Re:France outlaws hashed passwords...
by yannickmahe on Thursday April 07, 2011 @04:30AM
(#2418718)
According to other sources, you have to pay a fine of 3850 Euros for every time you don't comply to a request. That amount is low enough that the cost/benefit of giving out the passwords is not evidently on the side of complying with the decree. I'm not sure how many companies will rather pay than give out the data.
Is that 3850 euros per password?
Re:France outlaws hashed passwords...
by yannickmahe on Thursday April 07, 2011 @04:49AM
(#2418765)
Not sure. It's per request, but I'm guessing they only ask for the info of one person at a time.
I wonder if resetting the password counts as complying with the request.
Re:France outlaws hashed passwords...
by pavel_lishin on Thursday April 07, 2011 @11:40AM
(#2419872)
They could always pass the cost onto the consumer!
Re:France outlaws hashed passwords...
by martin_kirch on Thursday April 07, 2011 @05:09AM
(#2418798)
Actually, some Internet companies are not only refusing to comply but also suing the state against this law.
the important thing is that you don't lay down to fools
Is this really a good idea when the fools are the government?
Refusing to comply with actual laws makes it quite likely that you'll be sued or arrested, which isn't a great idea for either a business or a personal project. There are obviously times when civil disobedience is called for, but I don't think this is one of them.
If the government has no power to hurt you, then it seems like an excellent plan.
Once you get to be big enough, you get to bully the government. So get big fast.
That's right! Don't give in the illusion of creating a just legal system of government! Be an outlaw!
Wrap it up nicely if you must, say you've lost the key or something, but the important thing is that you don't lay down to fools.