But if innocence itself is brought to the bar and condemned, perhaps to die, then the citizen will say, 'whether I do good or whether I do evil is immaterial, for innocence itself is no protection,' and if such an idea as that were to take hold in the mind of the citizen that would be the end of security whatsoever.”
- John Adams
I can't help but see the similarity between this quote and the words of a 90 year old BLM protester that I met in Seattle recently: "No, I don't really care about the looters. Let them take what they want. Because it doesn't matter. Nothing matters anymore. Because guilty or innocent, if they're black, they're gonna end up in prison at some point before they die. Just like I did. For 24 years."
My therapist does some work in the state prison system, and he told me once that most prisoners go through the full 5 stages of grief usually within a couple of months. And by the end of those stages of grief, it is no longer painful for them to accept and openly admit that they committed a crime. He can only recall two long term prisoners that he worked with that refused to admit guilt after a year in prison...one of them has already been fully exonerated (not commuted, but actually cleared of all guilt), and the other was recently granted a retrial. Anecdotal, sure, but I find it believable.
Instead they just inflict the punishment up front on whoever they want. Then when that person tries to get it back, they have no standing because the suit is against the property itself. It takes some special people to believe in this legal fiction that the owner of the vehicle has no real standing or loss.
The road was also being used. Can they seize that and the police department would now have a new toll road to raise revenue. Oh, you say the state didn't know what the drivers intentions were on the road? Too bad -- they should have foreseen everything done with their property.
Even if you want to argue that the punishment of having your car seized fits the crime of DWI, there's no due process here. Taking the car and then asking a judge to get it back is "guilty until proven innocent".
If a drunk driver gets a $2,000 fine, but the owner has their $40,000 car forfeited, is that fair punishment?
https://www.aclu.org/blog/criminal-law-reform/reforming-poli...
But if the act was not pre-meditated, or somehow the result of a probable conspiracy the owner was a part of, the vehicle shouldn’t be seized.
The wrongness of this has nothing to do with this case, though. It is that there is any direct financial reward whatsoever to LE for civil seizures.
Incentive to seize property must be untethered from those whose job is to support order and reduce conflict.
It'd be pretty unjust if someone who's saved long and hard to buy their own car got it taken away, but trust fund kids driving daddy's BMW received a lesser punishment.
> "You're asking one drunk person to determine whether another person is fit to drive. That's absurd," said attorney Chuck Ramsay.
No, it's not. Just assume they aren't. What's the alternative? Merrily lend your car to someone who might be drunk, and not bear any consequences?