News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by flyinglizard on Saturday August 29, 2020 @10:41PM (#24320945)
Actual substantial longevity - beyond quality of life enhancements - is something I greatly fear. It would change everything.

Imagine life with no kids and the joy they bring, a stagnation in all societal structures, no turnover of ideas (loosely quoting "agendas don't die; people die").

I'm sure such a civilization would be very stable, but won't have any extreme sports.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by kgin on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:18PM (#24321100)
I would ask why 80 just happens to be the best lifespan for humans. If we’re optimizing for things you listed, imagine how much more child-inspired joy and new idea throughput we could get if we had kids at 18 and died at 40?

I’m still unclear on the point of life, but I’m not convinced it’s that kind of optimization exercise.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by PeterisP on Sunday August 30, 2020 @10:10AM (#24323137)
I would look at this as something where the interests of the society or species as a whole diverge from the interests of individuals.

It may be quite reasonable for someone to prefer a more dynamic society and social structures caused by an average life span of 50 years, while at the same time preferring themselves and their loved ones to live for 100+ years on average. The question of "do you want to live much longer" is not the same as "do you want everyone to live much longer"; accepting that death and "forced turnover" has some positive role in how societies function (e.g. that you can't have eternal dictators because, in the worst case, eventually they die of old age) is compatible with still wanting death to be something that happens only to someone else whom you don't know or don't like. It's hypocritical but realistic - there's no reason to assume that longevity advances will be distributed to be evenly available.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by acituan on Sunday August 30, 2020 @01:13PM (#24324198)
> I would look at this as something where the interests of the society or species as a whole diverge from the interests of individuals.

This is spot on, and exactly what is going at the genetic level.

The reason we have sexual reproduction as opposed to mere cloning ourselves is the fact that environment that the initial set of genes worked well changes over time and the genes have to continuously innovate and experiment to have a chance in adapting to the new environment. Sexual reproduction introduces this variability to build these A/B/C... tests in the form of mini niches we are constructing.

Granted, humans don't only reproduce genetically but also memetically, to borrow from Dawkins. And the memetic transmission is complicated, on one hand technology makes it trivial for ideas to spread, on the other hand 1-1 care of grandparents and parents still matter a lot for example in child development. But at the genetic level, wishing to extend life means essentially "cloning" one's genes more and more into the future.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by rantwasp on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:39PM (#24321181)
I would not fear it. Technology has the potential to make us immortal and to help us transcend out biological beginnings.

Humans that live for extended periods of time would be able to make progress and keep knowledge alive for longer periods of time facilitating an acceleration of progress made -> repeat.

You are also assuming that we fix aging but we make no progress in other domains. Would you really care how old you were if you could "download" yourself in a new replica at will? ie technology was so advanced that we would maintain our biological form only because we would like to experience things our ancestors did, not because it would be necessary.

---

Also, when people say longevity there are at least 2 things that are mingled together. One is: living longer but the other one is just improving the quality of life. So whenever you are afraid of this new future, picture people living 20% longer only, but their life quality into their 80s and 90s would be the same as a person today in their 40s.

Who would not want to have a better quality of life and instead of spending their last decades watching as their body fails and things get worse and worse?

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by d_burfoot on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:16PM (#24321085)
> Imagine life with no kids

People will still be able to have kids. In fact in many cases people will be able to have as many kids as they normally would. As long as the fertility rate is less than 2 children/woman, the total population will still converge even if no one dies. Places like South Korean have a fertility rate of 1 c/w, which would produce a mere doubling of the total population.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by 0-_-0 on Sunday August 30, 2020 @05:28AM (#24322346)
This is correct. For example: Let's say the population is P and the net reproduction rate (the number of daughters a woman has in her lifetime) is 0.9. The next generation would have 0.9P people, the next one would have 0.9², then 0.9³, etc. Even with immortality you would get lim_(i→∞)∑ᵢ0.9ⁱP = 9P. So as long as the net reproduction rate is less than one the population stabilises at a finite number even if everyone is immortal.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by yesbabyyes on Sunday August 30, 2020 @04:25AM (#24322140)
> As long as the fertility rate is less than 2 children/woman, the total population will still converge even if no one dies.

Converge to what? How?

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by ben_w on Sunday August 30, 2020 @05:21AM (#24322322)
I think they mean the infinite sequence of

Σ (generation_n)

always converges to some finite number when generation_(n+1) = k * generation_n has k < 1, which is equivalent to <2 immortal children per woman.

I don’t think that’s a good model, as people who want more offspring will out-reproduce those who don’t, but that’s an argument for another time.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by s7atic on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:01AM (#24322615)
> I don’t think that’s a good model, as people who want more offspring will out-reproduce those who don’t, but that’s an argument for another time.

This argument assumes the offspring behaves in the same way as their parents. I don't see that necessarily being true. Even if that is the case, there are legislative solutions.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by reducesuffering on Sunday August 30, 2020 @05:25AM (#24322328)
To population 0. 1.9 children / woman is a .95 multiplier on human population per generation, like a -5% interest rate. Assuming birth rate is constant < 2, it converges to 0.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by sokoloff on Sunday August 30, 2020 @01:33PM (#24324343)
Not "if no one dies" which was part of GGP's claim.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by reducesuffering on Sunday August 30, 2020 @01:46PM (#24324474)
Correct, my mistake. Other comments with summations are the accurate convergence then.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by vimy on Saturday August 29, 2020 @10:43PM (#24320950)
Why do you assume there would be no kids? How else will we populate our solar system.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by adrianN on Sunday August 30, 2020 @12:39AM (#24321411)
Eventually there would be a lot fewer kids. The new worlds we can colonize scale quadratically with the volume of space we can reach, but the number of potentially procreating humans scales cubically.

Although I'd assume that we have left our biological bodies behind before that.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by flyinglizard on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:15PM (#24321080)
I remember the times where colonizing the solar system was a means for our collective survival, not an endgame for which we irreversibly change our society.

That aside, we could populate the solar system just as well with people who live a healthy century.

It only takes a few months to get to Mars with the current technology.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by antepodius on Sunday August 30, 2020 @05:53AM (#24322420)
We could populate it equally well with people who live a healthy half-century. And think of the progress that would be possible with that sort of population turnaround!

Will you join me in making this dream come true?

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by abdullahkhalids on Sunday August 30, 2020 @03:54AM (#24322016)
I don't have to convince you or death-desirers of anything. I simply have to outlive you. (loosely quoting Cory Doctorow)
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by xwdv on Saturday August 29, 2020 @10:44PM (#24320958)
The best time to be alive is when longevity break throughs first appear. You have the advantages of experiencing the old ways of living and get to live unexpectedly longer and see the world adapt to the new normal. Fortunately that is what we are positioned for.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by hyko on Sunday August 30, 2020 @05:54AM (#24322426)
Fortunately that is what we are positioned for.

I would actually suggest that anyone reading this is likely to be too old to benefit. Thinking otherwise is completely fine, but we must acknowledge that the temptation towards motivated reasoning is unusually strong in this case.

I would also like the breakthroughs to be many centuries in the past, with all the biological and societal bugs worked out before I arrive :)

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by nynx on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:21PM (#24321117)
You're getting some downvotes, but I actually agree with this. The next ten or twenty years are going to be the most exciting so far, and then it only goes up from there.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by Vinceo on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:40PM (#24321187)
How long time do you think it's realistic that we reach longevity escape velocity? And what current longevity research do you think is the most promising?
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by xwdv on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:49PM (#24321218)
Probably about 20 years, just try to hold on until then.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by return1 on Sunday August 30, 2020 @02:06AM (#24321687)
Did people say that 20 years ago?
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by funnybeam on Sunday August 30, 2020 @03:41AM (#24321979)
Yes we did. I was on transhumanist mailing lists twenty years ago and the exact same comments were being made then as are in this thread today
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by hyko on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:22AM (#24322505)
Lol. I seem to recall seeing a comic strip once, where a young, a middle-aged, and an old man were asked when anti-aging treatments would arrive. Their answers were respectively: fifty years, ten years–and this afternoon!
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by xvilka on Sunday August 30, 2020 @10:17PM (#24327920)
Same situation like with nuclear fusion, I guess.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by lachlan-sneff on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:47PM (#24321207)
I have no idea, I'm not a scientist, I'm just a transhumanist.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by hyko on Sunday August 30, 2020 @05:49AM (#24322405)
There’s nothing to fear really. Why would there be no kids? Why would biologically “young” people have no new ideas?

I didn’t like extreme sports when I was young, but maybe if I was 10,000 years old, I’d think screw it and have a go at BASE jumping...

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by accurrent on Sunday August 30, 2020 @08:48AM (#24322902)
I don't know why you got down voted. Its perfectly honest to express what you feel.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by kiba on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:49PM (#24321215)
Actual substantial longevity - beyond quality of life enhancements - is something I greatly fear. It would change everything.

Enhancing health basically means you live longer. If you don't want to live longer then don't be healthy.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by lachlan-sneff on Saturday August 29, 2020 @10:58PM (#24321010)
Do you not want to live longer?
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by millstone on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:24PM (#24321126)
"Science advances one funeral at a time." - Max Planck

"Death is very likely the best single invention of life. It is life’s change agent. It clears out the old to make way for the new." - Steve Jobs

I know my life is accreting old biases and obstacles. Today and for years to come (I hope) I have more to do, but some day I will become an agent of stagnation instead of advancement.

Nobody wants to die. But in the big picture, the alternative is worse.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by lachlan-sneff on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:29PM (#24321138)
I can't say I understand this viewpoint. If you feel you're going to become an agent of stagnation, as you put it, simply put effort into not stagnating.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by millstone on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:56PM (#24321242)
I think we stagnate because we accumulate experience. As we grow old, we gain wisdom, but our wisdom is centralized in the past. We can't shed our experiences without forgetting ourselves.

Steve Jobs also talked about "the lightness of being a beginner again, less sure about everything." But I can't be a beginner again and again and again: some day my biases/old-dreams and stale-ideas/past-successes will dominate. Nobody has an endless capacity for creating the new.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by lachlan-sneff on Sunday August 30, 2020 @12:04AM (#24321278)
Perhaps stagnation is due to experience, perhaps it's due to accumulated, age-related brain damage. I doubt we'll know until people do live hundreds or thousands of years.

Surely you can be a beginner again. Pick something you've never done before, and do that. As fledgling as humanity is, humans already have millions of different traditions and areas of study. Just pick one (or many).

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by pessimizer on Sunday August 30, 2020 @02:25PM (#24324777)
> Pick something you've never done before, and do that.

You run out of those things shortly after birth. The vast majority of the aspects of everything that you attempt are familiar, and you have already developed habitual approaches to them. Having "never done something before" is shorthand for some experience having some aspect that you have never experienced before, not complete novelty. I'm going to build the strategies of flying a spaceship on the strategies I built learning to drive a car, which were built on the strategies I built learning to walk, which were built on the strategies I built learning to crawl, to manipulate my parents by crying, to identify distinct objects using my eyes, etc...

Eventually, the actually novel part of any new experience becomes vanishingly small. If anything, the ability to enjoy novelty, or to even see things as novel, is increased with our ability to forget. Maybe for a society, the ability to innovate relies on the ability to leave behind a bunch of brains whose plasticity has long been lost due to a lack of mental exercise.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by nynx on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:00PM (#24326288)
Get some help man
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by bpizzi on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:02AM (#24322465)
Those beliefs you spell are quite absolutes to me. Humanity is not made after a single mind model. What you take for granted (« nobody has endless capacity for creating the new ») might very well be an utterly false premise.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by kiba on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:56PM (#24321240)
For the vast majority of our history, there had been little to no technological changes.

Only difference is that in the last few centuries, there had been technological and scientific changes.

What changes? it's certainly isn't that old men die faster so that we embrace newer ideas faster. The old guards probably lived longer on average thanks to medicine.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by millstone on Sunday August 30, 2020 @01:11AM (#24321509)
Progress (technological or otherwise) is exponential by nature, because it builds on itself. What has changed is that its pace has outstripped our capacity to integrate it. So our age of peak contribution trends lower, towards the younger generation, which has less to unlearn.

As I grow older, I can see how my thinking is affected by my past. Someone with an unencumbered perspective will do the new thing, when I cannot.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by antepodius on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:03AM (#24322468)
It's an economic problem. Right now, there's this torrent of new minds to come up with new ideas thanks to their lack of preconceptions, so there's no effort put towards alternatives.

There's a lot of possibilities that will open up as our tech advances. Say, wiping all memories of your field so you can learn it again with a fresh mind. Spawning short-lived digital clones of your mind with the mental 'temperature' turned up, in whatever way that's possible- maybe just dose them up with synthetic lsd in different doses- and observe the results. Lots of ways to get novel ideas without having to rely on wastefully growing billions of brains (and the attached bodies!) before throwing them, and most of the information in them, away to rot.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by pessimizer on Sunday August 30, 2020 @02:34PM (#24324847)
A specific technological change: writing (and printing.) We were able to remember longer spans more accurately than could be done by memorization and the passing of that knowledge from old to young. Reversions occur due to the active destruction of recorded history through war and religion. When the retention of novelty depends on the health of a relatively small number of people, as a society you're perpetually rediscovering instead of discovering.

Now our problem is even having the ability to assimilate enough established knowledge during a lifetime to have a chance of making any novel contribution. The obvious endgame to AI is a dream of being able to assimilate information and innovate indefinitely.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by koonsolo on Sunday August 30, 2020 @05:04AM (#24322274)
The real question is what kind of life.

I love driving my motorcycle, and I'm well aware of the risks involved.

Now let's imagine a world where they cure aging. When dying in an accident, you could lose a whole lot more than now.

I'm pretty sure we would quickly evolve to a society where we minimize the risk to die to almost 0. I do not want to live in such a oversafely world.

Besides, I'm very happy with 70 or so years here, and try to enjoy all of it. The next generations will inherit it all.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by vharuck on Sunday August 30, 2020 @12:26PM (#24323847)
I doubt the extra years lost will affect people's decisions. I've seen a lot of 20 somethings weaving in traffic or not wearing protective hear while motorcycling. It's human nature to enjoy life by taking risks, reasonable or not (subjective as that is).
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by danieltillett on Sunday August 30, 2020 @05:48AM (#24322404)
Wait until you are 69.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by teej on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:23PM (#24321123)
No.

If I could add 10 years on to my 30s I would. But adding 10 years into my 80s doesn’t seem worthwhile.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by lachlan-sneff on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:28PM (#24321132)
The whole point of this is to be able to extend your healthspan, not just your lifespan. This includes age "reversal" and maintenance. A complete solution does not leave you in your 80s, it leaves you in your 20s indefinitely.
[dead]
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by lachlan-sneff on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:11PM (#24321064)
Never understood why so many people are so vehemently against anti-aging sentiments. Are they in denial about their own, current mortality?
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by melling on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:18PM (#24321101)
It’s the same story repeated. I got so tired of listening to people complain I wrote a blog about it 3 years ago so I could hopefully quell the noise.

“Death gives life meaning”

“It’ll only be for rich people”

https://h4labs.wordpress.com/2017/03/28/stories-that-should-...

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by PeterisP on Sunday August 30, 2020 @10:22AM (#24323178)
This is a situation where it's important to believe what is actually true.

If aging can't be stopped, then it's appropriate to accept your mortality and not be in denial.

But if aging can be stopped, then it's appropriate to fight against your mortality and not accept it.

Accepting your mortality has always been the correct answer because (and only because) we always have been inevitably mortal, and denial about mortality has been bad because (and only because) it's detached from reality. However, once the reality changes and it becomes plausible for the people living at that time (perhaps this time has already come for people who are still young? who knows) to become effectively immortal, then refusing to accept mortality stops being denial and becomes a healthy attitude.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by realbarack on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:20PM (#24321116)
I attribute it to mortality denial as well as general anti-technology sentiment across the board.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by koonsolo on Sunday August 30, 2020 @05:06AM (#24322285)
Maybe we're atheists that accepted our own mortality.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by antepodius on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:09AM (#24322479)
Would you accept your mortality if you were standing on a track in front of an incoming train, and could live longer by walking sideways?

Aging is, in principle, is engineering problem. The sooner and more people start to work on it, the sooner it might be fixed. Maybe too late for us, but maybe for our kids, or theirs, or whoever's- doing work towards curing aging is a gift to whichever generation fixes it.

(Not that it's as binary as 'just fixing it', of course, but you get the idea.)

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by flyinglizard on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:11PM (#24321066)
I also don’t want to pay taxes but here I am, grudgingly paying them for the benefit of our societal structure.

Would I want to live in a world where people don’t have kids, where people can take as much time as they want because time is infinite, a world where you wouldn’t even go out on the street for the chance something would happen to you and deprive you of eternal existence? I’m not sure, and in any case, it will be a vastly different future.

Imagine Mark Zuckerberg running his empire for 900 years straight.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by echelon on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:17PM (#24321093)
You do you.

I want to live 900 years and explore every discipline under the sun. I want to travel the world twenty times, read every book, see a hundred thousand sunsets.

Don't tell me I or anyone else doesn't deserve that. Evolution left us with bodies that don't permit it, but we'll escape that limit someday.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by acituan on Sunday August 30, 2020 @01:23PM (#24324275)
Not meaning this in an derogatory manner but this sounds to me something like what Peter Pan wanted. He didn't want to leave neverland and he wanted to be everything (pan). This is also well studied in the Jungian psychology under the term puer aeternus, the infinite child.

The problem with this is, personal harm it causes aside, if all adults wanted to be infinite children, it wouldn't leave space to (at least compete with) the incoming, actual children. It would cause great intergenerational conflict. Not leaving resources for the next generation also means endangering the continuity of species altogether.

If we take a step back, one might even argue that this is already what is going on today.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by flyinglizard on Sunday August 30, 2020 @05:02AM (#24322269)
Do you have kids? I think my view on this radically changed as a father. I feel like my generation sticking around forever would come at the expense of our children (or their children, which by proxy is the same thing).

With kids around, there’s just something biologically soothing that tells you “you’ve done your part. You can leave this world at peace”.

I know it’s not the same for everyone but on a humankind level, that’s exactly how it works.

“A society grows great when old men plant trees in whose shade they shall never sit.”

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by bpizzi on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:08AM (#24322477)
Those are beliefs from the past. Given time it will change. What human kind is biologically hardwired for is personal survival ability, not leaving the world for youngsters as soon as possible, and those two precepts are mutually exclusive.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by flyinglizard on Sunday August 30, 2020 @08:07AM (#24322796)
Humans have individually weak survival instincts, which is why soldiers were running into machine gun fire on the beaches of Normandy (or why others ride motorcycles). Some of that is surely the denial of our own mortality.

Humans excel at surviving as a group, which is a very different - sometimes contrasting - thing.

Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by antepodius on Sunday August 30, 2020 @06:11AM (#24322483)
Nobody's telling you you're not allowed to die, and I'll always be on the libertarian end of that equation. Just please don't stop people from trying to live.
Re:Longevity FAQ: A beginner's guide to longevity research by lachlan-sneff on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:13PM (#24321078)
I do want to live in a world where people can take as much time as they want! I'm 20 years old, and there already isn't enough time to do everything I want to do. I also disagree that increased longevity will lead to a stagnant society. Just as we don't expect a 30 year old to be the same person when they're aged to 40 or 50, I don't expect a 100 year old to be the same person when they're 300. Neurons are replaced, old memories are forgotten, old habits are redefined.