest of the world to make those choices.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by autarch on Thursday April 14, 2011 @12:01AM (#2445537)
Start your own company, and use a radically open compensation system, perhaps?

That's my plan, at least.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by xnxn on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @04:52PM (#2439225)
> only paid $45,000 a year

Reading this kind of thing on HN makes me feel ill; my W-2 says $47k. Maybe I need to make some changes.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by tjarratt on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @05:13PM (#2439337)
Really depends on where you work. There are some managers that make $47k in some parts of the US and live very comfortably.

Aside from that, contracting can help get bump your salary up. Fresh out of college I was making less than $47k and then easily tripled my salary within a year of contracting (although I was working insane hours and basically used all of my allotted overtime hours). It isn't always great for mental health or work/life balance, but it can be a great shot in the arm in terms of providing needed work experience and money.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by xnxn on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @05:33PM (#2439416)
Thanks -- I've toyed with the idea in the past, and I think it might be time to just dive in.

So if anyone has resources for a web developer in Portland looking to break into contracting, I'd love to hear from you.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by wtracy on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @07:46PM (#2439936)
Do keep in mind that "most" programming jobs are in areas with high costs of living: San Francisco, San Jose, and New York.

That said, take a look at this: http://www.payscale.com/research/US/Location=Portland-OR/Sal... The median salary for an SE in Portland is $67k.

So, yeah, it's negotiating time.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by viggity on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @05:00PM (#2439264)
Try contracting. Seriously. Go to a local user group and talk with people who contract and see what the going rate is in your area. Its probably 2x to 2.5x of what you're getting now.
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by AretNCarlsen on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @05:11PM (#2439321)
Though you have to pay your own taxes -- probably 30%, in the end -- and your own medical.
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by ewams on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @06:18PM (#2439614)
You pay your own taxes now.
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by kragen on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @06:52PM (#2439748)
In the US, there's a Social Security payroll tax (previously 12.4%, now 10.4%) that's split between employer and employee. Self-employed people pay it themselves; their clients don't.
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by christonog on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @06:59PM (#2439771)
I think what he meant was that you have to consider a hefty tax burden come April 15 because, as a contractor, you don't get taxes taken out of your paycheck. This is where having a good accountant and knowing what expenses you can deduct comes in (to reduce your taxable income).

If for nothing else, you should have a business just so you can claim more expenses and reduce the amount you have to pay Uncle Sam (from my understanding, all you need to have is a profit motive -- not necessarily profits).

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by danssig on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @10:38AM (#2442408)
My tax guy always tells me: the US hates employees. There are more loopholes if you contract or (even better) have your own business (which could be a contracting business).

Plus you don't get taxed at source so you can take that extra 30%+ you get each paycheck to pay a tax person to figure this all out for you in time to save up for the tax hit at the end of the year.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by eof on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @05:05PM (#2439286)
renegotiate/find a new job? With 1.5 years of 'starving freelance' experience I got my first programming job at 55k and was able to negotiate to 70k within 6 months.
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by xyzzyz on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @03:30AM (#2441169)
They offered me more ($55k) on my internship. I really think you should earn more.
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by arghnoname on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @10:55PM (#2440524)
For my first programming job I asked for $50k and got $40,000. I always resented that, as I thought I was giving them a break in the first place, but I had just moved to the area (DC) and didn't have time to look very hard.

So 6 months later I got them to raise it to 50, and a few months later they they fired the other programmer (my boss, who was making $85k) and expected me to do the work of both he and I, which I was capable of doing. They told me they just gave me a raise so I shouldn't be greedy.

I left of course. They hired my replacement at $90k after having a consultant do the job for three months at typically high rates. I would have accepted $60k! I just didn't want complete disrespect.

A year or so later I was making $80k and found out another guy at this company was making $40k. What the hell? I don't thing anyone should be so royally fucked.

Companies that do this deserve no loyalty. Salary information should be public as long as they persist in such behaviors.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by danssig on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @08:28AM (#2441816)
>Companies that do this deserve no loyalty.

No company deserves "loyalty". You need to get that dinosaur of a concept out of your thought process. We're free market entities now. We act completely within our own interest and the "invisible hand" makes sure everything turns out alright in the end. [1] Loyalty is for family and friends.

[1] Of course your own interest isn't a simple amount question. If another company offers me 5k/yr more I wouldn't drop what I'm doing at the current company and move for that. My reputation is part of my market value so I have to avoid angering my "customers" as much as possible (within reason, but the best choice is to just not take customers that will likely end up hating you later). Ideally, when I leave they'll all hope I come back some day.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by drndown2007 on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @04:47PM (#2439199)
So did mine, but that was 1994 so it didn't seem so bad :) (which is another way of saying that context is _very_ important, like year, what part of the country, web programming vs kernel drivers, DBA, etc)
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by Tycho on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @06:20PM (#2439620)
Hmmm... when I graduate I'd definitely take a £18000 p/a job. I mean it seems at this age getting your foot in the door, getting started and putting some 'commercial experience' on your CV is far more important than the actual salary.

On the other hand, if I could make a living doing freelance web development, then I could build that up until I have an income that employers would need to match (rather than just throwing me the low end of the offered salary-range).

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by quanticle on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @12:47AM (#2440803)
As of 2011-04-13, 18000 pounds sterling is 29421 US dollars. Despite what you say about "getting your foot in the door", I would hesitate before taking a job that paid so poorly. For the record, my internship paid $25 per hour. That translates to $42000 per year [1]. I'm not an exceptional programmer, and my grades in school weren't that stellar either. I would strongly encourage you to negotiate before selling your services for so low a price.

1. http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=%2425+per+hour+

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by Tycho on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @07:16AM (#2441609)
I see ads for 'Senior developers' that want to pay £25-33k. Granted there also ones paying better but the highest advertised I've seen is £40-45k p/a. Obviously it will be higher in London though, and there are lots of ads for contractors at £300 per day.

Meanwhile I know people who finished their CS degree and never got a programming job. I know one guy who's a decent programmer, only got a couple of interviews, one only because he offered to work for 14k, but ended up working in a bank admin job for 13k for years before finally getting a secondment to an SQL/Excel position at 18k or so.

I don't know, man. Just seems there's a disconnection between the salaries you guys talk about on HN and the salaries that are realistic for me. Bearing in mind if it's a graduate job then there's going to be many gaps in your knowledge (unless you're exceptional), so it seems you should bite the hand off the first place that offers you a job and the chance to become a more complete developer (after which you'll have a much stronger negotiating position, but until then, as an unproven dev companies can justifiably look at you as a liability).

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by infinite8s on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @11:21AM (#2442635)
You need to find positions where they don't look at you as cost-center, and instead as someone providing value to the bottom line. 300 pounds a day is ridiculous. Most contractors make double that in day.
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by danssig on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @10:53AM (#2442487)
1. Move

2. Go contracting

If no one would put up with these low wages they would be forced upward.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by Tycho on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @05:38PM (#2444356)
But what if I don't want to move, or don't want to spend anytime in unemployment? £1500 per month is pretty appealing when you have rent to pay. Also, while £18000 might be a joke in the respect that you're only slightly better off than the average admin job, despite the vastly different knowledge and problem solving requirements, what about the whole 'majority of developer applicants can't solve FizzBuzz in ten minutes' thing? Or the belief that programming ability is like compound interest - the more you learn, the faster you get better? Or the outsourcing to India (where I bet they get a whole lot less than 18k per head)? Those things would seem to make low starting salaries natural.

But I do like the idea of selling your skills on a freelance/contracting basis, and foregoing all the noise of the industry hiring practices. I'd definitely give that a shot before taking a 18k-24k job. Seriously doubt £25+k for a first, junior dev role is on the cards though.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by swombat on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @06:47PM (#2439730)
Tip: When asked about my salary expectations for my first job, I said "£20-24k". I got £22k. Many of the other people who started alongside said lower figures - and that's what they got.

Don't quote something way out of the range of the company you want to work for, but don't undersell yourself either. You'll probably get what you asked for... £15-25k is dirt cheap anyway, for any large corporation, but that £10k makes a whole lot of difference to your life.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by danenania on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @12:08AM (#2440713)
I think freelancing is a quicker way to get established and reach a high value if you can swing the social and project management aspects. Especially early on, your value increases enormously with each deliverable product you produce. Freelancing allows you to build a portfolio quickly, and you'll be able to point others to jobs you've completed. Successful jobs also inevitably lead to referrals and you can raise your rate on every new contract as your portfolio improves and you become more valuable.

Working for a salary, you can easily get stuck on projects that aren't portfolio-worthy, don't teach you anything that useful, and which you only have a small hand in anyway. And naturally it's comparatively much harder to get pay increases. One solid project that impresses people can take you from charging $50 to $100 an hour as a freelancer overnight. Try convincing your boss to double your salary after 3 months just because you've been shipping good code.

As for breaking in, talk to as many people as you can. Go to meetups, talks, events, whatever is happening, in both the programming AND (very importantly) business/entrepreneurship categories. Just chat and share ideas. If you're confident and you've got brains, people will recognize it, and you'll soon need to beat offers away with a stick. The first gig is the hardest to get because you have nothing to point to in your portfolio. Do this one for free if you have to, or build things on your own. Whatever it takes to get something finished that you can use to prove your competence.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by fsipie on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @01:11PM (#2443178)
Hi,

£18,000 is what I got at my first job over 15 years ago. I know things are tough in the UK for you young 'uns now though.

Commercial experience isn't as good as having some nice websites in your portfolio IMHO.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by gte910h on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @04:47PM (#2439201)
If you're making less, you're possibly being fucked. You're possibly avoiding a layoff.

If you're making more, I'm not sure how showing your salary data can help you personally.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by michaelochurch on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @04:53PM (#2439233)
If you're making more, I'm not sure how showing your salary data can help you personally.

Status, at least when you transition.

In investment banking, people would quickly discover what the top bonus was for their year and report it when they moved on to jobs in, for example, private equity. The banks saw it as symbiotic and would confirm inflated compensation. It made the ex-analysts get better jobs but it also made the firms look more generous, so it was seen as win-win.

It becomes an issue when next year's class expects the middle bonus to be last year's top bonus.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by Hovertruck on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @06:33PM (#2439675)
Depends on your situation. I got my first job at a mid-late stage startup in DC when I was 18 and that was about $35k as a strictly-frontend developer, which was definitely good enough for me.
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by nixy on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @02:50AM (#2441072)
My first was, in 2007, $46k. I'm still at the same company, now making $70k nearly four years later. (I'm 25, doing web programming, in Sweden)
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by clistctrl on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @05:20PM (#2439368)
My first year programming job I made ~50k though I was a contractor, and did a bunch of overtime so it was likely quite a bit more.

I think it was pretty good considering I had not graduated college... so I was getting paid to learn.

I started at $25 an hour. I quickly learned the business, and realized I could make it better. So i spent my nights building an app to do it better. They loved it, became the new thing we used. 6 months later my contract ended. I asked for more... and oh yeah did I mention I was a junior programmer (the code was exactly what you would expect, so I had some good leverage) to me $27 an hour was pretty good. I was 19, and making more than my Dad (he always said this is the benchmark I'm supposed to pass).

about 4 years later I'm now making $77k with about 5k or 6k bonus. I moved to Boston, so I think without a degree, its reasonable but I would definitely be making quite a bit more had I finished college.

I'm Hoping to quit my job soon, and start off on my own. The project I did for a $2/hr raise after 6 months could've been worth millions... and I'm sure I could do it again, seeing better ways to do things is kind of my thing.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by benihana on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @04:56PM (#2439247)
>FWIW, my first programming job only paid $45,000 a year. What a ripoff.

How is that a ripoff? That seems right at about average for starting salary programming.

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by jessedhillon on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @05:12PM (#2439330)
My first programming job paid $75k in 2007. It was not at some big name firm but a run-of-the-mill ad agency and I was doing PHP web dev. It was in SF and I had just graduated from UC Berkeley about six months prior to hire.

Unless he (or she) is working as a game dev, he is grossly underpaid. (Even if he is doing game dev he'd be underpaid, just the standard for pay would be much lower for his industry.)

Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by jamesteow on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @06:18PM (#2439608)
To be absolutely fair, SF/NY have much higher starting rates than other places.
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by jrockway on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @08:41PM (#2440119)
If people are getting $100,000 right out of college, then $45,000 is not very good.
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by tedunangst on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @12:56AM (#2440825)
Well, we'd need to know when that was. $45k in 1980 would be pretty awesome.
Re:The Programmer Salary Taboo by jrockway on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @05:48AM (#2441425)
I'm 25, so this was probably 4 years ago at the most.

(Fun fact: jrockway was once a PHP programmer. And, we did not use source control there. And a web developer did a "push" and overwrote my weeks worth of programming. Then I knew it was time to find a new job :)