one of the questions is whether passwords sent across the network are considered metadata or content.
NSA legal says passwords are metadata. which means NSA can scan all traffic for passwords and steal them and no FISA warrant is needed, nor a subpoena.
of course NSA already has a dozen programs just for extracting passwords from UPSTREAM passive collection. and presumably this means everyone in the FVEYS gets access to everyone's passwords, since they pool their capabilities and collection.
whatever the Courts rule about local cops and passwords, it doesnt apply at the level of SIGINT collection, which enjoys its own separate and secret system of laws.
Anyway, the point is that the website claims canadian courts can lawfully demand your password/key (key disclosure law) even though the reference cited (Wikipedia) says the exact opposite.
One part that isn’t mentioned in the article though is how the Canadian legal system would handle someone who has password-protected records about someone else. For example, you and I are friends, and I am on trial. Would the courts be able to subpoena your iMessage history with me? If you refused to provide your password, would you be charged with contempt? It’s not an 11(c) situation, because you’re not being compelled to be a witness against yourself.
>In a 2010 Quebec Court of Appeal case the court stated that a password compelled from an individual by law enforcement "is inadmissible and that renders the subsequent seizure of the data unreasonable. In short, even had the seizure been preceded by judicial authorization, the law will not allow an order to be joined compelling the respondent to self-incriminate."[12]
>In a 2019 Ontario court case (R v. Shergill), the defendant was initially ordered to provide the password to unlock his phone. However, the judge concluded that providing a password would be tantamount to self-incrimination by testifying against oneself. As a result, the defendant was not compelled to provide his password.
According to the Wikipedia article cited when "Canada" is clicked, key disclosure laws don't apply which is the opposite of what the site claims.
Or am I misunderstanding something here?