And indeed this is the entire point of the common law: to provide independent decisions, according to rules, in order to settle disputes without violence.
Endless appeals don't always work either -- you actually need a legal reason to appeal beyond "I disliked the decision". You need something like "The judge was wrong on points of law X, Y and Z" and you need the appellate court to agree that there might be something to review.
Most appellate courts look pretty dimly on appealing for the sake of appealing. Plus their time is limited, so they will tend to pick cases with broader legal consequences that will impact more than the disputants.
When purchasing private securities via any mechanism the purchasing party should to due diligence to ensure they are receiving fair value for it. I think they have a latin phrase for this something like 'caveat emptor'.
That the Winklevosses have this much money, that many connections, and manage to get themselves duped by the same guy is impressive.
If so, then justice has been served. Again, I don't know the details, so if that's the case, I'd hope the judge would actually state that even in the light of any new evidence their damages have already been covered in full. Exclaiming that there's simply an end to litigation seems to imply that justice hasn't been served, but we don't want to bother with it anymore.
Also, IIRC Facebook didn't withhold information from the court, they withheld information during a settlement negotiation. When purchasing private securities via any mechanism the purchasing party should to due diligence to ensure they are receiving fair value for it. I think they have a latin phrase for this something like 'caveat emptor'.
There are laws around disclosure of information for private securities. Maybe none of those laws were broken or didn't apply. But that seems like a reasonable question for the courts. I hope the judge actually weighed this and didn't simply toss it because he thought he had more pressing matters.
Judges don't like being appealed against, so as a rule they will treat every argument made before them when rendering judgement. Otherwise they leave an opening for an appeal on the basis that certain arguments weren't settled.
This coupled with the recent Supreme Court ruling that prosecutors effectively can't be held accountable for hiding evidence that would exonerate a defendent -- seems to be saying that your best strategy in the legal system is to illegally withhold information, because the legal system will eventually not care, even if the actors in the case still do.