This isn't even just to protect the student, and I expect that the rule was originally developed when universities didn't care about the potential for the student being abused: it also causes a potential for unfairness to everyone else, especially when the relationship is clandestine.
Academia is somewhat unusual in that relationships within research communities and universities need to be allowed, are rather common and accepted, and often even need to be accommodated by universities. Strict restrictions on them at some universities in the past actually caused serious problems at times. Many situations are accepted, so long as they are appropriately handled, even when there are close professional connections involved, and even, sometimes, between faculty and graduate students, when the student isn't their student.
But sleeping with your students has always been a deadly sin in academia. And this appears to be a case of someone trying to argue that, while he slept with his student, she wasn't really his student at the time. That's a difficult argument to make.
I have a few teachers and professors in my family, and get to hear stories about tenured professors and the antics they get into. According to them, there's one thing that tenured professors know they can't do and that is sleeping with their students.
> A bunch of innuendo that he was only fired over it because he mentioned opposing some kind of affirmative action in a hiring committee, but he doesn't prove that was why and doesn't give the committee "due process" to defend themselves.
The author ran to a rag that would publish his story without doing any investigative journalism behind it. He knew the audience would take what he claims at face value, and low and behold, that is what's happening.