On the other hand, I know that if I were trying to build a team, and someone said that he could get 10% more as an "analyst" at Goldman, I'd advise him to do so. Why would I want to hire someone who wants to work an entry-level banking job? Some people care more about remuneration and cachet than interesting work and that's fine, but like should dance with like. If 12 months of punishing hours and miserable work humbled him a bit, and he realized he wanted a work environment that assessed him according to ability rather than pointless sacrifice, I'd be willing to talk to him again after that point.
I feel like you're just the other side of the coin, thinking your company is "exciting", while the guy thinks he's worth more than you're offering.
If (a), I want to hear what he has to say. If (b), he should work at Goldman.
I'm 27 and have 4 years development experience. And I'm talented. I could realistically make $250-300k if I sold out and worked in investment banking-- a lot more than I'm worth at my level of experience, and more than I'd expect in a normal software job. I'd hate my life and probably burn out in the first 45 days, but I could do it if the thought of being a banker didn't disgust me.
That is to say, a tiny minority of recruiters.