Re:Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th
by kazinator on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @11:25AM
(#24211351)
Copyright is irrelevant also because you are not redistributing the program to those users (and possibly not at all).
Yet, the copyright law is what the AGPL is trying to wield as its basis.
It does not seem valid. Has anyone tested it in court?
I don't think that copyright can assert use restrictions. You cannot say that someone is not authorized to have a copy of something if they do not use it in such and such a way.
It's exactly like a "license" written in the flap of a book which says that you must read only the even-numbered pages. If you read any odd-numbered page, then you are breaching the license under which you're permitted to have a copy, and must destroy the book.
I would cheerfully deploy a modified AGPL program and not reveal the code to anyone. Nothing would happen at all.
I'm surprised Google are so allergic to the AGPL. If it came down to it, they could crush this bullshit in court like swatting a mosquito.
Yet, the copyright law is what the AGPL is trying to wield as its basis.
It does not seem valid. Has anyone tested it in court?
I don't think that copyright can assert use restrictions. You cannot say that someone is not authorized to have a copy of something if they do not use it in such and such a way.
It's exactly like a "license" written in the flap of a book which says that you must read only the even-numbered pages. If you read any odd-numbered page, then you are breaching the license under which you're permitted to have a copy, and must destroy the book.
I would cheerfully deploy a modified AGPL program and not reveal the code to anyone. Nothing would happen at all.
I'm surprised Google are so allergic to the AGPL. If it came down to it, they could crush this bullshit in court like swatting a mosquito.