News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday August 22, 2020 @07:36PM (#24248183)
> How about showing me a sound final (100k yr) storage for nuclear waste, built and ready, before you operate any more nuclear reactors?

"Nuclear waste" is an artificial problem. It is possible to build reactors that use the "nuclear waste" from existing reactors as fuel, which destroys it forever. We haven't done this primarily because people keep refusing to build new reactors that do this until we figure out what to do with the nuclear waste. Which obviously doesn't make any sense.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by ysleepy on Saturday August 22, 2020 @07:42PM (#24248220)
In the same sense that we will all be saved by CO2 capturing devices?

These kinds of reactors (Travelling Wave Reactor etc.) you mention are vapourware and have been for quite some time. And I highly doubt the "which destroys it forever" part, - really, no waste at all, magic you say?

This is just more of "Future Tech will solve this" externalization of problems.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by randallsquared on Saturday August 22, 2020 @08:05PM (#24248363)
> really, no waste at all, magic you say?

The core problem with nuclear waste is that it's energetic. There are a number of designs that burn up waste; if we were building and testing them, poor reactor types could be abandoned and better ones could be improved. We're not doing that primarily because "nuclear" is a scary word owing to activist efforts decades ago.

> This is just more of "Future Tech will solve this" externalization of problems.

That is absolutely the right plan, though. Assuming our civilization doesn't collapse or stall, future generations will be enormously wealthier than we are, and any problem we have will be proportionately smaller for them. Of course, stall or collapse isn't impossible, but I do wish people wouldn't so heavily advocate for exactly that.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by stephenr on Saturday August 22, 2020 @09:50PM (#24248887)
> because "nuclear" is a scary word owing to activist efforts decades ago.

Right, activists... not those pesky meltdowns spewing radioactive waste across Europe and into the pacific, it was the activists.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by spfzero on Sunday August 23, 2020 @11:03PM (#24257215)
"spewing ... into the Pacific" actually dilutes it more than when it existed in ore in the first place. It had to be concentrated by orders of magnitude from ore, to make it radioactive enough to be fuel for a reactor. Before that, it was just backround that we've lived happily with for eons, and in the Pacific it is even lower level.
Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by stephenr on Monday August 24, 2020 @04:39AM (#24258605)
The plant operators measured 7.5M times the legal limit of radioactive iodine in the seawater.

Complete dilution is not a given, and expecting zero consequences to marine life (and anything that then feeds on marine life) is optimistic at best.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by raxxorrax on Monday August 24, 2020 @08:21AM (#24259894)
because there is a lot of water on the planet?

Or a hungry fish will introduce it into the food chain before it has dissolved completely homogeneously into the wide oceans of the earth.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by randallsquared on Saturday August 22, 2020 @10:03PM (#24248956)
All the meltdowns in the 1950s, 60s, and 70s are what explains the automatic flinch that western cultures have had since the late 60s? Huh.
Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by numpad0 on Saturday August 22, 2020 @08:35PM (#24248506)
Recycling for spent fuels is a proven technology. Problem is ... it creates weapons grade Plutonium as the product, out of Depleted Uranium(stuffs so safe US military puts into tank shells as weights).

You know, Plutonium is a highly toxic heavy metal, and a bit radioactive, so,

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday August 22, 2020 @10:52PM (#24249153)
> Problem is ... it creates weapons grade Plutonium as the product, out of Depleted Uranium(stuffs so safe US military puts into tank shells as weights).

Calling this the problem is just more fear mongering. The hard part about building a uranium-based bomb is getting weapons-grade uranium, because the bomb is simpler but U-235 is only 0.7% of natural uranium and is hard to separate from U-238 because they're chemically identical. The hard part about building a plutonium-based bomb is getting the implosion right. Making weapons-grade plutonium is relatively easy -- you expose U-238 to neutrons and some of the uranium turns into plutonium, then you can chemically separate the plutonium. But then you need a sophisticated bomb instead of a sophisticated centrifuge. It's not actually easier. That's why most nascent programs don't generally even try to make plutonium.

On top of that, you can design a reactor that produces enough other Plutonium isotopes that it makes the Plutonium-239 totally useless for a bomb, because they're even harder to separate from one another than U-235 is from U-238.

Also, the nuclear waste which sticks around for 24,000 years? That's the plutonium. The existing reactors already make it, because they contain U-238 and neutrons. It's the thing we already have, don't want and newer reactors can get rid of.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by verall on Monday August 24, 2020 @04:22AM (#24258506)
It sure makes an easy dirty bomb when stuck on a regular bomb though.
Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by AnthonyMouse on Monday August 24, 2020 @06:29PM (#24266269)
Dirty bombs are, to begin with, Hollywood movie plot nonsense.

But long-lived isotopes aren't even what you would use because they're only mildly radioactive.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by fuoqi on Sunday August 23, 2020 @12:38PM (#24253112)
>These kinds of reactors you mention are vapourware and have been for quite some time.

Depends on a country:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BREST_(reactor)

>The reactor uses nitride uranium-plutonium fuel, is a breeder reactor and can burn long-term radioactive waste.

I think existing BN reactors can also be used in the same way:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BN-800_reactor

Yes, it's not 100% ready technology (e.g. there are problems with fuel fabrication), but I would call it last stages of development.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by qayxc on Sunday August 23, 2020 @12:57PM (#24253259)
The BN-800 reactor was an engineering nightmare, though.

Those things had more downtime due to technical issues than operation time. The issues were indeed so severe, that the follow-up project (BN-1200) required a redesign and was put on hold indefinitely...

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by fuoqi on Sunday August 23, 2020 @01:06PM (#24253333)
IIRC most issues were caused by problems and delays with fuel fabrication, mentioned in my post. And changes in fuel fabrication is one of the main reasons for postponing BN-1200 construction (i.e. it does not make sense to build a reactor, while fuel production line is not ready).
Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by bb88 on Saturday August 22, 2020 @07:51PM (#24248270)
So this falls into the category of the solution of "X" is more "X".

I'm usually skeptical of arguments like these especially when "X" is complex, potentially harmful, or offered as a magic bullet.

In your case in order to validate claims, I have to be a nuclear scientist to understand the potential ramifications of your argument before I can fully understand the pros/cons.

If as an engineer, I cannot afford the time to do it, how our are politicians supposed to?

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by godelski on Sunday August 23, 2020 @02:28PM (#24254074)
> If as an engineer, I cannot afford the time to do it, how our are politicians supposed to?

I'm not fond of this line of reasoning. Politicians are by definition not scientists and engineers. Their job is to listen to different experts, not to understand nuances of a technology.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by mnemonicsloth on Saturday August 22, 2020 @08:12PM (#24248409)
The same way politicians build bridges and operate air traffic control systems: by hiring experts to do it.
Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by bb88 on Sunday August 23, 2020 @12:25AM (#24249512)
I feel you're being pedantic here.

When bridges fail, they don't affect potentially millions of people's health. Nor does when an ATC system fail at an airport -- traffic can just be rerouted to other airports.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by luckylion on Sunday August 23, 2020 @11:29AM (#24252552)
Meh, when major industry things fail, and e.g. a refinery just breaks and releases all of the oil and other stuff into the next best river, it will affect potentially millions of people's health if it's located right.

That's why we're trying to make extra extra sure that it doesn't happen and hire experts, and learn from mistakes (and there were plenty, and I'm sure there will be more).

"If this fails it's just too horrible, we mustn't attempt it" doesn't sound like the most helpful attitude when dealing with large projects that have gigantic benefits but can also cause gigantic issues when they explode.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by bb88 on Sunday August 23, 2020 @03:48PM (#24254720)
It seems with Nuclear we have always underestimated the risk in the risk/reward nature.
Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by URSpider94 on Monday August 24, 2020 @01:55AM (#24257857)
I disagree, in fact, we have more frequently underestimated the reward. RTFA. As the article points out, tens of thousands of people die every year from lung disease directly related to fossil fuel combustion. Furthermore, he argues that more people have died from stress due to being relocated from Fukushima, than would have died if we left most of them in place. It’s the trolley problem writ large.
Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by bb88 on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @05:02PM (#24276071)
I did RTFA.

Have you read how:

    TEPCO tried to hide the extent of Fukushima? 

    USSR tried to hide the extent of Chernobyl?

    Russia tried to hide the extent of the latest nuclear sub accident recently?
Why is it when the last three major nuclear incidents occurred in recent memory, people have been not willing to cough up the truth on the extent of the disaster?
Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by acituan on Sunday August 23, 2020 @02:55PM (#24254318)
> When bridges fail, they don't affect potentially millions of people's health.

If you are saying bad policy decisions are inherently less scaling than nuclear disasters, I would remind you the Great Leap Forward and the tens of millions of people dead as a result of the famine in just a few years. Sure that was an outlier event, and so was the nuclear disasters of past.

The problem is, with nuclear there seems to be an emotional shock and imagery that accompanies it which doesn’t seem to match those of, for example, dying of hunger. Just like airplanes feel less safe than cars but the latter kills much more people in practice, our emotive reasoning biases us heavily in this topic.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by bb88 on Sunday August 23, 2020 @03:54PM (#24254773)
Sure, GLF focused on idealistic purity rather than expertise.

There are also a lot more agricultural experts in the US than nuclear experts.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by acituan on Sunday August 23, 2020 @04:23PM (#24254998)
> Sure, GLF focused on idealistic purity rather than expertise

1986 USSR bureaucracy didn’t fail only for a lack of expertise either.

> There are also a lot more agricultural experts in the US than nuclear experts.

It is not a numbers game of that sort. If anything, public misinformation being amplified in influence through social media affects expert based political will negatively insofar the topic is ripe for emotional biases, not lack of real experts.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by bb88 on Sunday August 23, 2020 @05:45PM (#24255534)
> 1986 USSR bureaucracy didn’t fail only for a lack of expertise either.

I think you're talking Chernobyl here, without actually saying Chernobyl. Again they were arguably pushing ideology over science -- in many ways to save cost. Then making any criticisms about safety state secrets so no one could know about them.

It's worth noting that Gorbachev believed that Chernobyl led to the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1992, six years later.

> If anything, public misinformation being amplified in influence through social media affects expert based political will negatively insofar the topic is ripe for emotional biases, not lack of real experts.

True, but that cuts your argument. As it turns questions of science into ideological ones. If you're a farmer you can go to your local extension office, and ask questions about herbicide and fertilizers and planting schedules without government interference -- essentially expanding knowledge.

If Russia ran ads on FB that said the best time to plant corn was in November of the following year, there would be a lot of laughter.

There is no such thing as extension offices for nuclear science -- ergo making it even more ripe for the idea that you're talking about.

On the other hand, people trust vaccines less, and there has been a concerted effort to cause public distrust. Imagine what would happen if that happened to nuclear scientists. Worse, there would be only few people to make that argument against it. With vaccines there were lots of people that could, and still largely failed.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by acituan on Sunday August 23, 2020 @06:15PM (#24255756)
> I think you're talking Chernobyl here, without actually saying Chernobyl

Yes.

> True, but that cuts your argument. As it turns questions of science into ideological ones.

That’s fair enough. If I am understanding correctly, you’re saying the institutional mistrust and failing public discourse we are experiencing today would render existing nuclear dangerous too. No matter if we have expertise or not (I believe we do) we can’t navigate our way to it in the presence of so much other BS.

Re:Data from Chernobyl and Fukushima provide answers about t... by bb88 on Sunday August 23, 2020 @10:55PM (#24257184)
Not only that, but in the past when a nuclear accident happens, TEPCO - a private company, and the USSR/Russia (twice now) have hidden information from the public during the accidents.

This makes the entire situation worse. Who does the public trust? The press? Watchdog groups?

It's bad enough it happens at all, but could it happen in the US? I would have said no until the last few years.

I kind of think this would be a good board game, actually. Kind of like pandemic but for a nuclear accident, and trying to make decisions based upon imperfect information.