But then society will have to vote for sacrificing luxury today for the benefit of future generations, which typically doesn’t go well.
It's a reasonable position and one of the options before those we have chosen to lead us. Then again, the argument "but muh munny" is a strong counterargument among those who own them.
As it will be for you, should you manage to accumulate any wealth.
However, it has nothing to do with the separate problem of creating a hostile environment (the physical world) for future generations which can only be avoided by reducing fossil fuel usage which can only be accomplished one way - increasing the cost of using it.
As far as how much personal wealth I’m willing to depart with, I’m willing to do whatever it takes to get people healthcare, minimum vacation time, sick leave, higher education, and parental leave.
Reducing population also only buys time. I think you already know both of these things.
If your time is worth little, public transportation will work. But if you want to get from home to work and back, the car will be quickest. And if you want to go to the grocery store on the way home, no public transportation helps with that.
There are a few modifications of that.
If you have to get to work and you're not in a rush and you have something to do along the way like listen to a podcast or read a book, then that might be slightly different, because you're living a bit. (although podcasts work in the car if you are not against driving + listening - some people are)
Public transportation works really well when the roads are full full full. Getting from one side of Mexico City to the other quickly during rush hour is possible with the metro, not possible in a car.
The corporate performance of railroads in the 19th and 20th century are distinguished by comical poor performance, abusive practices and unrivaled greed. For all the faults, the industry around cars is highly competitive at almost every level.
This line in the article is the crux of the issue.
> The question is not whether the predictions of how they will behave are accurate, but what kind of behavior we want to have more of.
How we build determines what kind of environment we have not the other way around. People WILL sell their cars if they have good public transport. They will live in dense areas if they can. This has been the case in the US and all around the world.
P.S. I really cringe at you saying that cars are cheap while talking about your ski trips. You obviously have never been around poor areas of the United States. Go hop a ride on a bus on the south side of Chicago some time. Go tell the people who commute an hour a day by bus that they should just buy a car because its so cheap.
The immense popularity of the quiet suburb seems to disprove this statement.
I get what you are saying, but there is so much more going on that makes them "popular", particular in the United States.
Firstly, is the cost of living in the suburbs is massively subsidized. In the coming decades this will become readily apparent as most of suburban America will not be able to afford its infrastructure. It is already starting to happen.
Secondly, the suburbs in America are often the only legal way to build. We've outlawed density in most of the country. Many of the most urban parts of our major cities are less dense than they were a few decades ago because of zoning changes.
Thirdly, we simply do not have good public transit. You may think that New York or Chicago have great public transit but they have substantially less per-capita ridership compared to many other equivalent cities.
I'd suggest looking to other parts of the world as examples of immensely popular dense development. In Asia, Tokyo, Singapore, many cities in China and across Europe are great examples of this. The U.S. is an aberration - not the rule.
(high) cost, noisy neighbors (and poor insulation), zero design for ventilation or privacy. This isn't directly addressed in the suburbs either, but the lower density in the suburbs decreases the effects.
I've never lived in a shared dwelling that isn't an apartment though. Maybe the equally unaffordable condos and such in cities don't suck; however I'm inclined to believe that they share these faults and all of the distractions of others, particularly in cities with mostly US citizens.
Haven't we just learned that being in close proximity to people in unclean settings is a big risk to public health? Public transit advocates are going to have to address and overcome that before anyone should listen to them.
And that's not even considering the massive decrease in commuting needs from distributed/WFH workforces.
Plenty of non-US cities denser than NYC did fine. and NYC is also doing pretty well by now. Consider basic stuff like how much is spread before CDC switched to promoting mask usage.
Respiratory Pandemics are also relatively rare events. Sorry, but it's true. Meanwhile suburbanization and car use causes tons of air pollution which sickens people constantly. Integrate and I am sure the suburbs come off as causing more unhealthiness.
Recent wave in suburban eras (Forida) + whatever doom we'll face in the winter will also make the April NYC a fainter memory.
------
The subway in particular has excellent air filtration systems, and there have been no super spreading incidents linked to it, so as long as it's less than rush our super-packed, it's fine. See https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/08/10/nyregion/nyc-...
You don't seem to have addressed the needs of anyone who doesn't live in a dense city. How about suburbia? The midwest? Try walking a couple blocks in Phoenix, AZ in summer.
I really doubt that our government, state or national, is capable of maintaining a decent infrastructure. California is certainly a good example of the propensity towards failure. (Maybe if we try again, with some extra rules, they'll do better next time?)
> we do a very poor job making the alternatives attractive...until we can either make car ownership/use more expensive
I really hope that the solution to poor transportation infrastructure won't be making the part that works even worse.
However, the largest problem I see which the article briefly touches on is the failure to even consider building something besides a freeway. A `correct` model should be screaming to build public transport.
However, consider the following circumstances:
1. As it is many people are forced to have a car even if public transport can serve their main commute but often public transport is more expensive than the marginal cost of driving a vehicle (i.e gas + upkeep) so they choose to drive unless the congestion is extreme (i.e one of the worst commutes in the US).
2. Even if public transport is pretty decent (commute + groceries), they just happen to already have a car because their previous location did not have public transport. So we are back at #1. Or I don't know if I'll move in a year or two so might as well keep the car.
3. OR now that I have a car , I would probably not want to have to pay for expensive parking (& housing) in an area with public transport plus now I'll have to pay a mechanic a premium to even change the oil. So instead I live further away thus reinforcing the need to keep the car.
4 & etc. I need to travel >50 miles (skiing, hiking), renting is a pain and long trip ride sharing is expensive. Groceries are easier to do with a car especially when buying in bulk (Although, if/when I can get Costco delivered same or 2-day with perishables at <=10% premium, then this is a moot point).
Cars are pretty (at least marginally or per mile) cheap in America and we do a very poor job making the alternatives attractive if not impossible. Anyone who has a car seems to drive it even if public transport could be used (again outside of super specific commutes in a few cities). Until we can either make car ownership/use more expensive or greatly increase the practicality of not having a car at all, anticipate having a car and being stuck in traffic at least part of the time.