Re:Court says Winklevoss twins must accept Facebook deal
by jacques_chester on Monday April 11, 2011 @06:21PM
(#2434689)
> If the two sides agreed on what constituted justice, there wouldn't be a court case.
And indeed this is the entire point of the common law: to provide independent decisions, according to rules, in order to settle disputes without violence.
Endless appeals don't always work either -- you actually need a legal reason to appeal beyond "I disliked the decision". You need something like "The judge was wrong on points of law X, Y and Z" and you need the appellate court to agree that there might be something to review.
Most appellate courts look pretty dimly on appealing for the sake of appealing. Plus their time is limited, so they will tend to pick cases with broader legal consequences that will impact more than the disputants.
And indeed this is the entire point of the common law: to provide independent decisions, according to rules, in order to settle disputes without violence.
Endless appeals don't always work either -- you actually need a legal reason to appeal beyond "I disliked the decision". You need something like "The judge was wrong on points of law X, Y and Z" and you need the appellate court to agree that there might be something to review.
Most appellate courts look pretty dimly on appealing for the sake of appealing. Plus their time is limited, so they will tend to pick cases with broader legal consequences that will impact more than the disputants.