News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by mcormier on Thursday July 10, 2008 @08:24AM (#242301)
Saying that iTunes is anti-web is like saying that any desktop application is anti-web.

When you click on a link in the browser it is forwarding the request to a desktop application. Just because the application connects to a remote server and displays html type content does not mean it needs to go in a web browser.

This is classic idealistic programmer blindness.

Examples:

I could write this program and I don't think it's worth $20 so it should be free.

It should be open source.

I can't reprogram my the fuel intake of my car so it must be anti-web.

etc, etc, ...

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by yef on Thursday July 10, 2008 @10:26AM (#242399)
Classic Apple apologism.

If Microsoft did this, there would be a swarm of complaints, and rightly so.

I'll stick with the Amazon music store, which is not only cheaper, has no confusing DRM files to deal with, and is fully on the web, meaning I can link to music, buy it on any web-enabled computer, etc.

There are plenty of reasons to like Apple, but their music store seems backward and anti-competitive to me.

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by jimbokun on Thursday July 10, 2008 @10:54AM (#242440)
"If Microsoft did this, there would be a swarm of complaints, and rightly so."

In Cringely's interview of Steve Jobs from "Revenge of the Nerds", Jobs says that he doesn't begrudge Microsoft their success. It just bothers him that they have absolutely no taste.

I agree that Apple (particularly under Jobs) is no better than Microsoft in terms of wanting to lock in all of their customers and extract as much money from them as humanly possible. However, I do think that Apple (particularly under Jobs) exhibits outstanding taste in software and hardware design. In particular, the combination of iTunes and iPod, while striving to lock customers in and not playing fairly with others, is far more usable and aesthetically pleasing than all of the sorry attempts by Microsoft to solve the same set of problems.

I think the fact that so many people LIKE Apple's products is part of the reason why not as many people get upset at Apple's anti-competitive behavior.

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by raganwald on Thursday July 10, 2008 @10:46AM (#242427)
> If Microsoft did this, there would be a swarm of complaints, and rightly so.

help me understand: how do I buy music for a Zune? I went to Zune.net, and this is what I found:

"For the full Zune Music experience, get the free Zune software. Browse over three million songs you can preview and download..."

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by Tichy on Thursday July 10, 2008 @08:26AM (#242303)
OK, so I'll say it: any desktop application is anti-web.

Is it programmer blindness? The reason I hate it as a programmer is that I don't see any compelling reason for the store to be not on the web. And it is very inconvenient. So it appears to be bad design, which disturbs the harmony of the cosmos.

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by mcormier on Thursday July 10, 2008 @08:38AM (#242316)
No reason? Seriously?

How about some business reasons?

- Don't have to test on multiple browsers. - Can upgrade the browser engine automatically with application updates and tie new features to iTunes version - Less risk of HTML hacking (source is much harder to get to), increases entrance barrier - Long term goal of familiarizing Windows users with a mac style interface.

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by groovyone on Thursday July 10, 2008 @09:54AM (#242377)
Good points! Apple is a BUSINESS :) Hey, and guess what - it seems to be working for them
Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by wallflower on Thursday July 10, 2008 @09:35AM (#242366)
Even if iTunes could be coded using jQuery+CSS, how would the sync to your iPod/iTouch/iPhone be handled?
Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by Tichy on Thursday July 10, 2008 @10:11AM (#242389)
Let them use iTunes for that, why not. But why not let me browse the selection on the web. I think you can also buy the stuff directly from the phone once you have one.
Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by gnaritas on Thursday July 10, 2008 @11:17AM (#242469)
How about because you're not their target market? Businesses exist for profit, and their resources are not unlimited, they clearly put their efforts into their customers, you know, the ones with iPods for whom iTunes exists. Their business is rocking, they have no need to chase you.
Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by Tichy on Thursday July 10, 2008 @01:55PM (#242690)
Actually I am interested in an iPhone, and my decision to buy it depends also on the selection of applications available.

Obviously Apple is doing fine without me as a customer, so what can I say...

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by silencio on Thursday July 10, 2008 @11:44AM (#242520)
but the thing is, that's a huge hassle. buying on a website, syncing in an app. what i really like about iTunes is how it's very tightly integrated with everything I use iTunes with/for. no webapp will be able to pull that off.

however, unless you mean explicitly browsing, in which case i might be inclined to agree because of the iTunes store links that only work in iTunes...that are useless if you don't have iTunes installed.

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by Tichy on Thursday July 10, 2008 @08:46AM (#242322)
<irony>I guess web applications were the wrong approach all this time.</irony>

I am surprised that it is still possible to buy applications for OS X anywhere. Why don't they tie OS X to the iTunes store as well?

In fact, why doesn't Apple just create it's own internet, completely isolated from the real internet?

Edit: one reason I can accept (just barely): pushing apps directly onto the phone if bought in the shop. I still think there should be a way to view the apps available in a browser.

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by utnick on Thursday July 10, 2008 @08:31AM (#242306)
It isn't on the web because it is integrated into the software that you play your music and videos in. This is a good thing.
Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by Tichy on Thursday July 10, 2008 @08:32AM (#242307)
Why? There are players for music and video for the web, and in any case, this is supposed to be a shop for iPhone applications?

If the players for web don't live up to Apple's standards, why not improve Safari accordingly?

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by utnick on Thursday July 10, 2008 @08:38AM (#242317)
i admit I only use Itunes for music/video.. and it is convenient to buy and then automatically be in my library where I can fire it up quick or export it to my ipod.

For Iphone apps it might not make as much sense.

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by Tichy on Thursday July 10, 2008 @08:47AM (#242323)
I have nothing against the convenience, I am just surprised they do it that way. I would have thought that basically iTunes integrates a browser for the shop, with some "plugins". So you could have the best of both worlds. If you want to just browse, you can do it with a normal browser, if you want the convenience, use the iTunes browser.
Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by pchristensen on Thursday July 10, 2008 @10:25AM (#242398)
Maybe no compelling reason for you as the user, but I'm pretty sure there are compelling reasons for Apple.