News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by CydeWeys on Monday August 31, 2020 @03:25PM (#24335069)
It also gives a great sense of your own power (which is very important to protest movements) in marching along and shutting down a freeway, which you could never in any other situation just calmly walk down the middle of. Critical Mass is invigorating for the same reasons.
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by austincheney on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:24PM (#24338249)
As a commuter nothing would turn me against the protestors goals faster than clogging a freeway. I have a long and frustrating commute and the idea of that commute becoming a multi hour trapped parking adventure after a long day doing a job that is agonizingly depressing is quite souring.

The experience is so decidedly wonderful that if, for example, the protest were a Black Lives Matter movement I would change from a whole hearted support to complete opposition in every objective they promote.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by conro1108 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @12:46AM (#24338643)
If interrupting your commute is enough to turn you to "complete opposition in every objective they promote," I have a hard time believing you were ever a whole-hearted supporter.
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by austincheney on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:13AM (#24339019)
That sounds like a problem with empathy.
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by ashtonkem on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:02AM (#24338982)
Protests aren’t supposed to be convenient for the uninvolved. They’re literally designed to force you to pay attention.
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by austincheney on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:21AM (#24339047)
I read that as designed for angst and animosity not influence, because the intention completely disparages the audience.
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by piva00 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @04:48AM (#24339725)
So protests are ok while they don't inconvenience you?

I don't understand what is your point here, protests are supposed to be disruptive, disparaging the audience is not by design, if you feel that way then you don't really believe in the value of the protest, no?

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by austincheney on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @05:30AM (#24339939)
Its like yelling at a customer and slashing their tires only to be confused why that customer doesn't wish to continue being your customer. Then blaming the customer for their lack of commitment and being somehow dumbfounded by their change of opinion.
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by potatoz2 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @11:46PM (#24349793)
That's an extremely poor comparison: you are not a customer, you are a co-equal citizen.
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by austincheney on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @01:40PM (#24355680)
If that were true we wouldn't need crowds to impose influence. Any one individual would be enough to influence any one other individual on the merits of the argument, but that's not how most people operate. Any attempt to influence is a sell no different than selling a hand bag.
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by ashtonkem on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:39AM (#24339122)
You might disagree with it as a tactic, but I'm not sure how you got to the idea that it's designed for animosity and not influence. Can you read the minds and intentions of the protestors? How would you know?
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by austincheney on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @04:04AM (#24339540)
As the delayed driver, the audience, I know absolutely how I would feel. This is the perception.
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by ashtonkem on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @10:05AM (#24341817)
Which is completely different.

You do understand how what you perceive and what they intend are different things, right? And that jumping from "it is inconvenient for me" to "they only intend to cause me harm" is a serious leap.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by austincheney on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @10:27AM (#24342071)
> You do understand how what you perceive and what they intend are different things, right?

If the protestors are utterly incapable of bridging that gap it doesn't matter what their intentions are as they are failing to win hearts and minds. That leap you speak to is only a minor baby step. If they really wanted to convince me of the value of their message they could start by not intentionally pissing me off.

This isn't rocket science. This complete lack of common sense on behalf of the protestors typically indicates youth. Everybody else has since either developed a few drops of empathy or moved on to anything more self-indulgent.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by ashtonkem on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @10:36AM (#24342201)
> That leap you speak to is only a minor baby step.

It absolutely is not a baby step. In fact it is a really big deal to jump from your own experience to assuming the intent of other people. That is actually a really fast way to anger people in my experience, because it requires that you pretend that you understand what is going on in another person's head. Saying "your actions caused X" is pretty straightforward, but "you intended to cause X" or "you intended to cause X and X alone" requires mind reading ability on your part.

Again, you can disagree with it as a tactic, I genuinely do not care about that. What bothers me is that you're unilaterally asserting that you personally understand the intention of the protestors, which is quite the assertion, and one that you have only backed up by "this is how I feel about it".

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by CydeWeys on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @11:35AM (#24342920)
And even if he personally is turned off the issue at hand because he experiences some personal convenience, so what? He's not the target audience of the protests, just collateral "damage" (if you can even call it that). Government officials and all the millions of people reached by news media coverage of the protests are the real target audience. And you can't deny that it's working; year-on-year nationwide opinion polls show an astounding reversal from majority disapproval of the Black Lives Matter movement to majority approval. It's been the most successful modern protest movement going possibly all the way back to the 70s.

So who fucking cares if some people got stuck in traffic. The protests are working, and the people who weren't even stuck in traffic but are complaining anyway because they hypothetically could have been (like this guy) should just be roundly ignored. Listening to their opinions is a terrible idea if your actual intent is to further the movement.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by austincheney on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @11:32AM (#24342882)
> It absolutely is not a baby step. In fact it is a really big deal to jump from your own experience to assuming the intent of other people. That is actually a really fast way to anger people in my experience, because it requires that you pretend that you understand what is going on in another person's head.

That is not correct. If you are blocking a freeway causing hours of traffic delays then I am not making assumptions about what's in somebody else's head. I don't care what their intentions are. They have made me disgruntled and digusted with their protest message completely alienating me from their cause. From that moment forward I would vote against and fund in opposition to everything they advocate.

As the audience all that matters is what's in my head, which I don't have to guess at. The inability for people to accept that reality tells me the things they are protesting about aren't important to them.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by biaachmonkie on Thursday September 10, 2020 @07:01PM (#24437476)
> From that moment forward I would vote against and fund in opposition to everything they advocate.

So given the protests in the U.S.recently have been about the treatment of minorities by the Police specifically the killing and abuse of black people. Are you saying that if you were to be stopped in traffic due to a such a protest you would then support, fund, and vote for more Police abuse and killing of black people? Is that really what you're saying?

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by ashtonkem on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @11:47AM (#24343060)
That’s literally a different argument. You’ve moved from “they’re intending to cause harm to people like me” to “I believe this tactic alienates people like me”.

As I’ve said repeatedly, the latter is an argument about the efficacy of this type of protest. You’re free to believe that, I don’t care. But understand that “it doesn’t work” is a completely unrelated argument from “its intended to do X”.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by CydeWeys on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @11:40AM (#24342983)
The protests are working. It doesn't matter if you hypothetically would be pissed off about being stuck in traffic because of one, they are demonstrably working. So they absolutely continue despite your objections. See:

https://thehill.com/homenews/news/502267-support-for-black-l...

https://news.gallup.com/poll/317321/believe-protest-actions-...

I think you should take a step back and really consider why you're arguing so vociferously over hypothetically being caught in traffic because of a protest when there are much larger issues at play here.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by austincheney on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @12:05PM (#24343286)
Neither of your links mention anything related to blocking freeways. Your second link mentions that violent protests are viewed extremely negatively. Where I live blocking a freeway would be viewed similarly. As negative as the numbers in your source suggest doing that a few times would tank support for any protest movement.
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by EarthIsHome on Monday August 31, 2020 @04:56PM (#24335845)
For those curious about power and mass protests, John Berger's piece from 1968[0] provides an excellent overview on mass demonstrations.

[0]: https://www.marxists.org/history/etol/newspape/isj/1968/no03...

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by cousin_it on Monday August 31, 2020 @04:12PM (#24335452)
(Deleted: not worth it)
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by CydeWeys on Monday August 31, 2020 @04:13PM (#24335464)
What a horrid comparison to make between those crimes and a constitutionally-guaranteed right.
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by dragonwriter on Monday August 31, 2020 @04:17PM (#24335507)
Would the moral status of rape, or, say, slavery be any greater if it was written into the Constitution? (Note that one of those was, extensively, written into the Constitution.)

If not, what is the point of your argument?

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by CydeWeys on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @11:46AM (#24343037)
You're just continuing the horrid comparison of somehow equating people exercising free speech with heinous crimes. Stop it. It's not a good look nor a valid argument.

I'm not even going to waste my time explaining how free speech is different morally from rape, because I guarantee that this is crystal clear to everyone else except for you somehow.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by jariel on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:04PM (#24338140)
"a constitutionally-guaranteed right"

You absolutely don't have a right to suppress others with your ideology.

'Freedom of expression' has nothing to do with shutting down highways.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by msla on Monday August 31, 2020 @04:00PM (#24335359)
And people who need to get somewhere to save lives are suitably invigorated, I'm sure.
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by CydeWeys on Monday August 31, 2020 @04:06PM (#24335398)
Yeah, actually. I saw a huge fucking grin on the face of the guy riding shotgun in the ambulance as the crowd of cyclists parted like magic in front of them and they had a personal escort of two vested corkers. Guy was even filming. They got where they were going faster than if the usual stop and go car traffic had been there.

The great thing about people on foot or on bike is that they can easily get out of the way of emergency vehicles, vs cars and trucks which often can't.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by macintux on Monday August 31, 2020 @05:45PM (#24336239)
If you’ve created a logjam however, how does the ambulance get through the stopped traffic?

(I’m not arguing against protesting on the freeway, to be clear, just genuinely curious how often it helps vs hinders emergency vehicles.)

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by Kerrick on Monday August 31, 2020 @06:06PM (#24336378)
I've experienced this outside of protests. My wife and I were driving somewhere near downtown St. Louis, on a part of the interstate where there are tall concrete barriers between the directions of traffic. There was a complete log jam due to an accident ahead, and we heard sirens coming up from behind us to the left. We were in the left of two lanes. The right shoulder was either filled up or too small (can't remember), so people couldn't really pull right more than a foot or two to allow the ambulance through.

The ambulance didn't let that deter them. They took the foot or two we and the other left-lane drivers could give by getting REALLY close to the car to our right, and used it to careen down the left shoulder, scraping the side of their vehicle along the concrete barrier much of the way.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by sudosysgen on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:48PM (#24338354)
Damn, that's dedication. Kudos to the drivers!
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by msla on Monday August 31, 2020 @06:04PM (#24336364)
I'm not talking about emergency vehicles or people who get escorts. I'm talking about the doctors who have to make their own way in their own vehicles.
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by Dylan16807 on Monday August 31, 2020 @07:21PM (#24336893)
It's okay, the minor negative effects of that are never going to be more important than the ability to protest effectively.

Just like nobody blames normal traffic for killing people via doctor delays.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by msla on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @09:10AM (#24341364)
> Just like nobody blames normal traffic for killing people via doctor delays.

That's because normal traffic jams aren't intentional.

[dead]
[dead]
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by sudosysgen on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:56PM (#24338406)
In the future, it's considered bad form to complain if your posts are flagged. That said, I agree that it certainly wasn't bad faith to argue that in some cases the downsides of protests are worth how vital it is, and it was a very cheap shot.

FWIW, my city had 35% of its population, over half a million people, entirely fill almost every street downtown, and there were no catastrophic events. Worse comes to worst, alternative routes will need to be planned. I think the most catastrophic thing that happened is that the cellular systems crashed, but for the most part GSM still held out so it was okay, and the stores had landlines that were used when worse came to worst.

Same during the Hong Kong protests, I never saw anyone complain about such things, and indeed I don't believe it had catastrophic effects.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by jariel on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:03PM (#24338135)
"It's okay, the minor negative effects of that are never going to be more important than the ability to protest effectively."

No way. You do not have the right to arbitrarily lock down traffic for some arbitrary reason.

Wait until Trump supporters lock down traffic in LA all day because they legitimately believe the 'election was stolen'.

You can protest in the park or city square or somewhere where it doesn't stop a large number of people from going about their business.

You don't get to suppress others with your ideology.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by sudosysgen on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:50PM (#24338370)
You definitely get to supress infrastructure when you have enough people willing to protest.

I don't get it, are you trying to imply that protests should have no disruptive effect? That is a good recipe for complete political dysfunction. Civil disobedience is based upon disruption. It is our right as citizens.

Besides, if an ambulance or doctor needed to go through a protest, the vast majority of the time just asking gets them through.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by jlawson on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:44AM (#24339143)
You have a vote. Use it.

You also have a voice. Use it.

You have no right to undemocratically wield power over others by physical force. You have no right to force others to suffer to compel them to your will which they did not choose.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by sudosysgen on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @09:48AM (#24341663)
Limiting the political engagement of your citizens to only voting in a two party system is madness. When people stop being engaged, and stop voting, and your country turns to shit, I can say that I warned you.

No, seriously, this is insane. You want to, functionally, ban protests. There is absolutely no way you can have a functional country if you can't even have peaceful demonstrations.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by jlawson on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:50PM (#24346223)
Funny, I never said "only voting". I also said you have a voice, use it. You seem to have completely ignored that paragraph.

Perhaps you'd like to take a shot at actually responding to what I wrote.

It is absolutely possible to protest without hurting innocent bystanders.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by sudosysgen on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @06:05PM (#24347684)
If your standard for "hurting innocent bystanders" is to mildly inconvenience some people by causing them to seek an alternative route, then no, it's not possible to have an effective protest under that standard.

The right to protest is generally accepted to mean that people are allowed to walk in the street in an effort to be heard.

I responded to what you wrote, and your arguments fall flat. Even during massive protests with millions of people ambulances get where they need to get and doctors go where they need to go.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by jlawson on Saturday September 05, 2020 @06:32PM (#24387382)
When you're blocked on the highway, you cannot leave. You're confined. No matter how sick you are, how hungry the baby is, how hot the car is getting, how low on gas or how late you are for work.

Stop being disingenous about what you're advocating. You're advocating confining people to their cars on the highway. Including old people, little kids, sick people. To force them to listen to you.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by msla on Thursday September 10, 2020 @05:21PM (#24436701)
> If your standard for "hurting innocent bystanders" is to mildly inconvenience some people

No, the standard is potentially killing people.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by jariel on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @10:31AM (#24342142)
"You want to, functionally, ban protests."

You have a misunderstanding of what is legal, what is not, and what a peaceful protest is.

Blocking traffic is already banned.

That's 100% illegal in all cases.

'Protests' which infringe on the rights of others are just another form of fascism.

'My Fascism is Worthwhile' is not a civic or moral argument.

You can protest peacefully, vote, engage in other forms of civic obedience, but you can't do it at the expense of others, full stop.

As soon as someone starts trampling on your rights for a cause you don't agree with you'll scream 'victim' and then maybe have a different perspective.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by sudosysgen on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @01:54PM (#24344633)
Walking in the street is not fascism. This is seriously ridiculous. Are you going to claim that the Hong Kong protests, or the Climate Protests are fascists because people were walking in the streets?
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by jariel on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @01:10AM (#24338744)
"You definitely get to supress infrastructure when you have enough people willing to protest."

No - you don't.

This is illegal, and it happens only by virtue of force.

You absolutely have no right do do this - you just have he power to do it 'if you have enough people'.

So yes, if you have an aggressive mob, you can get away with illegal things, that doesn't mean it's lawful.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by Dylan16807 on Monday August 31, 2020 @11:25PM (#24338255)
> Wait until Trump supporters lock down traffic in LA all day because they legitimately believe the 'election was stolen'.

Good for them? That's a valid protest. You don't have to stay out of the way in the free speech zone. (Not to say that separation is never appropriate, but not most of the time.)

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by jariel on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @01:12AM (#24338754)
"That's a valid protest."

It's valid to protest things which are not true?

So we can block traffic in LA to raise awareness that 'Aliens are coming'?

No - absolutely not.

Your arbitrary definition of what you consider to be a 'valid protest' is not relevant.

You 100% do not have the right to block highways under any circumstances. Full stop.

You can of course, block highways if you use force to do it, i.e. by amassing such a large, unlawful group so that 'nobody can do anything about it' - which is of course illegal and completely trampling other people's basic rights.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by jacobkania on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @01:56AM (#24338958)
I firmly believe that if you have enough people who think it’s important enough to block traffic to make a point — if their belief is that aliens are coming to destroy earth — they’re allowed to do that. Sure, it’s illegal, but they’ll do it anyways. I think it’s unlikely that so many people will come together to block traffic, but if it’s so important to them, then I’m all for it. They’ll definitely get to make their argument to the news and American people, who get to decide if their point is valid or not. But that’s the point of free speech.
Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by jariel on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @10:33AM (#24342170)
I doesn't matter if you are 'all for it'.

The rest of us are 'not for it' - and that's why it's well enshrined into law.

Your pet ideology is no reason to obstruct others.

If you can convince LA County to shut down the highway for a 'march' over the 'weekend' - then that's fine.

Otherwise, fines or jail.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by jlawson on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:47AM (#24339151)
Blocking traffic is not speech, it's physical harassment whose only outcome and whose intended mechanism of effect is to inject suffering into random innocent peoples' lives.

You have no right to do that any more than you have a right to randomly slap people on the street to make them listen to you.

Use your vote and your voice.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by ashtonkem on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @02:30AM (#24339082)
> It's valid to protest things which are not true?

If you set the bar at "your point has to be true before you can protest", then goodbye free speech. Because who exactly gets to decide what is true, and therefore is legitimate to protest over? The government? The media? That is an insanely dangerous power to give any institution, which is why the first amendment is purposefully interpreted to put the minimum number of restrictions on what is forbidden.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by jariel on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @10:35AM (#24342197)
"If you set the bar at "your point has to be true before you can protest", then goodbye free speech."

This is not true at all.

These arguments are purposefully conflating 'speech and protest' with the right to block traffic and infringe on other people's rights.

You can 100% stand in front of city hall to tell us about 'Alien Invasions' if you want.

You can 100% not block traffic to do it.

You have more opportunities for expression today than at any time in history, use those 'vehicles' instead of blocking 'vehicles'.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by ashtonkem on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @10:41AM (#24342260)
That is literally a different argument though.

Now you're arguing about the difference between civil disobedience (which necessarily involves breaking norms or laws) and simple protest. This is a fair distinction, but genuinely a tedious one. Yes, standing around in the street is illegal, that's the point. We're not going to work out anything new here that hasn't been discussed over the past century.

What I'm reacting to is you setting the bar based on the content of the speech. That is super dangerous territory, one that I would strongly condemn. The moment you say that tactics become legitimate or illegitimate based on the content of the speech, which is something the highlighted quote was saying, then you're heading into the land of no more free speech.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by jariel on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @05:25PM (#24347270)
???

So you fully support anti-abortion protestors blocking the entrance to abortion clinics?

That's 'civil disobedience' and 'breaking the law' for the 'content of speech' (in their view) of 'saving lives'?

Seems pretty legit? Saving lives?

What about White Supremacists burning down 'desegregated schools' in protest of 'desegregation'?

Or some 'burning crosses' on the streets in front of the NAACP? I mean, hey, it's their right to 'protest'?

How about 'Anti-Vaxxer' protesters surrounding evil big corporate pharma research centres and not allowing anyone in or out (civil disobedience) because 'big pharma' is giving everyone autism?

Or a much more mild case: two days ago in Montreal a small group of protestors brought down a national monument, as police watched and refused to intervene.

So how many protestors do I need exactly to tear down monuments? What's the 'headcount' threshold for the Washington monument coming down? I mean, he did own slaves ...

It's not tedious to distinguish between what is illegal and what is not, it's literally at the heart of civilization.

And no - we generally don't care what your 'cause' is - if someone really wants to 'protests' for 'segregation' - that's totally fine, they can make nice placards and sit in the park.

It's incredibly naive to ignore the damage and harm caused to a lot of people in the wake of a lot of unfortunate protests which have turned violent, let alone the problems caused but otherwise more basic civil acts.

There are 1000 ways to protest, if you want to sit on the sidewalk and get dragged away, that's fine, just don't get in other people's way.

Re:Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city... by ashtonkem on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @06:31PM (#24347880)
This response is so completely unrelated to what I actually said that it’s genuinely hard to respond to. If you want to continue to discuss this matter, respond to what I said, rather than making up what I said and then arguing against it.