News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EMule 0.60a by whywhywhywhy on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:52AM (#24362721)
> P2P technology is important to resist censorship

It's important to retain culture too, people who legally own movies, music, etc can't be trusted to actually archive or distribute them properly.

Look how many artistically important movies are not really available anymore and the only old dvd copies floating around are either badly cropped, badly graded, cut or have poor subtitling/sound. The only people who can be trusted to look after these artworks are people doing it out of passion rather than profits.

In 10 years the teenagers growing up today are going to have a cultural blackhole as a lot of the more unusual music they enjoyed no longer exists anywhere online because it was all on spotify, YouTube or soundcloud and they might have gone out of business, not retained it or the creators themselves lost it or moved on.

Re:EMule 0.60a by isolli on Thursday September 03, 2020 @07:41AM (#24362986)
Music can also be lost to fire, as it was in 2008 [0] (with Universal studios originally downplaying the loss until a 2019 New York Times article revealed its full extent).

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Universal_Studios_fire

Re:EMule 0.60a by arka2147483647 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @09:00AM (#24363585)
The point is that if everything is in a single giant "library", and it burns down, then everything is losf forever.

But if there are copies here and there, there is much more chance that at least some will survive the centuries.

Eg, single point of failure vs redundancy

Re:EMule 0.60a by whywhywhywhy on Thursday September 03, 2020 @09:45AM (#24363966)
>The point is that if everything is in a single giant "library", and it burns down, then everything is losf forever.

What.cd suddenly comes to mind...

Re:EMule 0.60a by selectodude on Thursday September 03, 2020 @12:24PM (#24365655)
That was so tragic.
Re:EMule 0.60a by salmo on Thursday September 03, 2020 @02:04PM (#24366790)
Now if P2P could only go back in time and get the original Beach Boy's Smile or MBV's Loveless followup finished and released.
Re:EMule 0.60a by powersnail on Thursday September 03, 2020 @02:38PM (#24367231)
P2P is actually mostly preserving movies. I find it to not be an abundant resource for old music recordings/lives.

I've downloaded quite a number of really old live performance of classical music from YouTube, that are practically nowhere else to be found. No pirate version can be found, private bay or the likes.

At least for now, YouTube is a gain in preserving and distributing old and unusual content, not a loss, in the world of classical music. I don't know what happens it one day it ceases to exist, but I imagine enough people would have saved copies of those videos to re-upload to whatever video site replaces YouTube.

Re:EMule 0.60a by carstenhag on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:32PM (#24369119)
Your "in 10 years the teenagers..." part applies even today already. A German rapper I know had released a mixtape 3-4 years ago, but as he had no rights to the beats it was only a mediafire zip upload...

Not even he has the zip or any of the songs, as the files got deleted, managers changed and so on. And this was no mediocre stuff, I loved it!

Re:EMule 0.60a by hosteur on Thursday September 03, 2020 @12:32PM (#24365749)
> Look how many artistically important movies are not really available anymore

Yeah like for example the moon landing videos that NASA deleted by accident. Had they been freely available in hires digitized copies we would still have them. But alas we only have low res copies.

Re:EMule 0.60a by duskwuff on Thursday September 03, 2020 @02:01PM (#24366757)
> Yeah like for example the moon landing videos that NASA deleted by accident. Had they been freely available in hires digitized copies we would still have them.

The moon landing videos were made in 1969, and are believed to have been erased in the early 1980s. There was no technology at the time to digitize those videos, nor any compact data formats to store them in, nor users with spare storage for that data.

Re:EMule 0.60a by jandrese on Thursday September 03, 2020 @02:09PM (#24366872)
While true, it doesn't invalidate the grandparent's point. The tapes were easy to lose because they were not replicated.
Re:EMule 0.60a by duskwuff on Thursday September 03, 2020 @02:39PM (#24367243)
And they were not replicated at the time because this data wasn't considered valuable, and on a larger scale, because there was not a culture of data preservation at NASA.

(It's not clear that they had the ability to replicate this data, anyway -- the reason it was lost was that they needed to reuse the magnetic tapes for data from another project!)

Re:EMule 0.60a by jandrese on Thursday September 03, 2020 @03:00PM (#24367481)
That's why allowing the data to be replicated is so important if you care about preservation. It only takes a few happy mutants who think some otherwise boring data might be interesting and keeping a copy for themselves.
Re:EMule 0.60a by duskwuff on Thursday September 03, 2020 @03:34PM (#24367859)
Again, you're assuming that ordinary people had some way to easily "keep a copy for themselves". This was emphatically not the case. This data was not digital. It only existed as a set of magnetic tapes in an unusual format: 1" magnetic tapes containing application-specific analog data. The number of institutions that would have been capable of copying and storing this data would have been small; it's improbable that any individual, "happy mutant" or otherwise, could have done so at the time.

The notion that any sort of data is easy to copy and store is a modern concept. It was usually not the case in the past.