News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by jacquesm on Monday August 24, 2020 @01:31PM (#24263043)
I'm seriously worried about the effect AGI would have on our economic structures and I do not think we are at all prepared for the kind of shock that would result from 75% or more of the current workforce becoming unemployed overnight.
Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by ramblerman on Monday August 24, 2020 @01:51PM (#24263305)
I dont believe we can get AGI without opening the door for super intelligence. So true AGI would either completely liberate us or destroy us. But the sheer power of it would be incredible.

To think about jobs after that event seems absurd.

Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by jacquesm on Monday August 24, 2020 @01:57PM (#24263364)
It may seem absurd but lots of people derive a lot of their self value from the fact that they are able to move the needle. Take that away and you're going to cause some serious social upheaval and quite a bit of that will be a negative.

"Your scientists were so focused on whether they could, they forgot to ask themselves whether they should".

The sheer power of it would be incredible, which is why this is a step that should not be taken lightly or accidentally.

Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by pdimitar on Monday August 24, 2020 @02:11PM (#24263538)
I'd think that whoever perceives themselves as craftsmen should continue to, you know, craft things.

I personally am interested in a society where work is 100% optional. And I think AGI would enable that.

How do you view AGI in relation to economic effects on the world?

Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by nick_kline on Monday August 24, 2020 @02:35PM (#24263839)
Work can't just be optional (as part of a trade off for food etc) because a lot of society in the US at least thinks it's a moral problem to just give people food, clothing, shelter even if we are better off avoiding starving people without homes (and it's a moral necessity but that doesn't seem to compel people). Look at the political situation here, people would be angry at the idea that you give 'other people' free stuff, somehow ignoring whether social security and medicare for senior citizens are free stuff. The fact that we don't trust "the other" means at least in the US giving people basics that we can provide almost for free it would be wrenching to society.
Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by pdimitar on Monday August 24, 2020 @03:45PM (#24264660)
Well that's one of the ideas of AGI -- it will give you no choice! :D

People can keep doing petty political fights but they'll quiet down when the food and basic goods land in their house without them lifting a finger, I think. And it's going to be made better if it's done by robots and not other people.

Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by TwelveNights on Monday August 24, 2020 @03:05PM (#24264184)
I'm concerned about the effect on people who find meaning in the work they do. It's similar to how AlphaGo caused Lee Se-dol to retire. Once AI surpasses humans, a lot of work will seem meaningless, even if it previously gave meaning to people's lives.
Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday August 24, 2020 @04:54PM (#24265392)
So what? Either people will find meaning somewhere else, or they won't. How is that different than any historical economic revolution, or indeed just the way things are now? There are plenty of people who already don't find meaning in work.
Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by pdimitar on Monday August 24, 2020 @03:42PM (#24264616)
Exactly this will give a second rise to hand-crafted goods. People will value handy work more than what a perfect robot can do. I know I do.

People will simply divide in two: those who want the automated labor goods, and those who prefer hand-crafted goods. The latter will also be willing to pay more.

Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by sh461 on Monday August 24, 2020 @03:23PM (#24264391)
The overwhelming probability is that none of us will see AGI in the span of our lives. The economic disruption is another thing - that can happen without AGI.
Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by p1esk on Monday August 24, 2020 @08:05PM (#24266891)
We have no idea when AGI might appear. I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s already running quietly somewhere in OpenAI or Google datacenter.
Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by sh461 on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @04:10AM (#24269143)
1. > We have no idea when AGI might appear.

We do know when it might not appear. This isn't a movie where AI is created by a single person in an afteroon because they had a creative thought. It's an effort by many people over a prolonged period of time. Everything that we know from decades of AI research tells us that it certainly doesn't exist and that we aren't close to discovering it. Also your common sense should tell you that if Google had AGI, they wouldn't currently get most of their revenue from ads and they wouldn't have a smaller market cap than a company that makes phones.

2. Your statement is non-falsifiable. It's similar to claiming that I wouldn't be surprised if humans have already been to Mars. It's an outrageous claim that no one can accurately disprove. Non-falsifiability is also a way some conspiracy theories spread. Because when someone says "No way" to such a claim (like the sibling comment), you can always respond with "How do you know?". Falsifiability separates science from non-science - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability

Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by p1esk on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @01:51PM (#24273982)
We do know when it might not appear

No, we don't. The progress in AI has been exponential. Anything exponential is hard for humans to estimate. This is perfectly illustrated by statements like "decades of AI research tells us ... that we aren't close". Every significant AI breakthrough has caught most AI experts by surprise (chess, IBM Watson, Imagenet results in 2012, Atari games, Go, GPT-2/3). If you made a poll of AI researchers a year or two before each one of these breakthroughs has happened, you would get estimates that would have been overly pessimistic in their timelines. We had no idea that scaling the original transformer would lead to GPT-3, and we don't have any idea of what's going to happen if we scale GPT-3 another factor of 100x.

if Google had AGI

We have no idea what an "AGI" would look like. More precisely, any ideas you might have about it probably came from Hollywood. For example, you seem to believe AGI will be superintelligent, even though it simply needs to be as intelligent as a regular human to be considered "AGI". It might be superintelligent, but we don't know.

Your statement is non-falsifiable

Relax. We are not proving a theorem here. Yes, it's unlikely Google has AGI. But I wouldn't be surprised if it does (ok, maybe a little surprised). But I would be very surprised if we don't have AGI within next 20 years. To me it's more likely we have it already than we don't have it within our lifetime.

Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by jacquesm on Monday August 24, 2020 @09:28PM (#24267350)
Not a chance.
Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by p1esk on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @12:22AM (#24268106)
How do you know?
Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by jacquesm on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @12:51PM (#24273339)
You make a claim that could not possibly be proven one way or the other. Therefore it is a meaningless claim.
Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by p1esk on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @12:56PM (#24273388)
No, I simply make a claim that your claim is false.
Re:Ask HN: Does Anyone Want AGI? by AnimalMuppet on Monday August 24, 2020 @03:39PM (#24264589)
How would the existence of an AGI cause 75% of the workforce to lose their jobs?

Take barbers/hairdressers, for example. Could an AI do that job? Sure, in one sense, you just need robotic scissors. Do those robotic scissors magically appear immediately after the AGI does? No.

Or take welding. Sure, you can replace the welder with a robot. Who makes the robot? The AGI? Using what factory? Does the AGI, just by virtue of existing, own all the factories in the world? No, it doesn't.

Or take the person at the front desk of the hotel. Can you replace them with a robot? Maybe, but nobody wants a smile from a robot. They want one from a human.