News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:That dev's salary is higher than mine by michaelochurch on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @08:22AM (#2436825)
The good advice in here is that you should always take a few days to consider an offer. I'd use that time to get into contact with some friends or favorable interviewers at the company and get some "off the record" time to get a sense of what kinds of projects you'll get. Project allocation is more important than a measly $5,000 in salary. If compensation is an issue, figure out if you're being paid fairly. Not, "What do you make?" but "What should I expect to make?" People will give you accurate numbers.

As for trying to claim another offer to get more pay... Bad idea! You're unlikely to have the offer retracted-- simply divulging that your offer was rescinded in the right corners of the internet will damage the firm's reputation in a way that is more costly than the cost of retaining you for a few months, but the "I have another offer" trick, if you use it to negotiate more compensation than you deserve, is going to damage your reputation among those who know you used the tactic. Yes, they'll hire you because rescinding an offer leads to negative press, but they won't like you much.

Also, firms that lowball are generally not places you want to work. It's a huge warning sign. I got an offer at a company that lowballed me, I negotiated a 25% increase, and went to work there, and it was still a mistake. My observation is that the initial offer gives you the best sense you'll ever get (better than performance reviews!) of what those in power at the company think of you. If you negotiate a higher offer, you'll get a little bit more cash, but won't improve their perceptions of you. So you'll get crap project allocation and a high salary. When layoff season comes around, guess who's at the top of the list?

A good company will pay you fairly regardless of your salary history and other alternatives, and likewise not be pushed around by high offers from, e.g., Wall Street, an industry that throws money at people so they ignore its deep cultural problems and generally low quality of work.

If you want to negotiate a higher salary, there's a right way to do it and a wrong way to do it. The wrong way is to say, "I have an offer at Goldman Sachs for 50% more", to which most self-respecting recruiters will say, "Then go work at Goldman." The right way is to say, "according to my research <don't disclose what your research is, especially if it involves people at the firm> the proper salary for a person of my position is $<X>. I also believe that I have considerable long-term potential both on the technical and executive ladders, so add 10%. Also, I don't need the 10% hiring bonus upfront so why don't we just include that in my salary, which allows you to pay it on a later schedule. So $<1.2X> is what I consider a fair number." The negotiation needs to be about what you can do for them, not what you can get from a competitor.

You claim another offer to expedite hiring processes and to have leverage to ask for more insight into the work you'll be doing (and for more interesting work, to the extent that such things can be bargained). What you want to show is that you respect yourself and are looking for the best fit for you and your career, not that you're a mercenary who is only going to be there because of $5-10k in marginal compensation. People talk more than they should and you can get a negative reputation before you start if you do this.

Re:That dev's salary is higher than mine by yummyfajitas on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @10:35AM (#2437358)
"...to which most self-respecting recruiters will say..."

That is to say, a tiny minority of recruiters.

Re:That dev's salary is higher than mine by michaelochurch on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @11:13AM (#2437524)
It depends on the individuals doing the recruiting and what their incentives are. If you're talking to someone who just wants to fill chairs in the short-term, you can make certain plays like that. Some recruiters are just trying to fill chairs and will overlook certain behaviors in order to "close the deal".

On the other hand, I know that if I were trying to build a team, and someone said that he could get 10% more as an "analyst" at Goldman, I'd advise him to do so. Why would I want to hire someone who wants to work an entry-level banking job? Some people care more about remuneration and cachet than interesting work and that's fine, but like should dance with like. If 12 months of punishing hours and miserable work humbled him a bit, and he realized he wanted a work environment that assessed him according to ability rather than pointless sacrifice, I'd be willing to talk to him again after that point.

Re:That dev's salary is higher than mine by blake8086 on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @04:37PM (#2439153)
So you would give up a quality guy over 10%?
Re:That dev's salary is higher than mine by michaelochurch on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @05:41PM (#2439457)
Let's say I'm hiring people into an exciting tech company. How is a guy who is going to work for Goldman over 10% "a quality guy"? Maybe he's talented, but do I really want to hire a guy who values small differences in pay over the difference between a great opportunity and a crappy banking job? No. I'd rather let that guy work at Goldman, so he can see how much it sucks first-hand and then possibly come back looking for something more rewarding (or not).
Re:That dev's salary is higher than mine by blake8086 on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @07:15PM (#2439835)
I don't understand, is it a small difference in pay or not? If it's not, why not hire the guy? If it is, why do you think it's so strange that that would make his decision for him?

I feel like you're just the other side of the coin, thinking your company is "exciting", while the guy thinks he's worth more than you're offering.

Re:That dev's salary is higher than mine by michaelochurch on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @07:27PM (#2439884)
Does he think he's worth more than I'm offering (a) because he has some talent or skill I'm not aware of, or (b) because Goldman Sachs is willing to pay him more to do 120 hours per week of mind-numbing work?

If (a), I want to hear what he has to say. If (b), he should work at Goldman.

I'm 27 and have 4 years development experience. And I'm talented. I could realistically make $250-300k if I sold out and worked in investment banking-- a lot more than I'm worth at my level of experience, and more than I'd expect in a normal software job. I'd hate my life and probably burn out in the first 45 days, but I could do it if the thought of being a banker didn't disgust me.

Re:That dev's salary is higher than mine by blake8086 on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @11:04PM (#2440551)
Ok I looked at your commenting history and it seems like you have this same discussion over and over. I disagree with you, but I definitely see merit to what you're saying.