News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Montessori Mafia by ladon86 on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @03:23PM (#2416532)
I went to a Waldorf/Steiner school, which shares some of these traits such as the lack of a focus on assessment and grading and the emphasis on creativity.

We weren't taught the alphabet until the age of about 6-7 and basic arithmetic at 7-8. We did begin learning foreign languages at age 6, however. In practice my older brother taught me to read and count well before the Steiner curriculum did, but I still think that the education was very valuable.

I think that creativity in adults is often stifled because they don't want to "get it wrong". People are afraid of trying their hand at a new skill or taking a risk on a new idea because they are "realistic" about their chances of success. Children just do it anyway. I think that Steiner schools encourage this attitude, and no doubt Montessori schools do the same.

There's a reason the really big hitters are often first-time entrepreneurs - they are naive enough to try. Creativity works the same way.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by kwantam on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @06:29PM (#2417267)
My then-girlfriend and I did some work to help start a Waldorf school in western Massachusetts, so I've had a bit of direct experience with Waldorf schools despite not having attended one, and I agree with most of your assessment: the focus on creativity / learning to teach yourself is a huge departure from the traditional approach, "here is how we solve this kind of problem, now practice on these other, nearly identical problems."

One problem I noticed with the particular school we were helping to start was that the majority of the parents were technophobic to the point of hysteria: they literally asked me not to bring my laptop to meetings. As far as I can tell, this isn't a necessary feature of such schools. The general lesson, for me, is that in settings like this (e.g., an alternative educational facility bootstrapped by a small community) the school can take on the pathologies of the community, with potentially undesirable results.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by ladon86 on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @06:56PM (#2417348)
Actually that isn't unique to the school you worked at, it's a philosophical feature of the education system. I wasn't allowed to use a computer until I was perhaps 11 years old, and then only sparingly. I don't think it affected my later abilities, and I was incredibly excited once I got the chance to code at home!

I think this came about partly as an extension of Steiner's views on television as something that stunts imagination and creativity. The first 7 years of the education have a very strong focus on mental imagery, and there is probably a belief that viewing concrete depictions of concepts on a computer is harmful.

I happen to believe that a computer can allow increased exploration of the imagination when used for creative tasks, but in the 90's schools were mostly using them for looking at Encarta and so on. That's exactly what Steiner schools want to avoid for their younger children.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by gnosis on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @09:26PM (#2417805)
"I think this came about partly as an extension of Steiner's views on television as something that stunts imagination and creativity."

I wasn't aware Rudolph Steiner had any views on television, since he died in 1925, before even the earliest television sets were commercially available.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by gmac on Thursday April 07, 2011 @05:04AM (#2418794)
It's certainly true though that Steiner schools tend to be very down on TV, and I have to feel that if the alternative is some kind of creative or social or engaged-in-the-real-world activity then the alternative is almost certainly better.
Re:The Montessori Mafia by Ratfish on Thursday April 07, 2011 @05:03AM (#2418791)
Can confirm technophobia in the New Zealand Steiner system too. I believe things have improved somewhat, but TV was definitely the Antichrist.
Re:The Montessori Mafia by smilliken on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @07:45PM (#2417521)
As a counter-point, using computers was an essential part of my education when I attended a Montessori school. I agree with your conclusion though; schools like this might easily adopt the "pathologies of the community".

As an aside, I think the biggest benefits I received from attending Montessori were independence and self-motivation-- I was never forced to learned something, I had to want to learn it first and pursue it myself.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by brlewis on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @09:57PM (#2417863)
At my kids' Montessori school they begin using computers in 4th grade and are required to own one in 7th-8th grade, so my experience is the same as yours. However, I wouldn't call it a "counterpoint" since Waldorf and Montessori are different.
Re:The Montessori Mafia by grinich on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @04:32PM (#2416843)

    I think that creativity in adults is often stifled because they don't 
    want to "get it wrong". People are afraid of trying their hand at a 
    new skill or taking a risk on a new idea because they are "realistic" 
    about their chances of success.
There is a fantastic TED talk by Sir Ken Robinson on this exact subject. By far one of my favorites.

http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/eng/ken_robinson_says_schools_...

Re:The Montessori Mafia by stretchwithme on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @07:10PM (#2417395)
That is an excellent talk. The dude is hilarious.
Re:The Montessori Mafia by Alex3917 on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @04:06PM (#2416742)
"There's a reason the really big hitters are often first-time entrepreneurs - they are naive enough to try."

I think it's often because they don't understand the difference between a good product and a good business, so their expected outcomes tend to be at the extremes. Some of them end up doing ridiculously well, but overall I wouldn't consider not understanding lead gen, sales cycles, margins, cashflow, lifetime customer value, etc. to be a virtue.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by aik on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @11:10PM (#2418013)
I don't understand, why exactly don't they understand any of those things? I would expect them to be exceptional at them.
Re:The Montessori Mafia by Groxx on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @05:08PM (#2416971)
>they don't want to "get it wrong"

I, thankfully, realized this pretty early on, with help from my siblings. Collectively, we quit caring about gold stars, and started to actually learn. IMO, the main problem is that we're taught that it's bad to be wrong, and not good enough to try to outweigh the risks if you're not already fluent in the area. Success is essentially all that's valued at both an educational and social level, which entirely ignores the value of actually learning something, improving your future attempts.

tl;dr: "Win or go home" is killing our minds.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by paganel on Thursday April 07, 2011 @04:47AM (#2418760)
> Success is essentially all that's valued at both an educational and social level, which entirely ignores the value of actually learning something, improving your future attempts.

Which I find quite strange, especially as our Western culture wouldn't have existed without Socrates, who championed the exact same ideas you're talking about :)

Re:The Montessori Mafia by qaexl on Thursday April 07, 2011 @06:19AM (#2418952)
How's that Socrates championed these ideas on success? I'm curious. I never studied Socrates in detail and the closest I've come are hodgepodge collection of folklore. Do you have any quotes or references?
Re:The Montessori Mafia by paganel on Thursday April 07, 2011 @08:17AM (#2419161)
> I'm curious. I never studied Socrates in detail and the closest I've come are hodgepodge collection of folklore

First and most important thing, when reading Plato you always hear Socrates say again and again that one should "know himself" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Know_thyself#By_Plato). I don't have any exact citation at hand, you can find the exact links on wikipedia, but this theme seams to permeate all his speeches. Sometimes even if it's not said in plain words you kind of feel that that's what he has been after all along, i.e. a better understanding of oneself.

And there's also Socrate's mistrust regarding books, which isn't directed at the physical objects, but more at what the books represent, condensed wisdom that many of us already take for granted without questioning. In certain ways that's very similar to what the modern educational system does to today's kids, I mean we take lots of things for granted without bothering of thinking with our heads anymore.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by cwp on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @07:03PM (#2417373)
My Mom was a Montessori teacher. For a couple of years when I was a kid, we rented a house from a Waldorf teacher who lived in the basement. The clash of pedagogical philosophies was epic.
Re:The Montessori Mafia by aik on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @11:11PM (#2418014)
I'm hooked. Please explain how?
Re:The Montessori Mafia by cwp on Thursday April 07, 2011 @01:38AM (#2418344)
Ok, take math. The Waldorf argument went something like this: "Little children can't absorb abstractions so we don't teach math until they're ready." The Montessori argument goes like this: "Little children can't absorb abstractions so we teach math by making it concrete. We don't introduce the abstractions until they're ready."

There was a lot of that agree-on-the-facts-but-reach-different-conclusions. The conversation would go "Yeah, sure. Yup. Yup. WTF?"

Re:The Montessori Mafia by chalst on Thursday April 07, 2011 @03:46AM (#2418611)
This, the Montessori view, is really accepted wisdom now. It was only in the crazy days of New Maths that any educators thought that the right way to teach children was to give them a "foundation" consisting of the most general abstractions possible that everything else could be built upon. Think Bourbaki for children.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicolas_Bourbaki

Re:The Montessori Mafia by il on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @04:24PM (#2416817)
I think it comes down to the fact that, considering the work involved and that the majority of startups fail, it's never an economically rational decision to work on a startup. Realistic to most people means in the "real world" you follow a safe familiar progression from school to entry level job to management to retirement. There are guide rails and evaluations along the way to make sure you're on track.

You found a startup because you wouldn't be happy doing anything else.

I can't imagine getting a real job. Ever. For me, the set of things I could be doing with my life is {startup}.

I remember seeing a quote from some very successful founder saying that the only reason he went into entrepreneurship is because he was completely unemployable.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by cynicalkane on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @05:34PM (#2417079)
It can be economically rational if you value things other than the expected value of your money-to-utility function.

<rant>

People forget that economics takes into account things other than money. A lot of "economic" discussion would go a lot smoother if people remembered this.

</rant>

Re:The Montessori Mafia by stretchwithme on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @07:09PM (#2417391)
Yeah, what's actually rational cannot all be put into a spreadsheet.
Re:The Montessori Mafia by brlewis on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @05:14PM (#2416997)
At the Montessori school my kids attend, children learn letters when they're ready/motivated, usually around age 3 or 4. Basic arithmetic starts around around age 4-5, typically. I don't think Waldorf/Steiner emphasizes materials the way Montessori does: http://ourdoings.com/brlewis/2006-01-21

I'm not actually sure how similar Waldorf/Steiner is to Montessori, aside from both shunning the same bad ideas.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by dhs on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @06:29PM (#2417265)
I've researched this for my children, and there seemed to be significant differences. The amount of superstition in the Steiner teachings put me off big time ("Beware of right angles and potatoes!"). Montessori makes far fewer wild assumptions.
Re:The Montessori Mafia by gmac on Thursday April 07, 2011 @05:02AM (#2418788)
I went to Steiner school, and it's true that the theory is essentially nothing-but-crazy. But the practice of it can be utterly fantastic, and at least where I went the theory was entirely unmentioned. In the final half hour of school we had a lesson on "where did the last 14 years of your education come from?" -- we apparently (for example) literally have seven bodies, but you would thankfully never have guessed it from those 14 years of education.

If I had to pick a single strength of Steiner education, it would be that it genuinely believes that traditional academic skills aren't the only skills worth having. Lots of guff is spouted elsewhere along these lines, but at Steiner school people who were good at sport or art or whatever were genuinely just as valued as geniuses in writing and maths, which gave the place a lovely ethos.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by khafra on Thursday April 07, 2011 @08:45AM (#2419226)
If there's a word for "deriving effective practice from insane theory," it's probably something like "to rudstein." Biodynamic farming uses esoteric geomancy techniques like burying a cow's horn filled with powdered quartz, and when used in vineyards yields some truly excellent wines.
Re:The Montessori Mafia by pnathan on Thursday April 07, 2011 @10:20AM (#2419534)
Say what?!

Can you elaborate more on this?

Re:The Montessori Mafia by chalst on Thursday April 07, 2011 @03:47AM (#2418617)
Plus educators at Waldorf schools tend to talk up Steiner's poisonous Anthroposophy.
Re:The Montessori Mafia by damla on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @06:38PM (#2417297)
For grading, I don't think much traditional preschools do grading. It begins usually with primary school. There may be more praises though, like drawing stars on hands, but until the age children buy such praises like 4,5.

Creativity is very important for Waldorf, but not the main issue in Montessori. For example, you must be presented by a teacher on how to work with a material (play with a Montessori toy) first. There is not much room to art, nor imaginative play in Montessori.

If Montessori has a remarkable effect on success, I think it's because it helps children the value of working hard at an early age. There are no programs to distract you. You pick something, play with it as long as you like, learn all you like from that one and continue with a more difficult one.

As there is no rush, you do your all work like wearing cloths, putting your dish to the table. Being able to do all work yourself, one very important skill that every entrepreneur must have :)

Re:The Montessori Mafia by ronnier on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @05:03PM (#2416954)
>We weren't taught the alphabet until the age of about 6-7

My daughter is 1.5 years old and knows almost all of the alphabet. Is this a good thing or bad thing?

Re:The Montessori Mafia by run4yourlives on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @08:57PM (#2417738)
It doesn't matter what she knows, it matters that you encourage her to learn more and follow where her mind takes her.

For my boys, (3.9 and 1.5 years) I looked into Waldorf and was actually completely turned off by the fact that reading was completely ignored until much, much later. (7 years) For my eldest, who is already reading 2 and 3 letter words and phonetically sounding larger ones, this would be such a set back that he would be discouraged.

I think it isn't important where he is right now, but more so that he is encouraged to continue learning and continues to have an enjoyment of learning. I think that's really where our schools fail and why a self-motivated Montessori child can be a high achiever.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by crpatino on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @05:10PM (#2416980)
Neither good or bad.

It is a clue that she probably is good at "symbolic thinking". More of this stuff to come in the near future. Just make sure she has plenty of chances to develop this (probably innate) ability.

On the other hand, as she grows up, you probably should keep an eye on her and help to mitigate any shortcomings that'd eventually show up. But this is the same with all children anyway.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by zipdog on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @05:36PM (#2417085)
It could be a clue about symbolic thinking, or it might be the result of the approach used.

I've seen an approach where letter-shaped toys are handed out as toys, which provides a concrete object to associate to the letter. Children using this seem to be able to pick up the alphabet around 1 year old fairly easily.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by Afton on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @06:16PM (#2417226)
The important thing is that, as a parent, it's easy to fall into the trap of comparing milestones. There isn't the evidence that e.g. knowing the alphabet early means being a better reader later in life. Just like early walking milestones don't lead to 'better walking'.
Re:The Montessori Mafia by ern on Thursday April 07, 2011 @08:44AM (#2419224)
Your comment resonated with me. My wife's very verbal niece could name 12 animals in a book of animals at 18 months. Her mother drilled her, and then they would take the book around to show how clever their daughter was.

I'd feel quite bad since my son was the same age and wasn't talking much, let alone identifying animals. The constant showing off and comparisons by my in-laws led to us taking him to a speech pathologist and to his pediatrician for an eval, to make sure he had no delays (he doesn't have any).

The other day, my wife realized that her niece (now over 2) couldn't identify the exact same animals, when they were in a different book, or using plastic models. She had learned the book, but didn't understand the concepts.

I've learned my lesson about comparing milestones. I suppose a professional may be able to do meaningful comparisons, but the average parent or grandparent cannot.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by Afton on Friday April 08, 2011 @03:41PM (#2425314)
Right. And yet it's hard not to feel that swell of pride when your child 'overachieves' on some milestone. But often when a child hits a milestone early, it's actually because they are doing something differently than age-equivalent children or adults do it. And that something may well be an intellectual dead end. The niece in your story may be tagging the name 'tiger' to something like length of tail, or surrounding context. And I could write books on the need for serious investigations into what kids mean when they use certain words.
Re:The Montessori Mafia by crpatino on Thursday April 07, 2011 @12:56PM (#2420189)
Yes, it could be... my comment was really more about the idea that any persistent advantage that may come out is going to be driven by the child's interests. As parents, I believe, we should encourage more than enforce.

I also think that drill down has its use, but it is reserved for cases where the kid is visibly falling behind some minimum standard. And the bar must be set really low for that. By definition, roughly 50% should be "below average" in any given skill. If the skill is important and the deviation from the norm is severe, you have to push the kid regardless.

As a personal example. At home, it is not acceptable to be unable to get yourself out of water. This is a life or death issue; so, my kids have been enrolled in swimming classes, from early age, whether they like it or not. They don't have to go in competitions, they don't even have to be fast or have a good technique... but it is not acceptable that they are not at least as good as myself. At this point, my 8yo is probably a better swimmer than either me or my wife (who was in an amateur team in her teens)... but I will never ask for more than an honest effort.

Re:The Montessori Mafia by Shorel on Thursday April 07, 2011 @02:16PM (#2420540)
Making the Roman alphabet so ingrained may make very hard to learn other alphabets, like Greek, Cyrillic, Hiragana or the Chinese one.
Re:The Montessori Mafia by igrekel on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @07:46PM (#2417524)
My son knew the alphabet too at that age. He is now 5 and has forgotten and relearned it quite a few times since then. Knowing this, I wouldn't worry about it really.
Re:The Montessori Mafia by Muzza on Thursday April 07, 2011 @04:35AM (#2418734)
> We weren't taught the alphabet until the age of about 6-7 and basic arithmetic at 7-8.

Is that strange? I started school (a "regular" one) at 7 (as is customary in Sweden) and I didn't know the entire alphabet or basic arithmetic then. None of my classmates did.