Wrap it up nicely if you must, say you've lost the key or something, but the important thing is that you don't lay down to fools.
Is this really a good idea when the fools are the government?
Refusing to comply with actual laws makes it quite likely that you'll be sued or arrested, which isn't a great idea for either a business or a personal project. There are obviously times when civil disobedience is called for, but I don't think this is one of them.
Once you get to be big enough, you get to bully the government. So get big fast.
If I had to run, say, Wordpress or SMF for a French client, I'd probably do as perlgeek suggests, and just hook the password create/change function to also store a public-key-encrypted version just for law enforcement / compliance purposes, and let the 3rd party software continue to authenticate as normal.
Then log the plaintext passwords to a different file, encrypted with a public key. The corresponding private key would live on a separate machine (without internet access), and would only be used in cases where it's inevitable.