News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by marcan_42 on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @01:42AM (#24195641)
You seem to have trouble understanding the difference between network usage and distribution.

If I give you a CD with nginx, I'm distributing it.

If I send you a .tar.gz with nginx, I'm distributing it.

If I bring up nginx on a server, put some HTML files in the webroot, and give you a URL to it, I am not distributing nginx. I am merely using nginx, and offering you a service using nginx. I am not offering nginx itself. I am distributing my HTML website, and I am merely using nginx for it.

Cases 1 and 2 invoke copyright. Case 3 does not. In the absence of a license, you are not allowed to do 1 nor 2, but you are allowed to do 3. I can give you software I created, say nothing whatsoever about its license (which means, implicitly, "all rights reserved"), and international copyright law says you can not do 1 nor 2, but you can do 3.

The GPL, BSD, and other free software copyright licenses say you can do 1 or 2, under certain conditions.

The AGPL, and other EULAs, says you can NOT do 3, unless you meet certain conditions (other EULAs may, for example, limit the number of users, which would be typical for typical proprietary software server EULAs; the AGPL limits how you can serve the software, in that you must provide source changes to users of the service).

Therefore, the GPL and BSD strictly grant rights (to copy). The AGPL both grants rights to copy and restricts rights to use. It is therefore not a copyright license, but a contract, an EULA, a click-through usage agreement. And anyone who treats it as a copyright license (i.e. users are not expected to care) is doing a disservice to their users, because they are, in fact, not allowed to use the software without abiding by that contract (license).

If nginx were AGPL-licensed (thankfully it isn't), and I made a change to the source for personal use, then the AGPL would require me to stick a download link to that modified source in the footer of every website served using that copy of nginx, even if I am not serving the nginx binary itself.

The GPL is already perfectly suited to cover distributing software on the internet, as tarballs or whatever. The GPLv2 had some outdated provisions referencing a "medium" and written offers (e.g. the CD story), and the GPLv3 already covered that by saying you can just send the source via the same medium as the binary, e.g. from a network server.

The AGPL is a very different beast, and it has nothing to do with updating the GPL to allow for network transmission of the source, as you seem to imply.

Have an example: I run a Nextcloud instance for personal use. It is AGPL-licensed. Thankfully I have not made any changes to the code. However, if I touch a single php file in my /var/www/nextcloud (other than config files - hopefully, the AGPL is too vague to say for sure), that means I now need to figure out how to package and distribute that change to literally every visitor to my instance, which could be anyone on the internet (even if they just hit the login page). This is NOT possible with a purely copyright license. And my distribution did not warn me about it (like they did for proprietary software EULAs, which require an explicit ack), because they erroneously believe that the AGPL is not an EULA, because the FSF wrote it.

Does this make sense now?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by belorn on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @08:29AM (#24197810)
This kind of sillyness of calling AGPL a contract is incorrect because it assumes that copyright law only care about distribution. It does not.

It is an copyright offence to perform any of the following acts without permission of the owner:

    Copy the work.
    Rent, lend or issue copies of the work to the public.
    Perform, broadcast or show the work in public.
    *Adapt the work.*
A person who take a copyrighted software and adapts it into a online service need to get adaptation permission from the author. If the work is given out under a AGPL license then that license is proof of permission as long as the person follow the terms, just as with any other copyright license.

You do not need permissions from a copyright license unless the action a person does falls within the scope of copyright. If a person don't copy, rent, lend, issue copies, perform, broadcast, show, or adapt the work, then the AGPL conditions are irrelevant because the user do not need permission in the first place. An EULA or contract however is not limited in this way and can restrict usage of a program outside the scope of copyright.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by marcan_42 on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @10:13AM (#24198758)
Do you have any case history supporting this interpretation of copyright law?

While it is true that copyright protects the right to create derivative works, that is, in practice, usually applied to creating such derivative works and distributing them. Otherwise, scribbling with a pen on a book you bought would be a copyright violation.

Similarly, while technically running a program requires copying it into memory (and thus requires a license), no court in this day and age is likely to rule that running software which was acquired legally, but which does not come with a license to run it, is a copyright violation.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by belorn on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @01:00PM (#24201134)
Scribbling with a pen on a book you bought would be a copyright violation if it would qualify under the definition of recasting, transforming or adapting the book. It must be substantial and original. A full translation, scribbled on the side, would be a pretty obvious violation regardless if you made further copies. Similar if you bought the movie rights to distribute you still need additional permissions to add translations or to cut it into new versions. There has also been cases where a broadcasting station got sued because they added commercial breaks without having copyright permission to create new adaptations (the author had a very public opinion against commercial breaks).

The memory issue has been well discussed and handled in the past. The law has an explicit exception made with this in mind where legal owners of the software has a right to both copy and adapt software if it is an essential step towards utilization of the program. licensees however does not have this right and are restricted to the terms under the license. Naturally this is designed more towards the world of proprietary software where such distinction is more clear.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by marcan_42 on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @09:36PM (#24206316)
In the broadcasting case, obviously broadcasting/distribution was involved, which is not the case here. Do you have any examples where someone making a private modification to a copyrighted work without distribution was legally liable for it after it was discovered?

The AGPL attempts to control any changes made to the code, not just, say, a substantial refactoring or reworking. So in principle a one-line patch is sufficient to trigger AGPL clause 13.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by imtringued on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @03:09AM (#24196019)
>If nginx were AGPL-licensed (thankfully it isn't), and I made a change to the source for personal use, then the AGPL would require me to stick a download link to that modified source in the footer of every website served using that copy of nginx, even if I am not serving the nginx binary itself.

People add links to the source code because it's much less work than responding to emails. It's entirely voluntary. Users have a right to the source code of AGPL software you make accessible to them and you can satisfy that constraint any way you see fit.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by marcan_42 on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @04:41AM (#24196476)
You haven't read the license, have you? :-)

> your modified version must prominently offer all users interacting with it remotely through a computer network [...] an opportunity to receive the Corresponding Source of your version by providing access to the Corresponding Source from a network server at no charge [...]

An email does not cut it. It has to be a direct link to the source, or some kind of equivalent mechanism to directly download it from a server. Merely providing you the opportunity to ask a human for it does not cut it (an email bot might, but that'd be dumb).

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by jordigh on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @11:14AM (#24199651)
You seem to have trouble understanding that you are not the user of nginx: the users who visit your website and use nginx to serve files to themselves are the users.

Does it make sense now?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by marcan_42 on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @12:07PM (#24200411)
Copyright law doesn't say anything about users of software, it talks about copying, performing (no, you are not "performing" nginx for your remote users, that's not how it works), etc.

In fact, courts have repeatedly ruled that the output of software (i.e. the packets nginx sends over the network, but which aren't its own code) is not covered by the software's copyright itself.

If I lend you my phone, in the absence of more restrictive EULAs, and excluding media (which is reproduced verbatim by the phone), you are free to use any software on it without being subject to the copyright of said software.

Does it make sense now?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by jordigh on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @12:42PM (#24200896)
You seem to have trouble understanding that copyright is irrelevant to determining who the users of the software are. The users are the ones using the software. That there is a network between them and the software they're using is irrelevant.

Does it make sense now?

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by kazinator on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @11:25AM (#24211351)
Copyright is irrelevant also because you are not redistributing the program to those users (and possibly not at all).

Yet, the copyright law is what the AGPL is trying to wield as its basis.

It does not seem valid. Has anyone tested it in court?

I don't think that copyright can assert use restrictions. You cannot say that someone is not authorized to have a copy of something if they do not use it in such and such a way.

It's exactly like a "license" written in the flap of a book which says that you must read only the even-numbered pages. If you read any odd-numbered page, then you are breaching the license under which you're permitted to have a copy, and must destroy the book.

I would cheerfully deploy a modified AGPL program and not reveal the code to anyone. Nothing would happen at all.

I'm surprised Google are so allergic to the AGPL. If it came down to it, they could crush this bullshit in court like swatting a mosquito.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by marcan_42 on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @01:01PM (#24201158)
So you're saying that the license does not impose restrictions on users of the software, but I am not the user, so it can impose restrictions on me? Then what am I, and why does the license get to impose restrictions on me beyond copyright obligations without violating Freedom Zero?

You're grasping at straws here. There's provisions based on copyright, and then there's everything else. Redefining users to exclude the person running the server and implying that means the person running the server loses all rights under the Free Software definition is ludicrous.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by jordigh on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @01:34PM (#24201607)
You are free to run our hypotheticlly AGPLed nginx for whatever purpose you want. You can serve a military website or an online shop from our hypothetically AGPLed nginx. There are no limitations on usage. You are the user as long as you are operating and using nginx.

Once you serve to other users, though, they also become users of nginx. In this regard, you have an upstream/downstream relationship between you and the other users of nginx that you've made users by giving them access over the network.

You are still free to use nginx for your military website or your online shop or whatever. Your usage of nginx has not been restricted for any purpose.

By granting network accesss to our hypothetically AGPLed nginx, though, you now have an AGPL obligation to provide a link to the source code of nginx, in case you modified that source yourself. This isn't taking any rights away from you -- indeed, the AGPL is only granting you rights. You wouldn't have the right to even serve nginx to other users or to modify its source code if it weren't for the AGPL.

None of this is substantially different from the GPL except for the method of interaction with the software.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by kazinator on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @01:37PM (#24201635)
> This isn't taking any rights away from you -- indeed, the AGPL is only granting you rights.

Note that a shrink-wrap end-user license agreement from Adobe also doesn't take away your rights; it only grants you rights.

At least, according to copyright rhetoric.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by marcan_42 on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @09:40PM (#24206340)
This is not correct. Those agreements are based on the idea that your license to use the copyrighted software is predicated on accepting a large number of conditions outside of copyright.

Merely receiving a license-free piece of software (i.e. "all rights reserved") with no strings attached gives you a certain set of default rights (i.e. anything not in violation of copyright), such as to run it for any purpose. EULAs like a shrink-wrap agreement from Adobe, or the AGPL, then attempt to remove some of those rights.

Though, sure, you can look at it from the point of view that in the absence of a license at all, nobody would've been able to distribute the software to you in the first place, and therefore you'd have had no rights as a result.

Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th by kazinator on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @11:33AM (#24211464)
The doctrine under copyright law is that you have no right to have a copy of a work without the copyright holder's permission. From that basis, various forms of asshole on the face of this Earth, and their lawyers, have come up with various licenses that inject all sorts of behavioral conditions, far outside of the scope of copyright law, on the granting of a permission for you to have a copy. The idea is to turn the non-compliance with those conditions into copyright infringment. "Oh, you're violating clause 37? And still have a copy of the work? That's not allowed! You must comply, or else destroy the copy!"