News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To the young brilliant minds by yummyfajitas on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:06PM (#2433551)
Health care is expensive, limited, and must be rationed. Not everyone can have as much as they want. There simply is not enough to go around. In the US, this rationing process is done by price, and by insurance companies. In other countries, this is done by govt bureaucrats.

No rationing system can change this fundamental fact: some people will die because we don't have the resources to save them.

I don't know why the author can't believe it has come to this in the US. Does he feel that the laws of scarcity should not apply, simply by virtue of American Exceptionalism?

Re:To the young brilliant minds by rdtsc on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:21PM (#2433623)
> No rationing system can change this fundamental fact: some people will die because we don't have the resources to save them.

Don't agree. If access is free then a lot of preventative care can be done in order to not have to conduct expensive critical and emergency procedures.

People in this country don't go to the doctor because they may or may not end up owing sums of money ranging from $0 to many hundreds of thousands, depending on the combination of provider, doctor, insurance policy, state and federal laws. So people just stay away. Until they have a heart attack, or cancer is in the terminal stages then they are rushed to emergency and then guess what happens -- a very expensive procedure probably needs to be perfomed. So not very surprising that health care is expensive.

But let's take from another point of view. You say it is expensive. But how come Scandinavian and many European countries manage do provide it? Could it be that we just spend everything on defense (well...I personally called it offense but let's keep it official here) -- more than all the countries in the world combined? Do our doctors and medical supplies companies charge insane prices? I don't know the answer, but I know it has been done in other countries, and it is currently better than here. So it seems like it is possible.

Re:To the young brilliant minds by retree on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:37PM (#2433712)
But how come Scandinavian and many European countries manage do provide it?

The simple answer is we don't.

England has a body called NICE (National Institute for Health and Clinical Evidence) who assess each and every treatment. They're a body of experts who look at all the evidence on a particular treatment and work out how much it will cost and how much of an improvement it will bring to a persons life. It it doesn't reach a certain threshold - measured in cost per QUALYs (quality adjusted life years) - the government won't pay.

It comes in for criticism every so often (usually when it won't fund a new, very expensive cancer drug) but in the physicians (and government's) eyes it does a very good job for something so hard.

Re:To the young brilliant minds by abyssknight on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @10:03AM (#2462623)
This. I was born in the UK, and I still have family there. They all have private insurance for this very reason.
Re:To the young brilliant minds by yummyfajitas on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:30PM (#2433681)
Don't agree. If access is free then a lot of preventative care can be done in order to not have to conduct expensive critical and emergency procedures.

Preventative care also consumes resources. A doctor can only perform 8-10 hours worked / (duration of preventative procedure) preventative procedures per day. The number of doctors is limited. Thus, the number of preventative procedures is limited.

You might be right that the US is currently not at the optimum. Insurance companies try very hard to find a better optimum - they stand to gain millions if they can find it. But that doesn't change the fact that doctor hours are limited.

The OP didn't say that the US had a suboptimal system relative to some other. He merely criticized the fact that medical care is a scarce resource and we can't all have as much as we want.

But how come Scandinavian and many European countries manage do provide it?

Scandinavian and European countries provide unlimited medicine to whoever wants it? That's news to me. Do you have evidence for this?

Also, if Scandinavia and Europe have reached the singularity, and now live in a post-scarcity world, how come they are still poorer than the US? How is it possible that their singularity only works for medicine?

...it has been done in other countries, and it is currently better than here.

Do you have evidence for this? So far, in spite of asking this many times, I see very little that is convincing. All I see are life expectancy gaps comparable to the life expectancy gap between people who eat leafy green vegetables and those who don't, and studies from the WHO that give more weight to inequality of marginal costs than to actual medical care provided.

Re:To the young brilliant minds by loire280 on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:49PM (#2433790)
Preventative care also consumes resources. A doctor can only perform 8-10 hours worked / (duration of preventative procedure) preventative procedures per day. The number of doctors is limited. Thus, the number of preventative procedures is limited.

Maybe doctors shouldn't be doing preventative care. Surely you don't need a Ph.D in medicine to perform and interpret blood tests, monitor blood pressure, take some measurements, and conduct an interview. If there are serious symptoms or something that doesn't respond properly to changes in diet, exercise, or simple medication, escalate to a doctor.

Specially trained nurses could be filling these roles much more cheaply, freeing up doctors' time for activities that require their training and experience.

Re:To the young brilliant minds by warrenwilkinson on Monday April 11, 2011 @03:52PM (#2434103)
I agree. The only thing standing in the way is state licensing. The AMA lobbied for medical practitioner licensing in the earlier 1900s on the grounds that they would set high standards for future doctors. The end result was different:

"The licensing boards in each state soon began refusing licenses to health professionals who had not been trained at one of the 'approved' medical schools. Only half of the existing medical schools were approved, so most of the others had to close their doors by 1920. By 1932, almost half the medical school applicants had to be turned away. Those who apprenticed, went to unapproved schools, or developed their own therapies were stopped- at gunpoint, if necessary- from healing. As a result, the number of medical doctors per 100,000 people dropped from 157 in 1900 to 125 by 1929. Specialists, such as midwives, were usually forbidden to practice unless they had a full-fledged medical degree."

Source: http://www.ruwart.com/Healing/chap5.html

Re:To the young brilliant minds by rdtsc on Monday April 11, 2011 @03:29PM (#2433991)
> Scandinavian and European countries provide unlimited medicine to whoever wants it?

I didn't say that. I just pointed out that they have free public health care and to me it seems they are spending less and are a healthier country. Now yes, I don't have hard evidence for you but is just my general impression. The point was that it is possible in theory and in practice to provide it.

> how come they are still poorer than the US?

Disagree with that. Look at the income distribution across the population. Look at other social indicators not just GDP. What is the life expectancy, crime, general health, and happiness of the population.

> I see very little that is convincing.

Sorry. It is just my personal oponion and impressions. Take it for what it's worth (probably nothing for you). Maybe someone else has a pointer to some hard data...

Re:To the young brilliant minds by alextgordon on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:52PM (#2433805)
Scandinavian and European countries provide unlimited medicine to whoever wants it? That's news to me. Do you have evidence for this?

This is a straw man. Nobody is claiming that Scandinavian (or any countries) provide "unlimited" heathcare. Only that they distribute it more effectively to a larger proportion of the population.

Re:To the young brilliant minds by yummyfajitas on Monday April 11, 2011 @03:04PM (#2433865)
From the post I was responding to:

> No rationing system can change this fundamental fact: some people will die because we don't have the resources to save them.

Don't agree. If access is free then a lot of preventative care...

If you want to argue that Scandinavia distributes health care more effectively, make that argument. The OP doesn't. It merely complains about scarcity.

Re:To the young brilliant minds by mdemare on Monday April 11, 2011 @03:05PM (#2433874)
Norway, Denmark and Sweden are all richer (per capita) than the U.S. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nomin...).
Re:To the young brilliant minds by yummyfajitas on Monday April 11, 2011 @03:11PM (#2433902)
I should have been more careful with the term "rich". Most of those countries are a lot more expensive than the US, so the higher nominal GDP doesn't buy you anywhere near as much as it does in the US.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_...

You are right about Norway, however. (Luxembourg is also substantially richer.)

Re:To the young brilliant minds by johngalt on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:46PM (#2433771)
The preventitive care thing, sounds a little soundbite-ish to me. Most people have health insurance that covers preventitive care. There may be some people that just prefer not to go to the doctor, but that's more of a cultural thing than a purely rational economic decision. People do preventitive maintenance on their cars, even though insurance doesn't cover it.

Bottom line, if we provided preventative care only up to a certain low ceiling. You'd call it good? Everyone else can die? Or does everyone need all encompassing care?

Re:To the young brilliant minds by silvestrov on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:42PM (#2433747)
In other countries it is very often done by doctors.

Denmark has recently had a big "scandal" because doctors used "codes" in the patients journal when the patient should not receive emergency care if they had e.g. a heart attack while at the hospital. They doctors added this code when such care would kill the patient anyway because the patient was too weak to survive such intensive treatment.

In the end, the "super secret code" was just the phone number of the intensive care unit, with a minus sign in front of it, meaning "don't call the unit if this patient has a heart attack".

Re:To the young brilliant minds by stellar678 on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:19PM (#2433613)
It's really not so black and white:

1. The laws of scarcity don't dictate how a scarce resource is distributed. I guess the argument is all about what the most effective means are to distribute this resource.

2. Anyhow, commercial enterprises have strong incentives to produce artificial scarcity. The "laws" of scarcity don't have to apply here.

Re:To the young brilliant minds by rick888 on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:23PM (#2433631)
The "laws" of scarcity don't have to apply here.

The laws don't necessarily apply to digital goods, because we can make infinite copies. However, Space, time, hospitals, and doctors are limited...so these laws apply.

Re:To the young brilliant minds by stellar678 on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:35PM (#2433703)
Sure, but they're also not 100% efficiently utilized. Far from it. And the argument is that profit motive in health care may actually drive "efficiency of utilization" the opposite direction. When one person is staying at home with chest pain, afraid of the ER bill, while another person shows up with a soar throat and a headache because they have health insurance, well...that's pretty clearly misdirected utilization of the scarce resources.
Re:To the young brilliant minds by billjings on Monday April 11, 2011 @04:10PM (#2434166)
There are perverse effects in the market which make health care more expensive than it needs to be, and there are advantages to universal coverage. Atul Gawande's piece on McAllen, Texas is recommended every time this subject comes up, as well it should be. It is also enlightening to read up on and understand the major moving parts of the recent health care reform bill - namely, 1) the universal mandate/subsidies, 2) coverage requirement and pricing reform, and 3) health insurance exchanges. Each has a reason to exist, and it's hard to make it work without the others.

Health care is not a widget. It is not a resource. It is a service, a service that directly affects the quality of life of your average citizen, that directly affects how well put together your work force is, that directly affects the likelihood that you or your business will be pushed around by something completely beyond your control.

We are currently running that service extremely inefficiently.

Re:To the young brilliant minds by Adam503 on Monday April 11, 2011 @05:07PM (#2434381)
Rubbish.

America is the only country in the Western World paying these astronomical prices. The only reason health care is so expensive in the US is because "for-profit" health care costs twice as much as single payer heath care.

Re:To the young brilliant minds by michaelochurch on Monday April 11, 2011 @03:42PM (#2434048)
some people will die because we don't have the resources to save them.

Except for organs, which are "rationed" by transplant committees of doctors and not health-insurance scumbags, I don't think this is true. And if it is true, health-insurance executives need to be the first ones to go.

Also, yes, the American health care system is terrible. It's not only unfair, but it's extremely expensive and just doesn't work very well. Even upper-middle-class people would be better off under a European-style system. You're mean-spirited or an idiot if you think American-style health coverage is a good thing.

Re:To the young brilliant minds by mdemare on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:53PM (#2433810)
I think you're too facile in comparing health care with economic goods such as crude oil, for which the laws of scarcity ordinarily apply. Compare this statement:

"Chemotherapy is expensive, limited, and must be rationed. Not everyone can have as much as they want. There simply is not enough to go around." Certainly this sounds silly to your ears?

If you were to say that some treatments are very expensive, and must be rationed, then I'd agree with you. But I believe that there are many treatments that our society can afford to offer to anyone who needs them, without rationing.