Re:The Pirate Bay Wants to Encrypt the Entire Internet
by martey on Thursday July 10, 2008 @12:23AM
(#242026)
I think the most useful part of this article is the last paragraph, where the author notes that none of The Pirate Bay's lofty projects have come to fruition yet. Until there is something that I can download and install on my computer, this is just vaporware.
Re:The Pirate Bay Wants to Encrypt the Entire Internet
by bluelu on Thursday July 10, 2008 @04:58AM
(#242203)
Their projects only succeed if they use illegal content to push them.
This was also the reason youtube succeeded and right now they are only selling ads for about 4% of all content, because for the rest of the content, the original post doesn't own the copyright.
Re:The Pirate Bay Wants to Encrypt the Entire Internet
by michael_nielsen on Wednesday July 09, 2008 @11:18PM
(#241969)
John Gilmore (employee number 5 at Sun, and co-founder of the EFF and cypherpunks) tried something similar in the late 1990s: http://www.toad.com/swan.html
Re:The Pirate Bay Wants to Encrypt the Entire Internet
by huhtenberg on Thursday July 10, 2008 @01:54PM
(#242689)
Just to add to the above - FreeS/WAN project was too heavy on an ideology and it had a major impact on their technical decisions. They refused to support DES, because it was weak, nor did they want to include X.509 (PKI) support, because it was a hierarchy "controlled by selected ones". This limited practical usefulness of the project and it was one of the primary causes of its demise. Others were the fact that it was hard to install (required patching and rebuilding the kernel from the source) and tricky to configure.
There is a fork called strongSwan, which is still being developed even though it's Linux-specific and there is a native IPsec implementation in Linux 2.6.
Re:The Pirate Bay Wants to Encrypt the Entire Internet
by reazalun on Wednesday July 09, 2008 @11:32PM
(#241980)
From the article, it seems his goal was not met yet. However he is very proactive in fighting the illegal net spying. Maybe the Pirate Bay guys should consult him too.
Re:The Pirate Bay Wants to Encrypt the Entire Internet
by iamelgringo on Thursday July 10, 2008 @03:42AM
(#242158)
Well, we have to do something with all those extra cores we're getting courtesy of the hardware guys. We might as well encrypt/decrypt the data that we're using with the extra cores that we're going to have.
Unlike in IPv4, encryption and authentication is a
mandatory feature of IPv6. Those features are normally
implemented using IPsec (which can be also used by IPv4).
Seems to me that if support for encryption is mandatory for IPv6, even if it's not on by default, using that somehow would be a better route than writing your own New Thing.
Re:The Pirate Bay Wants to Encrypt the Entire Internet
by aggieben on Friday July 11, 2008 @03:21PM
(#243892)
The essence of IPSec is a mandatory feature of IPv6. I don't see how this could mean anything other than "packets don't have to be encrypted by default, but encrypted packets must be allowed to be sent and received at any time". That makes IPv6 very much not orthogonal to the topic at hand.
What I'm trying to get to is this: why are they trying to figure out how to encrypt the internet when they can just use IPv6 (presuming that existing implementations support all the "mandatory" features)? The only rational answer I can come up with off the top of my head is if they think governments will have backdoors for transparently observing the traffic unencrypted, but that wasn't mentioned in the article as a rationale for anything.
Re:The Pirate Bay Wants to Encrypt the Entire Internet
by josefresco on Thursday July 10, 2008 @12:26PM
(#242588)
Too bad TorPark (aka xBrowser and a lot of other things) swayed too far from the Mozilla/Open Source path and into the hands of a semi shady privacy company.
Re:The Pirate Bay Wants to Encrypt the Entire Internet
by wmf on Thursday July 10, 2008 @02:19PM
(#242726)
Onion routing solves a different problem: anonymizing traffic. This "project" doesn't aim to provide anonymity, just resistance against sniffing and some MITMs. Onion routing provides encryption as a side effect of anonymity, but it's massively inefficient compared to just encryption.
Re:The Pirate Bay Wants to Encrypt the Entire Internet
by aggieben on Friday July 11, 2008 @04:11PM
(#243955)
Yeah, onion routing will grind your data rates way, way down. It also very much works against the inertia of the internet as it stands, which it turns out to not be all that useful.
This was also the reason youtube succeeded and right now they are only selling ads for about 4% of all content, because for the rest of the content, the original post doesn't own the copyright.
(only have german source http://www.heise.de/newsticker/Zeitung-Google-von-YouTube-We...)
It was officially shut down in April 2004 - http://www.freeswan.org/ending_letter.html
There is a fork called strongSwan, which is still being developed even though it's Linux-specific and there is a native IPsec implementation in Linux 2.6.
I agree that the Pirate Bay should join forces with the IETF BTNS effort that is already underway, but this is still orthogonal to IPv4/IPv6.
What I'm trying to get to is this: why are they trying to figure out how to encrypt the internet when they can just use IPv6 (presuming that existing implementations support all the "mandatory" features)? The only rational answer I can come up with off the top of my head is if they think governments will have backdoors for transparently observing the traffic unencrypted, but that wasn't mentioned in the article as a rationale for anything.
Was a cool project.