News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by jamroom on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @01:29PM (#24344289)
Oh man - the same here with me - when I first got Morrowind there was an option you could enable in ATI (now AMD) cards at the time that made water look "real". I was able to enable that and was blown away - I was like "well that's it - doesn't get any more real than this". Having loaded Morrowind recently I could not believe had bad it looked lol. Makes me wonder - what are we "not" seeing right now that will make us think this way 10-20 years from now?
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by formerly_proven on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @01:56PM (#24344666)
Hm. Many people here share their sentiments of perceiving older games (or current games) as being close to photorealistic. Personally it never felt that way to me. All games have obvious problems where they don't behave/look anywhere close to reality. If you remove the interactive element and only use somewhat massaged screenshots, then, sure certain elements are basically photorealistic and have been for a while. For example, landscapes look pretty darn realistic. Anything alive or even most man-made artefacts, not so much.

Apart from graphics most stuff in games is pretty rough. Animations are generally bad and ways before reaching the uncanny valley of "getting close"; they're still in the "abstract representation of concept" detail level. AI is dumb (largely for [perceived] player-acceptance reasons). Sound is generally poor; some games still don't use 3D sound. Physics are "abstract representation" level again, some games still have fly-through walls and vibrating items. etc. etc.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by foxdev on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @04:31PM (#24346693)
I was always so confused by people saying the latest games were realistic. They looked so horrible. Maybe it's because my point of comparison was Nintendo games where they focused more on art direction than polygon count. I read an interview with someone who worked with Shigeru Miyamoto and they talked about how he would come back with changes to specific leaves and rocks after spending time exploring a cave or forest. The attention to detail, no matter how low-poly and simply-textured, made all the difference.

This hasn't changed. New "realistic" games still range from horrible to boring-looking. I don't know if it's collective delusion or if I'm missing something.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by WillPostForFood on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @06:47PM (#24348018)
The new Microsoft Flight Sim goes for realism, and often achieves beauty.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=isvWpUXgKgM

Take this as a compliment, not a criticism when I say you've rigged your proposition by holding up Nintendo first party games, and Shigeru Miyamoto for comparison. If you were to look back at he average Nintendo game, not made by Nintendo, they are mostly unremarkable.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E7ymWKnkAxM

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by foxdev on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @06:58PM (#24348101)
I should have specified first party. There were some third party games I liked, but few paid as much attention to style and detail. It's hard and expensive to get both realism and style right. I don't think it's a coincidence that most games I like for the art direction come from small indie studios who never had a shot at competing on realism.
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by KaoruAoiShiho on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:07PM (#24344806)
Yeah... these comments are kinda weird. Hate to say it but maybe they should go outside more lol, computer graphics always looked pretty bad at me, even the clips in today's nvidia presentation looks really unnatural. That's not to take anything away from the technology and the massive advances it represents, just compared to reality it's still really far from fooling a human brain.
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by wiz21c on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:16PM (#24345766)
interestingly many of us feel that there's a huge gap between the past and now. But how many of us can actually verbalize what will change in the rendering of pictures in, say 3 years.

For example, I can clearly see that ray tracing produces better results. But it's a bit harder to tell how better it is, to find the words that describes how better it is. Of course, one can say that, for example, photon tracing is more physically accurate. But still, what words can we use to describe how real (or not real) a still image is ("more realistic" doesn't count :-))

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by bonoboTP on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:40PM (#24346078)
Game graphics look sterile, too clean, sharp, plasticky. The real world is messier with less clear separation between objects, things blend together more, subtle shadows, surfaces are less uniform, there is more clutter, dirt, wrinkles, details.
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by nightski on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @04:31PM (#24346698)
Is that an artifact of the graphics capability? Or the art style? I think the two often get confused and many games are specifically designed for a sterile/clean look.
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by bonoboTP on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @05:29PM (#24347309)
Not sure. It's hard to analyze as it's more of a visceral impression. It could be in part the way natural environments tend to structure themselves over time, like how we throw our stuff around in natural ways.

But also, the design often adapts to the capabilities. Games like GTA3 used to have thick fog just to hide the fact that they couldn't render stuff far away in time. You can say that's an artistic choice to give a smoggy big city atmosphere, but clearly it was a practical choice as well. Even today, game designers like to make things dark, blurry and rainy, so that the un-realism becomes less obvious.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by formerly_proven on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:44PM (#24346122)
In games and animations, everything is textured, but few things actually have a texture to them :)
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by Nursie on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:32PM (#24345990)
To me the "marbles" RT demo looked amazingly real.

The rest, not so much, sure.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by Retric on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:53PM (#24346261)
Just watched the RT demo video and the paintbrushes for example look amazingly bad. All surfaces look flat for a better word, most noticeable it’s sterile without dust. The steam blasts are terrible as they miss all the internal swirling you get from actual vapor. They cover most of this up by moving stuff around and adding clutter which tries to keep you from really focusing on anything.

It’s basically using the same technique as hand drawn animation where as long as you realize what’s being represented you can automatically fill in missing details. However, this fails as soon as you focus on any one detail.

Honestly, it’s not bad for what it is. I mean the physics engine was probably the worst part, but as a visual demo that’s fine.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by freeflight on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @01:42AM (#24350320)
> For example, landscapes look pretty darn realistic. Anything alive or even most man-made artefacts, not so much.

Which is something really obvious with the PS5 UE 5 tech demo [0]. The environment looks great and very realistic, while the character is very stylized and looks more like a comic than realistic.

[0] https://youtu.be/d8B1LNrBpqc

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by deaddodo on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @04:15PM (#24346490)
Yeah, I never understood these comments. I went from the 8-bit generation on up and never thought PSX/Saturn/n64 games looked “real”; just better and more options than before. I don’t think I ever considered a game “realistic” until the mid-late 00’s.
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by lacker on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:05PM (#24345610)
The biggest thing to me is that video games do not have very many independent objects, compared to reality. Go outside and look at the real world and you will see the ground has little pebbles and bits of mud and all this stuff that gets kicked around. No video game will let you inspect the leaves of plants to look for little bugs, the way reality will. Or for indoor scenes, there is no video game that accurately captures the experience of "picking up a living room with a bunch of toys strewn about".
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by outworlder on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @05:34PM (#24347374)
> Go outside and look at the real world and you will see the ground has little pebbles and bits of mud and all this stuff that gets kicked around

We are getting better. Like snow deformation in RDR2, for instance(works even in a PS4).

But random bits of debris that can get kicked around - and subsequently inspected - no. That's a problem.

> No video game will let you inspect the leaves of plants to look for little bugs, the way reality will

That's an easier problem than tracking all the debris. Before you inspect, you have no idea what will be there - the computer also doesn't have to and it can be optimized away until there's an observer.

Think heisenberg uncertainty principle but for virtual worlds.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by lacker on Thursday September 03, 2020 @11:44AM (#24365152)
Yes, I actually thought of the snow in RDR2 as I wrote that comment! The beginning of RDR2 with the deep snow is one of the most impressive visual scenes in a video games so far, visually, to me.

You could implement little bugs without all that much trouble, true. Maybe a better way for me to think about it is more like, the real world has an incredible diversity of appearances at a small scale, that's hard to reproduce in a video game. The bug isn't the part that causes trouble, it's the fact that every leaf looks different, some leaves are oddly discolored, some leaves have bug bites on them, some got a little torn up, et cetera.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by Mossly on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @06:57AM (#24351963)
Level of detail and foveated rendering work on this principle.
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by Shorel on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @04:44PM (#24346854)
That would require programming lots and lots of procedural generation algorithms, one for each kind of thing.

Sounds like a fun project for the next generations. Something to play when I am older.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by perseusmandate on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @06:32PM (#24347893)
Procedural generation for plants is actually pretty common already Most trees you see in video games are from middleware like Realtree
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by Shorel on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @07:12PM (#24348203)
That's just one procedural generation algorithm.

Now suppose I want to take some fruit from the trees. And I want to slice and dice the different fruits. Peeling the skins when appropriate.

Or I want to plant a new tree. Or I want to remove it, with say, a lightsaber.

That's a couple generators more. Now add birds, dogs, insects, moss, moist surfaces, and so on. Hence, my point on needing several generators.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by BeKindAndLearn on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @10:22PM (#24349416)
I mean, fine if you want to make an actual virtual world. But when it comes down to it, it's a video game. Why in the world would any of this be in COD or Battlefield or Fallout? It would take more time than making the actual game part of it to do this pointless garbage that nobody would care about and consume the majority of computer resources. Not to mention a lot of video games remove realistic aspects that would otherwise make it a chore to play.

There are lots of things to be improved in games, but what you're describing are improvements to a real life simulation.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by fock on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @06:26AM (#24351790)
And so you start to wonder, why you should buy a new version of COD, Battlefield or Fallout? Because it uses more energy and you need a new GPU then?
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by makapuf on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:11PM (#24345690)
> No video game will let you inspect the leaves of plants to look for little bugs, the way reality will.

Why not? With procedural generation and LOD rendering it's not impossible. Not that it's easy, but not impossible?

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by bonoboTP on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:33PM (#24345998)
Presumably you're not a native English speaker. "will" here does not refer to the future, this is a subtle grammatical thing that I can't explain well, but it refers to presently existing games.
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by cyberlurker on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @04:29PM (#24346675)
Still, there is no reason I can think of that the game described couldn’t be created right now besides it not being a very fun/Marketable game.
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by bonoboTP on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @05:32PM (#24347340)
But that's theoretical, the point is more how current games actually look, not what people could make potentially with today's tech.

Also, some games are intentionally cartoonish as an artistic choice so photorealism isn't always the goal.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by bobthepanda on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @04:23PM (#24346605)
Everything has a cost, either computational or human.

We've probably reached the point where human cost exceeds computational cost, which is to say that developing and QA testing such a feature would probably cost more money than it's worth. How many users of software would gain from such minutiae?

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by jakear on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @06:08PM (#24347716)
As someone who is most definitely not a gamer but with coworkers and friends that get big into high cost gaming systems, here’s where I see the biggest deltas between real life and the screen:

- Hair. Up until very recently hair was downright awful. Nowadays it’s acceptable-ish, but there’s still lots of room for improvement, in particular in natural motion of long hair.

- Water. I spend a big chunk of my time on the water, so I’m probably more attuned to how it moves than most. Games just don’t have it down. In particular, I think a lot could be gained by embracing it’s fractal nature: in my experience, at every human scale (mm to dam and everything in between) very similar wave patterns exist, but games tend to have just a small fixed number of “wave-layers” at various scales stacked together.

- Clouds. I can easily spend hours just observing clouds, looking at things like their shape, overall motion, internal motion, composition, edge behaviors, etc, and how they change over time. Game clouds are lacking in all these regards, particularly the time-sensitive nature of a cloud.

- Foliage. In games I’ve seen, individual plants/etc. in isolation generally look really quite decent. But the second an physical object interacts with them, they very clearly don’t respond in the right ways. There’s a lot about how branches bend and leaves rustle and more that is lost. Additionally, in groups of plants it’s often clear that some small number of models are being reused, possibly with some generated randomness added. But the variety doesn’t come close to matching what one would really see.

- Human faces and expressions. These are generally really bad, especially in normal gameplay (cut-scenes are sometimes better)

Again, this is probably all just really weird stuff I notice because I spend the vast majority of my time outdoors and only see “HiFi” games being played very infrequently. I don’t think games are worse for not implementing these, but I am very interested in what they’ll look like 10-20 years down the road.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by Polylactic_acid on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @07:26PM (#24348308)
I think these days it mostly comes down to human effort in development and not hardware limitations. You could spend hundreds of hours modelling faces or putting accurate physics on a fern but it doesn't add too much to the game and costs too much to develop.

What I think will be a huge boost is proper raytracing. You can see animated movies and blender renders look stunning but they take minutes per frame.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by jakear on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @07:49PM (#24348480)
Right, like I said I don’t think a game needs to be lifelike to be good, but I also don’t think any are. 10-20 years out, who knows.
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by renjimen on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @09:19PM (#24349063)
A good list, though I think human faces and general animation are okay when you compare with foliage, which is downright awful. A lot of the improvement in human features has to do with motion capture and 3D scanning, but getting transitions between movements is where progress needs to be made.

Foliage seems like something that will be difficult to get realistic for any close inspect, at least from a layperson's point of view.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by vimy on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @07:24PM (#24348288)
Regarding clouds, have you seen videos of Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020?
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by int_19h on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @01:47PM (#24344523)
It was one of the first prominent uses of pixel shaders in the game, coinciding with NVidia (not ATI) releasing GeForce models that supported them.

It was so noticeable because it was such a huge increase in quality compared to what passed for water in games before - usually some kind of blue-grey translucent texture. For the first time, pixel shaders produced water that was clearly an attempt to imitate water IRL, not the cartoonish representation of it.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by 0xffff2 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @06:50PM (#24348048)
>Makes me wonder - what are we "not" seeing right now that will make us think this way 10-20 years from now?

My vote would be cloth simulation and clothing clipping. I've yet to see a game that comes even close to doing this realistically. Imagine what happens to your sleeves when you lift your arms above your head for example, or how the plates of a suit of armor naturally slide over each other. In every game I can think of, clothing is rigidly attached to the underlying skeleton and it just stretches/clips as the character moves.

I guess fidelity of everything else has gotten much better, because I recently started noticing this and now I find it very distracting in any game that has in-engine cut scenes involving character closeups.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by pvg on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @01:41PM (#24344446)
Maybe the water stood out since Morrowind was an ugly game even in its day. All the Elder Scrolls games have a well-earned reputation of looking like they're populated by cardboard mutants. Reminds me a bit of the old Infocom ad:

http://www.retroadv.it/images/03082019/Home_Computer_Magazin...

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by int_19h on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @01:48PM (#24344541)
Morrowind was complicated. The characters were ugly, and animations especially horrible. But the landscapes were considered very beautiful by the standards of the day.
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by Budabellly on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:27PM (#24345069)
For me, it's fidelity of human facial animation that has a long way to come. There are teams doing a great job of it [1], but the labor/skill required to bring one high hyperreal facial rig to a game or movie seems insane. I think companies pursuing AR/VR applications will lead here.

ML creative tools stand to automate a lot of this imo.

[1] random example: https://snapperstech.com/

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by johnwheeler on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @01:30PM (#24344306)
> "well that's it - doesn't get any more real than this"

> Makes me wonder - what are we "not" seeing right now that will make us think this way 10-20 years from now?

Yes - well said. That's what I was trying to convey in my comment.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by lwansbrough on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @01:45PM (#24344501)
I think Epic’s UE5 demo is really really close to reality in terms of lighting and geometry. Next 10-20 years will probably see the same technology being brought into larger and larger environments with more moving parts.

Then there’s the more obvious stuff that isn’t done well even today: skeletal animation is still lacking and feels unnatural, physics systems are still very approximate and constrained - often times most things are indestructible in games, fluid dynamics are still very slow/limited. Human models still don’t look real though, and the voice acting never quite matches the mouth movement or body language.

I do really feel like we’ve crossed the uncanny valley when it comes to natural scenery rendering. But a lot of what makes things feel real are still missing from games.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by heipei on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @01:58PM (#24344697)
I agree, it's so close that it's actually being used as an interactive movie background with a big-ass 360-degree screen for dynamic scene and lighting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hjb-AqMD-a4
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by formerly_proven on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:30PM (#24345105)
IMHO it looks fake. The lighting is way off, it quite literally looks like they're standing directly below a big diffuser - which they are. The background looks like a poster with one of these diffraction parallax effects.

It's very cool tech. But it doesn't look real.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by jiggawatts on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @06:40PM (#24347950)
The camera angles in that demo were off axis.

Take a look at The Mandalorian series, almost all of the outdoor scenes were shot using the video wall technology.

I've worked in computer graphics and I didn't realise the sets were fake until after I finished the whole series.

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by manigandham on Thursday September 03, 2020 @04:01AM (#24361790)
The behind-the-scenes context is making it visible to you, but you've probably already seen films and TV using it without even noticing.
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by Yajirobe on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @05:25PM (#24347267)
> Makes me wonder - what are we "not" seeing right now that will make us think this way 10-20 years from now?

How about ray tracing?. If we get real-time 60fps+ ray-traced computer graphics in games, that would blow what we have now out of the water

Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by noja on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @01:45PM (#24344497)
When you compared it recently did you use the same monitor, cable (analog or digital), and resolution?
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by outworlder on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @05:31PM (#24347330)
YES! Morrowind was my 'shader benchmark' for some time.
Re:Nvidia Unveils GeForce RTX 30 Series GPUs by 0-_-0 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @07:48PM (#24348469)
Game physics are still absolutely horrible