News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Anti-Capitalist Software License by ryanbrunner on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @07:13AM (#24209168)
When the community elects to police itself, if someone volunteers to watch a neighbourhood for a night are they considered law enforcement? If not, why? I recognize there's a difference but this license makes no effort to distinguish between those two things.

And if your starting point for why a term of a license is "we don't need laws", what exactly is the point of having a license anyway?

Re:The Anti-Capitalist Software License by krapp on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @07:23AM (#24209239)
As I understand it, the difference is that law enforcement exists to maintain a state's authority and control of its monopoly on violence, whereas community policing claims no such authority or interest.
Re:The Anti-Capitalist Software License by ryanbrunner on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @07:26AM (#24209265)
There's nothing inherent to the words "law enforcement" that necessitates that they are state run or makes any claim about the state's position on violence. I get that's what the authors are getting at, but it's not clear.
Re:The Anti-Capitalist Software License by krapp on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @07:31AM (#24209300)
Yeah... there's a reason people hire actual lawyers to write these things.

The authors probably thought the meaning would be obvious to everyone because it was obvious to them, but that's not how binding legal contracts work.

Re:The Anti-Capitalist Software License by colesantiago on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @07:19AM (#24209206)
> When the community elects to police itself, if someone volunteers to watch a neighbourhood for a night are they considered law enforcement?

It is 'community enforcement', they volunteered didn't they, it's not by force, by state, or are being paid to do it.

Re:The Anti-Capitalist Software License by ryanbrunner on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @07:25AM (#24209248)
Sure, that's fine - my point is that a blanket "you can't be law enforcement" doesn't make this distinction. If you want to include something like that in your license, you need to be a lot more clear about what "law enforcement" entails. Right now it makes no mention of whether it's speaking about professional law enforcement, state-operated law enforcement, or anything like that.
Re:The Anti-Capitalist Software License by guerrilla on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @07:22AM (#24209234)
> When the community elects to police itself, if someone volunteers to watch a neighbourhood for a night are they considered law enforcement? If not, why?

The difference would be that they would be chosen from the community by the community, not external to it and chosen by external actors.

> "we don't need laws"

This confounds laws with law enforcement. The concepts you're missing are consent and cooperation.

Re:The Anti-Capitalist Software License by nailer on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @10:42AM (#24210859)
> The difference would be that they would be chosen from the community by the community, not external to it and chosen by external actors.

So law enforcement chosen by the community is not law enforcement?

Re:The Anti-Capitalist Software License by guerrilla on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @12:03PM (#24211890)
It is not what people call law enforcement today, correct.
Re:The Anti-Capitalist Software License by ryanbrunner on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @07:27AM (#24209277)
> This confounds laws with law enforcement. The concepts you're missing are consent and cooperation.

I'm not the one making the claim that laws are a social construct and we don't need them.

Re:The Anti-Capitalist Software License by guerrilla on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @07:31AM (#24209293)
> I'm not the one making the claim that laws are a social construct

Now you're confounding two further ideas. Laws are obviously a social construct, nobody serious is going to disagree with that. We create them, unlike the laws of nature.

Re:The Anti-Capitalist Software License by slowmovintarget on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @05:27PM (#24216790)
You created a straw-man by omitting "and we don't need them" from your quote.

Laws are a social construct. We do need them. Civilization has proven this time and again over thousands of years.