News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by Kylekramer on Thursday April 07, 2011 @10:16AM (#2419512)
While probably the right move (no need to take responsibility for an app that is going to anger labels when your platform allows sideload), it is funny to see Google kicking out a company that is following the YouTube playbook word for word.
Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by jamesbritt on Thursday April 07, 2011 @12:59PM (#2420210)
While probably the right move (no need to take responsibility for an app that is going to anger labels when your platform allows sideload),

Doesn't this indicate that Google admits potential culpability and concedes that it is their responsibility to police what goes into their app store?

Seems a better approach would have been to shrug their shoulders and argue that the Android app store is merely an open conduit, not their curated set of apps.

The implication is that they concede responsibility for whatever they don't remove.

Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by bostonpete on Thursday April 07, 2011 @02:26PM (#2420591)
> The implication is that they concede responsibility for whatever they don't remove.

I'm not sure I agree. Just because Google is asserting the right to remove apps from the store (e.g. to keep strategic partners from flipping out) doesn't mean that they're conceding that they're under any obligation to do so.

Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by jamesbritt on Thursday April 07, 2011 @06:46PM (#2421536)
* ... doesn't mean that they're conceding that they're under any obligation to do so.*

Maybe not, but it seems like the kind of crack in the door a lawyer might jump at next time someone complains that an app offends them, or is copying their idea, or whatever.

Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by ffumarola on Thursday April 07, 2011 @10:31AM (#2419582)
"following the YouTube playbook word for word"

Exactly, I guess they don't want to get in the middle of it. The disadvantages of building on someone else's platform, I suppose.

Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by jokermatt999 on Thursday April 07, 2011 @12:55PM (#2420186)
It's less of a risk here though, because as pointed out elsewhere in the thread, it's still easily available through http://mobile.grooveshark.com/android. The loss of discoverability from being on the Market sucks, but the publicity from being removed reminded me to install it at least.

Overall though, I think the ability to have your users install your app even if you get kicked off of the market is a fundamental advantage that Android has. It's going to be a detriment if you're a paid app, but if you're ad-supported, being kicked off the Market is not nearly as big of an issue. You just need to solve the publicity/discoverability issue.

Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by ffumarola on Thursday April 07, 2011 @01:48PM (#2420430)
Not all Android devices allow side loading, to my knowledge. So it doesn't seem to be an inherent advantage of Android. After all, you CAN jail break your iPhone.
Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by gcb on Thursday April 07, 2011 @10:57AM (#2419680)
They don't want competition.

As the parent stated, that is youtube starting.

And now they also have to protect amazon mp3 investment on them.

Seems weird, but I bet theres lots of politics between google and amazon over android

Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by trotsky on Thursday April 07, 2011 @12:21PM (#2420055)
Isn't the planned google music (set to launch in 2011) service going to be more or less in direct competition with Amazon MP3 & Cloud player? I doubt they are protecting Amazon interests here.
Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by gcb on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:50AM (#2422629)
Are you pretty sure it will not be a way to direct people to amazon?

Google shopping is not about google selling stuff... and guess who's usually on top

Either way, I'm still sure I'm not allowed to uninstall amazon mp3 app from my android super open and free dev phone

Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by trotsky on Friday April 08, 2011 @09:57PM (#2426267)
I think that it's true. They have been trying to secure streaming and sales licenses from the labels for some time now. I suppose if that falls through (the labels are brutal at this stage of negotiations) they might team up with amazon, but I'd be surprised if that happened.

They do have some precedent here, consider the google books ebookstore: http://books.google.com/ebooks

Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by taylorlb on Thursday April 07, 2011 @01:57PM (#2420460)
I think the paths are similar, but there is a key difference for me: YouTube's success didn't initially 100% rely on using other peoples copyrighted works without permission or compensation. No doubt music videos etc. helped immensely but funny cat videos and other amateur goofy content was a big part of its success. Whereas with Grooveshark, I am fairly confident that amateur authorized content doesn't factor into the equation.

That said, if the major music rights holders would just license to them from the start at affordable rates they wouldn't need to violate copyright so I suppose it's a bit of a chicken and egg problem.

Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by MatthewPhillips on Thursday April 07, 2011 @10:46AM (#2419626)
Is it? I know that YouTube's early days were similar. But does Grooveshark have any content deals, because otherwise it is nearly 100% copyright infringement.
Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by Kylekramer on Thursday April 07, 2011 @11:32AM (#2419839)
Deals with these labels: http://grooveshark.com/labelslist

TL;DR They got EMI (following a lawsuit), a few prominent indies like Merge, and 99% nobodies. Alongside a still in process suit from Universal Music Group.

Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by jawn on Thursday April 07, 2011 @10:53AM (#2419666)
Grooveshark has a content deal with EMI. I'm sure there are deals with other labels as well.
Re:Google kicks GrooveShark out of the Android Market by MatthewPhillips on Thursday April 07, 2011 @10:57AM (#2419679)
Good to know, thanks.