News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by brainless on Saturday August 15, 2020 @11:17PM (#24174676)
I find it really fascinating to think that when 60 minutes pass on star S62, on Earth 100 minutes would have passed in the same duration. This is Sci-Fi territory in my mind. I am having all sorts of difficulty imagining some implications of this.

Does this roughly mean, things are "sped up" in S62 from our point of view, if we could observe some activity on that star?

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by tsbinz on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:52AM (#24176058)
There is a couple of things to keep in mind.

First, like others mentioned, they are way off in the effect size, for this kind of time dilation you need 80% the speed of light, not 8%.

Second, when looking at time dilation caused by velocity, it is always necessary to say who observes what since observers that move relative to each other won't agree on which clock runs at what speed. If the star moved at 80% of the speed of light, someone on that star would say "When a 100 minutes pass here, only 60 minutes pass on Earth" while an observer on Earth would say "When 100 minutes pass here, only 60 minutes pass on that star". So both observers would say that the other's clock is running slower than their own.

This answers a part of your last question - time dilation always makes clocks appear to tick slower than your clock if they move relative to you.

There are other effects that can make things appear "sped up", there's all kind of odd things happening when you go to high relativistic speeds ...

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by eru on Sunday August 16, 2020 @04:43AM (#24176250)
> Second, when looking at time dilation caused by velocity, it is always necessary to say who observes what since observers that move relative to each other won't agree on which clock runs at what speed.

Interestlingly, the universe does have a preferred velocity (and thus a preferred inertial frame). It's the speed and direction that makes the cosmic background radiation not have a dipole.

https://astronomy.swin.edu.au/cosmos/c/Cosmic+Microwave+Back...

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by tinco on Sunday August 16, 2020 @04:59AM (#24176319)
So this velocity must be relative to some common point/area right? Like the center of the event that caused it?

When they say "300,000 years after the big bang" how do they count that, is that seconds in some periodic movement inside matter or radiation?

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by brnt on Sunday August 16, 2020 @05:25AM (#24176408)
There is no center to the source of the background radiation, as it is was created at a moment the universe was still a fairly homogeneous soup (apparently) with these photons being created (and absorbed) everywhere roughly in equal quantity.

Only after the universe became transparent did these photons become free, and since they were produced roughly homogenously in that soup there are everywhere in the same quanitity: a background radiation.

Since they were not produced in a localized event, they won't have a center. But since they're everywhere, they are a sort of absolute reference for how fast you're going (actually that's a new and interesting idea for me too, pretty neat).

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by jstanley on Sunday August 16, 2020 @05:37AM (#24176458)
But if they're a reference for how fast you're going, aren't they also a reference for what direction you're going? Can you then not look backwards at the direction they have come from and work out the point that they all appear to originate from? And then haven't you found the centre?
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by brnt on Sunday August 16, 2020 @07:45AM (#24177019)
Imagine an omnipresent and homogeneous field, let's say an infinite field of corn. By looking at the corn, you can see how fast you're going, without that observation requiring the field to have a center.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by stallmanite on Sunday August 16, 2020 @10:19PM (#24183245)
This is a great analogy, finally “clicked” for me after trying to understand this concept for a while. Thank you.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by ben_w on Sunday August 16, 2020 @06:03AM (#24176573)
They are coming at you from every direction at once.

What you’re asking is analogous to asking where the center of the Earth is on a map of the surface, and arguing it must exist because of how things on the horizon change when you move.

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by thedufer on Sunday August 16, 2020 @11:30AM (#24178552)
The reference velocity is the one such that you see an equal amount of cosmic background radiation in every direction. If you're moving relative to it, you'll see extra radiation from in front of you (much like how you see extra cars moving in the opposite direction from you on a highway).
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by onemiketwelve on Monday August 17, 2020 @11:53AM (#24188385)
I never got a real answer to this thought experiment. It's something I always thought about but I've been too lazy and dumb to figure out. So say two people are hanging out in space and their watches are synced to 12:00, then one person blasts off, turns around then comes back.

`Clocks slow down when they move in relation to you`

So to the "stationary" person, the clock of the person who zoomed off would be behind. But since it's relative, to the "zoomer" the stationary person went out and back. So then to the zoomer the stationary person's watch would be slower.

But which one is it? Do they end up showing the same time?

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by mb7733 on Monday August 17, 2020 @12:18PM (#24188656)
Things aren't symetrical because only one of the two underwent acceleration. So one of them was not in an inertial frame of reference.

This is a famous paradox, see here for a full discussion/resolution: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twin_paradox

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by pdonis on Sunday August 16, 2020 @12:27AM (#24175116)
> I find it really fascinating to think that when 60 minutes pass on star S62, on Earth 100 minutes would have passed in the same duration.

It doesn't; phys.org is way off in their math (if they even bothered to check the math).

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by perbu on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:12AM (#24175888)
Way off.

60 minutes, 11 seconds on earth would be more like it.

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by tsbinz on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:34AM (#24175968)
It looks like someone (in addition to forgetting to clearly state where the observer is) forgot a zero when putting it in the calculator, at 80% of the speed of light you get the time dilation factor they state.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by mikro2nd on Sunday August 16, 2020 @10:54AM (#24178284)
Furthermore they betray a Northist bias that I find disappointing in an Astronomy article, when they say, "In the Fall of 2022..." For half the terraqueous globe it will, in fact, be Spring. And anyway, I think they really meant "Autumn", dammit! </curmudgeonly>
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by wtmt on Saturday August 15, 2020 @11:31PM (#24174766)
> This is Sci-Fi territory in my mind.

Simpler Sci without the Fi, but still incredible to lay people, is that earth’s gravity and the movement of the satellites cause time dilation that’s accounted for in GPS satellite clocks and the receiver clocks. It’s amazing how much the Special Relativity and General Relativity influence our daily lives.

See: The Wikipedia entry on GPS.

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by spyder on Sunday August 16, 2020 @12:33AM (#24175152)
Yes:

Time go faster at the top of a building compared to the bottom.

https://wtamu.edu/~cbaird/sq/2013/06/24/does-time-go-faster-...

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by saagarjha on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:48AM (#24176045)
Well, it’s that and also their speed, the effects of which are predicted by general and special relativity respectively.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by saagarjha on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:47AM (#24176041)
> It’s amazing how much the Special Relativity and General Relativity influence our daily lives.

I mean aside from the obvious one of it being an underlying theory for how the universe works and without it a lot of stuff would break it is really not that huge a part of most people’s lives. Sure, the GPS example is a fun one to bring up, but other than that there’s just a few things that we interact with that actually have a noticeable effect due to relativity, like some of the very characteristic properties of heavier metals or the design of particle accelerators, which many people used to have in their house until recently. And I guess you could go out and look at Einstein’s cross. But other than that it really doesn’t affect us that much.

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by chrisweekly on Sunday August 16, 2020 @08:18AM (#24177178)
Ha! Apparently other mods didn't, but I appreciate your sense of humor. :)
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by brainless on Sunday August 16, 2020 @05:35AM (#24176443)
You are absolutely right. I guess I was just fascinated because of the stated difference, which some have pointed out is off by a factor of 10! Yikes, so much for reporting.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by wruza on Sunday August 16, 2020 @04:07AM (#24176116)
It barely mentions the effect. Better see https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Error_analysis_for_the_Globa...

tl;dr we perceive gps satellites clock ticks faster due to lower gravity (+46us/day), but slower due to motion (-7us/day).

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by mensetmanusman on Sunday August 16, 2020 @08:55AM (#24177356)
You are re-experiencing the thought process of Einstein.

The recognition that there are consequences to our understanding of time if the speed of light is constant in every reference frame was earth shattering in the science community a century ago.

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by mulmen on Sunday August 16, 2020 @12:13AM (#24175029)
How would FTL communication work? Let’s assume we can literally communicate over any distance instantly. Do we come across as a bit slow to anyone orbiting star S62? “Wow, these earthlings sure are hard to work with. They just can’t seem to keep up!”

Do we have to remember that the people we communicate with have different experiences of time?

Gender identity, sexual orientation, native language. Temporal perception?

Honestly it doesn’t seem hard to overcome. But I do love the idea of shipping off a problem and having it done 20% faster.

But wait, aren’t they 20% farther along in evolutionary terms too? So isn’t that like a multimillion year advantage?

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by doctor_eval on Sunday August 16, 2020 @04:07AM (#24176112)
As others have commented, you can’t send information faster than light. This is because time itself doesn’t run off any kind of central clock. The relationship between two events in time changes depending on where the observer is. There is no way to perfectly synchronise two events which are separated in space. This is called the relativity of simultaneity. FTL communication results in paradoxes because of this.

There is an awesome article on wikipedia that describes it more. Totally blew my mind.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativity_of_simultaneity

As an aside, I’ve found this to be a helpful way to visualise data flowing through distributed systems...

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by mulmen on Sunday August 16, 2020 @07:53AM (#24177056)
Right but the purpose of the thought experiment is to consider the speed of thought processing, not information delay.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by jedberg on Sunday August 16, 2020 @12:59AM (#24175284)
> Do we have to remember that the people we communicate with have different experiences of time?

This is already true on Earth. Different people process information at different speeds. Think about when you're talking to someone who is elderly. Do you slow down a bit so they have a chance to keep up?

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by mulmen on Sunday August 16, 2020 @02:05AM (#24175619)
Yep, exactly. I was just chatting with someone in the park today who was much slower to process and respond than I am accustomed to. I was able to adapt to that and we had a nice conversation. It’s definitely a thing. Communication is messy.

I do think this thought experiment is a bit different though. In the sense that everyone orbiting S62 is faster than us, by a considerable margin. There will still be individual variances of course but the baseline moves. It’s not just a way you adapt to an individual but to an entire group of people, based on properties of their location.

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by daveFNbuck on Sunday August 16, 2020 @09:15AM (#24177492)
From reading the comments here, the margin isn't that much, and from their perspective we're the faster ones. Relativity is weird.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by prox on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:28AM (#24175950)
Reminds me of that star trek voyager episode with the fast moving planet “Blink of an eye” Hours in our universe, is centuries on this planet that orbits at an incredible velocity.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Sunday August 16, 2020 @08:33AM (#24177244)
That episode was a (poor) adaptation of Robert L. Forward's first contact novel "Dargon's Egg". Humanity discovers life on a neutron star, where the intense gravity (billions of gs) enables degenerate matter chemistry where interactions are orders of magnitude faster than in conventional matter.

I highly recommend it.

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by prox on Sunday August 16, 2020 @08:49AM (#24177321)
On my read list, thank you!
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by andrepd on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:06AM (#24175862)
>Let’s assume we can literally communicate over any distance instantly.

We can't, that's the whole point of relativity.

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by Daniel_sk on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:18AM (#24175911)
Nothing travels faster than light, not even information in any form.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by praptak on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:41AM (#24176011)
Nothing travels faster than c but light sometimes travels slower than that.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by saagarjha on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:49AM (#24176051)
Always, unless you happen to have a way of making perfect vacuums ;)
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by praptak on Sunday August 16, 2020 @10:58AM (#24178324)
That too, but I meant actual cases when it is possible to make things go faster than light in a given medium, see also Cherenkov radiation.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by mulmen on Sunday August 16, 2020 @07:47AM (#24177025)
If the cow is a sphere...
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by thedufer on Sunday August 16, 2020 @11:39AM (#24178623)
But the particular simplifying assumption you made invalidates the whole thought experiment. Who is moving faster actually depends on where you're looking from. This turns into complete nonsense if you assume instantaneous communication - who needs to slow down for whom?
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by progval on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:27AM (#24175943)
> Let’s assume we can literally communicate over any distance instantly. Do we come across as a bit slow to anyone orbiting star S62?

Communicating "instantly" would be a paradox.

Remember there is no absolute reference to which speeds are measured, aka. a "luminiferous aether". Its existence was disproved in the 19th century.

So Earthers are slow for observers on that star, but inhabitants of that star are also slow for Earthers; because speed is relative. Hence the name relativity.

And the reason it doesn't result in a paradox with light-speed communication is that the increasing (resp. decreasing) latency between the two account for the increasing (resp. decreasing) difference of time caused by this discrepancy of an object speeding up away from (resp. toward) the other.

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by floydnoel on Saturday August 15, 2020 @11:39PM (#24174817)
I think they’ll appear slower to us. We’d be sped up to them. I’d love to be able to travel at half the speed of light, a few months and I’d be able to return far in the future.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by saagarjha on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:38AM (#24175988)
I’d hate to burst your bubble, but if you travelled at half the speed of light for what you think is a couple months, you’d come back in…a couple months. The dilation effect is only about 15% at that speed.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by yodsanklai on Sunday August 16, 2020 @07:58AM (#24177080)
This is the plot of the book "planet of the apes". The explorers think they are on a different planet, until they realize they are in a future earth (because they travel at near the speed of light in their spaceship). (hope I don't spoil anything, it's such a classic).
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by dragontamer on Sunday August 16, 2020 @08:44AM (#24177292)
YOU MANIAC!

You spoiled the movie.

Damn you. Damn you all to hell!

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by vagab0nd on Sunday August 16, 2020 @01:34PM (#24179577)
Why do you do such a thing? You hope you don't spoil it but you just did the opposite.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by caf on Sunday August 16, 2020 @08:05AM (#24177116)
Time there appears to pass slower to us (an observer here).

But time here also appears to pass slower to them (an observer there)!

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by j15e on Saturday August 15, 2020 @11:33PM (#24174785)
I think its the opposite: things are slowed down on S62 so they can’t reach speed of light. That is how you could (in theory) go in the future because earth time would go faster if you were on S62. So if you could watch it, it would be slower?
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by neltnerb on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:42AM (#24176016)
Yet from S62's perspective, we're the ones moving.

It will be hard to imagine if you try to retain the concept of some universal clock. The important thing is that if you actually traveled from one to the other that during your accelerations time would warp around you so as to perfectly make both sides local clocks correct.

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by samus on Sunday August 16, 2020 @07:36AM (#24176971)
From S62's perspective, _everyone_ is moving. They would infer that S62 is the oddball, and not the galaxy around them.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by neltnerb on Sunday August 16, 2020 @11:51AM (#24178740)
Sure, and knowing that they're the oddball doesn't mean their physics is any different locally.

This is the core concept of special relativity from which the rest is derived, neither of us is special in how our environment behaves. Whether you're on the spaceship traveling at 0.99c relative to earth or "at rest" (both are actually at rest but hopefully you know what I mean) everything feels the same as long as you are not accelerating.

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by vagab0nd on Sunday August 16, 2020 @01:39PM (#24179612)
But S62 is special because it's constantly accelerating very fast (going in orbit). And that makes it special and not equivalent to us. Twin paradox is very similar. It's an apparent paradox but not real.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by thdrdt on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:43AM (#24176025)
Last week I watched the movie Interstellar and I still don't get why the main character could be younger than his daughter when he returns from space.

And I also don't get your comment. Probably because I don't get relativity.

If we send a clock into space it will just tick away seconds (a unit designed by people). When it will return back to earth years later in my mind it just ticked away the same amount of time as it would have on earth.

What am I missing about relativity?

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by qppo on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:55AM (#24176067)
Think about the starting positions on a track.

The track is divided into lanes and each player is set backwards based on their lane by a fixed distance, despite the fact the finish line is in the same position. This is because of the curvature of the track - if everyone started at the same "line" across all lanes, the runners at the outer lanes would be running a further distance than those on the inner lanes!

Gravity does the same thing to time itself. The curvature is not of a track but of spacetime.

In Gravity, the main character starts at an inner lane and his daughter at an outer one - but the starting line is the same across all lanes. Gravity bends spacetime, such that the inner lane is shorter than the outer lane (in terms of distance in time). So when they ultimately arrive at the finish line, the daughter has traversed a longer path in the time dimension than her father.

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by chrisweekly on Sunday August 16, 2020 @08:22AM (#24177202)
Awesome analogy!
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by p1mrx on Sunday August 16, 2020 @06:39AM (#24176733)
These minutephysics videos provide some idea of what's happening:

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bg9MVRQYmBQ

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0iJZ_QGMLD0

(Although the time dilation in Interstellar is due to gravity, not high-speed travel.)

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by TACIXAT on Sunday August 16, 2020 @04:12AM (#24176137)
Light travels at a fixed speed relative to the observer. If you shine it from a train it will move away from you at the speed of light. I am not standing on that train, it still moves away from me at the speed of light. This is where time dilation comes from.

The classic example is a clock of light ticking between two mirrors. If you are moving with that clock it is ticking at the speed of light. If I am in a frame of reference where the clock is moving perpendicular to the light tick's path, the light will have a greater distance to cover. [1] Since the speed is fixed to me, this tick is slower.

1. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/8/8e/Ti...

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by faeyanpiraat on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:52AM (#24176059)
It’s simple: You are familiar with how temperature works, right?

Imagine the same volumetric difference exists in 3d space, but the different regions are not hotter/colder, but time goes faster/slower.

So You get two identical clocks, showing the same time, and move one of them into a “slow time” region (which would be a star moving very fast (8% of lightspeed). Let some time pass, then re-join the two clocks.

Since they spent some time in regions with different “speed of time” they’ll show a different time.

I might be wrong though, I’m not a professional.

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by chillee on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:46AM (#24176035)
It will have ticked away less seconds. Time runs slower the faster you move. From the perspective of each individual person they wouldn't be able to tell the difference, but when they come back together they'll have passed different amounts of time.
Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by thdrdt on Sunday August 16, 2020 @04:11AM (#24176130)
But doesn't Einstein not talk about how you observe the clock when you move away from the clock? So the clock keeps ticking the same time but you can't observe it because you are traveling at the speed of light.

So when you travel away from the earth at the speed of light you can't see the rotarion of the earth. But when you move back to the earth you are still just as old as the people who were the same age as you when you left?

Re:Fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light by ben_w on Sunday August 16, 2020 @06:18AM (#24176645)
I’m going to try a different thought experiment than the others.

Imagine your clock is an LED, a light sensor, and a mirror. The “tick” of this clock is: the LED sends out a brief flash of light, which travels to the mirror, bounces off, and returns to the sensor.

If this clock is stationary relative to you, the time of that tick is the distance between the three components divided by the speed of light (c = d / t).

If it is moving relative to you, the light has to be at an angle, shining at where the mirror will be by the time the light gets there. This is a longer distance, and so it ticks more slowly from your perspective.

Every atom in your body, or in a clock, is held together by forces that behave like the light in the example clock.

Give two people clocks and have them move relative to each other, and both think the other is slow. This leads to the “twins paradox”, and while I can say the answer involves acceleration, I don’t fully intuit it and can’t help you with it.