News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alternate YC Summer 2011 Class - let's do it ourselves by anon_19409 on Saturday April 09, 2011 @11:24PM (#2428698)
A word of caution about the name and approach. You'll find when fundraising that branding yourself as "ycreject.com" will make it very hard to raise funding. VCs and Angels are going to think, "if YC wouldn't give them money, why should I give them a much larger amount of money?"

I don't think it's controversial to say that most angels and VCs suffer from group-think and an over-reliance on social proof. That's why finding your first investor is the hardest.

This concept will be perfect for boot-strapers, but not good for someone looking for funding. You'd be better off avoiding all relation to YC and branding yourself as some sort of unaffiliated startup co-op.

Re:Alternate YC Summer 2011 Class - let's do it ourselves by allantyoung on Saturday April 09, 2011 @11:53PM (#2428730)
While your advice makes a lot of sense, I think they can definitely get some traction with this idea.

Here is a wrinkle that I think could work. Limit it to everyone that got an interview but didn't get in.

Re:Alternate YC Summer 2011 Class - let's do it ourselves by wangwei on Sunday April 10, 2011 @12:42AM (#2428814)
Then, this would disqualify the author of this post because he didn't get an interview.
Re:Alternate YC Summer 2011 Class - let's do it ourselves by allanscu on Sunday April 10, 2011 @12:45AM (#2428826)
Yes.. then I would be DQ'd.
Re:Alternate YC Summer 2011 Class - let's do it ourselves by cabinguy on Sunday April 10, 2011 @02:48AM (#2429046)
I'm sorry it DQ's the OP, but this idea is a winner.
Re:Alternate YC Summer 2011 Class - let's do it ourselves by hanibash on Saturday April 09, 2011 @11:49PM (#2428727)
Doesn't this show determination? Paul Graham's number 1 trait in a founder?
Re:Alternate YC Summer 2011 Class - let's do it ourselves by kaisdavis on Sunday April 10, 2011 @10:52AM (#2429559)
It shows determination in the same way that showing up on a date and telling him / her that 'I'm having a lot of success in the dating world, I just got turned down for 3 dates' projects confidence. Sure, you're out there getting names and numbers and seeing what happens, and that's great! But what's the story you're telling to potential investors / spouses?

The name YCRejects can tell a lot of stories. "We had an interview, but we weren't the right fit for the program, so we're building the product / finding the market ourselves" is one story. But the name YCRejects says "We didn't get an interview, but..." and puts you [in my mind] in an awkward position where you're apologizing and making excuses for applying to something. That's not right.

If YCombinator brought this idea together [as it obviously has], why not build on that? YCombinator — Summer Batch 2.

You're a group of founders, brought together by YCombinator, working together to build awesome things. You're a skunkworks incubator. You [probably] have no funding, but you have passion for your ideas and a burning desire and determination to get this show started.

You aren't rejects. You're founders.

Re:Alternate YC Summer 2011 Class - let's do it ourselves by jaxn on Sunday April 10, 2011 @12:01PM (#2429698)
Determination towards the startup? Or determination towards being in a group of startups?

This may be a really great idea, but it seems like a distraction for the person running it.

Re:Alternate YC Summer 2011 Class - let's do it ourselves by allanscu on Saturday April 09, 2011 @11:57PM (#2428736)
It's just a name by itself for now (for SEO purposes as well). Of course I wouldn't go around to investors and say we're 2nd tier groups that PG didn't want.

Right now, I want to keep it very small. Find out what everybody wants and go from there.

Re:Alternate YC Summer 2011 Class - let's do it ourselves by tlrobinson on Sunday April 10, 2011 @02:18AM (#2428988)
I don't know, with the way things are going for YC some prominent group of angels will be pledging to invest $150K in these guys any minute.
Re:Alternate YC Summer 2011 Class - let's do it ourselves by abbasmehdi on Sunday April 10, 2011 @12:18AM (#2428764)
Dissociated from YC could totally work!!! Also find mentors to answer questions at the dinner, and have each team do a 5 minute quick presentation regarding their progress that week. Also, don't judge people on any other criteria outside of a) launch date (to be sure you're all planning on lunching something substantial around the same time) and b) potential to become profitable soon.