News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lightroom app update wipes users' photos and presets, Ado... by prawn on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:35PM (#24231049)
I also detest the subscription as I rarely update and don't care about new features. It compares really poorly too with the other key piece of software I use - DaVinci Resolve. Resolve has an incredibly good free version and then the paid upgrade is a single payment.
Re:Lightroom app update wipes users' photos and presets, Ado... by jiggawatts on Thursday August 20, 2020 @11:54PM (#24231815)
An observation I've made is that DaVinci Resolve seems to be a more technically capable still image editing tool than Adobe Lightroom, despite being designed for video colour grading instead of photography.

For example, Lightroom does not allow custom colour spaces for the output, they're restricted to a fixed list of baked-in ICC profiles. The only option is to export in the large ProPhoto space and then externally convert to the target space as a second step.

Lightroom has no support for true HDR, the type that requires HDR10 or Dolby Vision displays. If you want to edit a 14-bit RAW photo for, say, the background image in a HDR computer game or a YouTube video, Lightroom can't help you.

Even in SDR mode, the colour grading in Lightroom is much more primitive than Resolve. There's no vector scope, for example, something that would be trivial to implement for them.

Adobe talks a lot about their "AI" features, but they're very basic. They've left a lot of low hanging fruit on the tree. For example, it would be great feature that when flicking through a bunch of shots of a face while zoomed in, the eyes should be automatically aligned between each shot to make it easy to compare shots. Similarly, they could train an AI to recognise in-focus and out-of-focus faces, and automatically "score" a shot based on things like: "Are both eyes in focus, or just one?"

These days, this stuff is trivial to implement in software, yet Adobe is still firmly rooted in the 1900s era of "It's just like your darkroom! All the terminology of the black and white film era is unchanged! You can dodge! You can burn! Just... with a computer!"

Reminds me of AutoCAD 20+ years ago: it was a digital blueprint software. More computer-native CAD with proper 3D modelling capabilities such as SolidWorks ate their lunch...

Re:Lightroom app update wipes users' photos and presets, Ado... by bleepblorp on Friday August 21, 2020 @03:54AM (#24232977)
Adobe stagnation is not surprising given that they've switched to a subscription model.

Perpetual licensing means that software vendors are essentially competing with the previous versions of their own products and have to provide compelling improvements to their customers for them to upgrade. Ongoing revenue, and with it, vendor survival, depends on continual improvements.

In contrast, subscription models combined with cloud-based vendor lock-in allow software vendors to extract economic rents from their victims indefinitely. There are no previous versions to compete against and victims must pay in perpetuity to access their own data. Vendors get paid without needing to do work, so they do no work, make no improvements, and reap disproportionate profits.

Software subscriptions are a perfect example of rent seeking, with all that implies about the relationship between vendor and victim and the prospects for ongoing product improvements.

Re:Lightroom app update wipes users' photos and presets, Ado... by formerly_proven on Friday August 21, 2020 @03:06PM (#24237878)
I don't think there is any other software that matches Resolve's ease of use and results when it comes to primary or secondary (selective) color correction. I'm pretty sure you could just make a 6000x4000 (for example) timeline (resolution isn't limited to 4K in the paid version) and drop in a bunch of stills as separate single frame "clips", and export as a bunch of stills.