> You can indeed come back and fix that later, and you can make this trade cautiously to get your work to production faster.
I think that is only true in certain companies of a certain size. If you're a small startup trying to launch an MVP, yes, time to market will be prioritised over everything.
If you're in a regulated sector, or your company is any larger than e.g. 30 people, "going back and fixing later" gets harder and costly than shipping correct software in the first place; either because you'll damage your reputation, you'll have a deadline to implement the fix (unnecessarily adding pressure on your own team), or other teams start relying on the wrong behaviour and now your fix is not trivial anymore because it doesn't affect only a local scope.
I want to highlight this because it's a trend to think any company and any project can (and should!) be managed as if anything being done is a prototype, w/ a perception that this is "agile", and picking the worst set of trade-offs for the task at hand.
Some tasks are suited better for mad scientists, ... some for town planners. Some regulated environments are only suited to the type of work that town planners can do (6-sigma people, that's how it's also explained in the class.)
But the settlers won't have much to do if pioneers haven't done some heavy lifting first, and so on (thanks a lot, mad scientist,) and the town planners can't do the type of work that you need from them either, unless there have been many layers of groundwork laid before them.
Glad you enjoyed checking it out!
For future changes, factoring also requires a crystal ball since you have no idea how requirements will change or if your factoring will actually be useful for them. Better to keep things simple and contained until you actually need to make them more complex.
I've been doing TDD a long time (18+ years), and I'm definitely pragmatic in the sense that I don't test everything, definitely don't aim for 100% coverage, and don't use mocks often, etc. I aim to extract most of the value from the tests without paying an absurdly high tax on them. Still learning in that regard, but I have had some real successes in testing.
I find this is key in our broader team's ability to keep the internal quality high. It's obviously easy to mess up a code base, but (high quality!) tests have been an important part of that, in addition to refactoring, code review, etc.
That's what I've heard called "trading external quality" for time to market. That is exactly how you're supposed to do it, at least according to the dev coach that I've been listening to (@GeePawHill)
Why you write tests and refactor is to keep your code's internal quality up. Those are the things that customers can't see, the things that make it harder for you to change your code when you come back to do more work later.
The Correlation Principal states that ISQ and developer productivity are directly correlated and that you cannot trade internal quality for development time to market without this trade-off quickly coming back to bite you, in the form of lost productivity.
A feature that is only partially implemented, or an edge case that isn't tested properly and causes something to fail at runtime, are both examples of external quality. You can indeed come back and fix that later, and you can make this trade cautiously to get your work to production faster.
But if you write a long method for example that "just works" and ship it without further introspection, refactoring, or complete test coverage, you may never recover from that. It might require devs to spend an extra hour or more each time that method should need to change in the future. In some future state it has become so long and complicated that nobody can fully understand it, the time to stop digging is whenever you see yourself inside of this hole.
And according to Sandi Metz, those big long methods are almost always guaranteed to be the ones that will need to change again, they are long and complicated because those are the business objects that you care about. They should be well factored as early as possible to facilitate future changes, (unless you have a crystal ball and can say for sure that won't ever need to happen!)