But by prohibiting apps from even telling the user about alternate payments, Apple is effectively trying to dictate how everyone on their platform can and can't do business. That seems problematic regardless of whether what numbers they dictate.
Agreed. The problem of leveraging their App Store dominance for payments dominance is the issue. I don’t think there is an issue with the App Store being the only store on iOS devices.
If the App Store is worth the 30% cut, let them compete for it.
I don't think it's worth the cut. I think the overwhelming majority of people download apps they already trust directly from the source (like they do on computers), and the App Store provides exactly zero value in that use case.
Yes, App Store does provide value and it can charge a cut. Having said that, Apple should equally provide a way to host different independent app stores just like Windows does.
Imagine on Windows/Linux/MacOS you could install software only from one corporate controlled store. Would you be fine with that?
Yes. I don’t need work requiring I install a Google App Store on my iOS device. I have a general-purpose computer already. One shouldn’t buy an iOS device if these restrictions are an issue.
When that happens having the power to dictate which apps are allowed (censorship, exclusive browser engines etc) along with taking a part of income from the apps, makes it unfair.
I come back to my Desktop example. Imagine Adobe had to pay 30% of their revenue to be on Windows, and Windows could dictate which browser engine all browsers must employ.
Does it hurt UX a bit to install a different app store? Maybe. But it's an inconvenience only for those who use their smartphones as a secondary computer.
And so the 30% isn't just for the upkeep of the store but also all of the work involved in maintaining/growing the tens of millions of iOS users at the other side of the channel. For example, Apple spends well over $2 billion a year on marketing which would need to be factored into your costs.
Also I don't understand how anyone could support Apple taking less money from big developers.
Apple benefits from third party developers, third party developers benefit from Apple. Third party developers don't get a slice of iPhone sales revenue.
You wouldn't support Kitchenaid only allowing curated vegetables and charging their vendors 30% (or even 3%).
Apple provides useful services with its App Store: filtration and curation. The degree to which this is effective is debatable. But that it has an effect is not.
Apple also extracts socially useless rents from its App Store. The degree to which this exists is debatable. But its existence, given Apple's dominance in app industry profits, is not.
The first costs Apple in terms of labor, tools and research. The second is a result of their independently-profitable devices business. These costs are roughly the same from app to app, review to review.
One solution might be to charge a fixed fee per review. This scales perfectly with Apple's costs. But it's prohibitive for small players. A scaling fee structure relative to revenues promotes first movers, thereby keeping the app ecosystem fresh. Apple came up with a 30% flat rate. This made sense when apps made hundreds of thousands of dollars. It does not make sense when they make hundreds of millions.
A simple answer is a sliding scale. 30% for the first $20mm in a year. 20% for the next $40mm. 10% after $60mm. This is more than generous to Apple. It beats Epic's request for a 12% flat fee at $400mm. And it continues letting Apple give new entrants, who are both more sensitive to costs and more needing filtration and curation, a field to play on. As a bonus to Apple, it reduces the incentive for developers to litigate as a function of their capacity to sue.