Re:Microsoft Open Source
by kanobo on Friday August 14, 2020 @02:39AM
(#24154502)
I don't know about you youngsters, but I'm in my thirties and it's amazing to watch Microsoft evolve since the 90s. As a teenager I would never have imagined the words 'Open Source' would ever be in a <h1> tag on a Microsoft-branded website.
Re:Microsoft Open Source
by pydry on Friday August 14, 2020 @06:00AM
(#24155928)
I'm in my thirties too and I'm not at all amazed by the way MS evolved. The three MS open source offerings I have tried where MS has something that resembles a non open source competitor - Azure MySQL, Azure Postgres and WSL are all horrendously slow (I'd go as far as to say deliberately crippled). It's a trap.
Every time they've released something big as open source or on Linux (e.g. .NET/vscode) it's been something where they're losing ground quickly and fighting off irrelevance.
Moreover it's just as irritating as ever to get Linux installed on laptops (the OEM stranglehold is still there).
I am amazed that Microsoft did a PR push on how they've turned 5 or so years around and people bought it. They acknowledged some new realities but they didn't fundamentally change tactics. They still (correctly) view open source as a threat to their profits and act accordingly.
Re:Microsoft Open Source
by ewzimm on Friday August 14, 2020 @12:06PM
(#24159703)
Microsoft is over 163,000 people. While I don't doubt that executives tend to be motivated by profit, I doubt that everyone shares a singular focus on it. Someone in charge of an open source project at Microsoft today might have been working with Mozilla or Apache yesterday.
I know executive leadership sets trends and influences culture, but I don't agree with the idea that a corporation is nothing more than the extension of the leadership's ambitions.
Re:Microsoft Open Source
by robbyt on Friday August 14, 2020 @04:58PM
(#24163193)
Hanlon's Razor... I highly doubt they've intentionally crippled the open source ones just to promote MSSQL. So many things are bad on azure, the slow databases are just one part.
Re:Microsoft Open Source
by kanobo on Friday August 14, 2020 @01:27PM
(#24160674)
I'm not disagreeing, but there's plenty of microsoft closed-source efforts that have been horrible too. It's possible microsoft just isn't very good at everything.
Re:Microsoft Open Source
by ItsJason on Friday August 14, 2020 @10:56AM
(#24158722)
Can confirm; tried to use Azure PG in a project at work and we were shocked at the terrible performance. It was basically unusable. This was < 1 year ago.
Re:Microsoft Open Source
by Legogris on Friday August 14, 2020 @02:44AM
(#24154547)
Unless perhaps when compared to some kind of disease. Looks like even Ballmer himself did a 180 on the whole "Linux is a cancer" thing (thinks he was still "right" at the time becaus ethe stance made them money): https://www.reuters.com/article/us-microsoft-ballmer-linux-i...
Re:Microsoft Open Source
by mehrdadn on Friday August 14, 2020 @03:21AM
(#24154835)
It's not the prettiest word, but just saying he called it cancer leaves out important context. He wasn't trying to bash Linux itself so much as (his interpretation of) its GPL license. If its license had been different (say, MIT or BSD) I don't think he would've described it like that.
Re:Microsoft Open Source
by nix23 on Friday August 14, 2020 @06:47AM
(#24156257)
I did not say they where allergic against free code/work, i said they where allergic against a complete different Business where you sell just the service and not the code.
EDIT: And i wrote "the made no mit/bsd code" but adapting it...just like Apple
Re:Microsoft Open Source
by sgift on Friday August 14, 2020 @05:39AM
(#24155783)
Afair the first IP stack of either Windows 95 oder Windows 98 was the one from FreeBSD(?). They rewrote it later, but there was an acknowledgement in the docs for a while. So, they at least used it when needed.
(My memory may be fuzzy, it's been a long time after all ..)
Yes, the IP stack was derived from BSD as well as Internet Explorer was derived from NCSA Mosaic however they didn't publish those things under open licenses. (Which isn't required by BSD etc.)
Re:Microsoft Open Source
by Hokusai on Friday August 14, 2020 @05:13AM
(#24155618)
I agree (not a youngster). I guess that Microsoft has also changed business model. Nowadays they are way more into hardware, cloud and services than just selling software.
Still a nice move. Other similar companies (Oracle, Amazon) are less kind with Open Source. So, kudos to the new Microsoft.
Oracle certainly has a different approach, but they contribute to the Linux kernel (i.e. bttrfs originates from Oracle), Oracle also runs MySQL, OpenJDK, GraalVM, Fn Project, ... https://github.com/oracle/ has a few more projects.
Re:Microsoft Open Source
by phillc73 on Friday August 14, 2020 @04:04AM
(#24155154)
I don't think the list of projects is complete.[1] I specifically know Microsoft's open source initiatives through Microsoft R Open[2], which is not listed on that page.
Re:Microsoft Open Source
by rudiv on Friday August 14, 2020 @07:27AM
(#24156531)
They're implementing a very basic version of a package manager. There's a whole saga about the creation of that which you might also have seen, was on HN. (Called winget)
Edit: Just realized that's probably what you're referring to, didn't know they were officially calling it Windows Package Manager. I thought you were being sarcastic vis-a-vis the lack of a windows package manager.
Re:Microsoft Open Source
by beagle3 on Friday August 14, 2020 @07:07AM
(#24156397)
No, they deserve less trust than most other large enterprise software - most should not be trusted. Microsoft should be actively distrusted following their previous assaults on FOSS in general, open standards (web with IE6, ISO committee loading fiasco), FUD and mob tactics (they were collecting a few bucks for every android unit sold from manufacturers supposedly for patents - details never disclosed - and for all I know they still are). The Microsoft kiss of death (for those old enough to remember it) was strategy, not random happenstance.
Re:Microsoft Open Source
by mhh__ on Friday August 14, 2020 @05:05AM
(#24155578)
Trust but verify, as the saying goes.
I'm not that worried in the long-ish term about microsoft, but I worry that the new generation (my generation) have grown up post GPL in that there is an open source tool for everything now but generally under a corporate-friendly license - I worry the pendulum will swing back the other way.
Re:Microsoft Open Source
by solarkraft on Friday August 14, 2020 @11:08AM
(#24158884)
> I worry the pendulum will swing back the other way
So do I, but only moderately so. They're using open source projects to smuggle in proprietary things in their official builds (VSCode), collect data (dotnet telemetry) and get people into their proprietary offerings (Azure, LiveShare).
This is arguably not very nice, but the business case is obvious and they're pretty much only doing the same thing as the other big players. Additionally, since the core offerings really are open, people are free to build more user friendly versions of them (VScodium).
Strategically I think they're slowly entering the "Extend" phase. Let's not let them extinguish, ie don't start depending on their proprietary offerings. Getting it into peoples' heads probably requires EEE education.
Microsoft open sourcing .Net is not a PR stunt. It's like Sun open sourcing Java. I'm not sure what other big company open source projects you're thinking of that compare. Maybe Chrome, Electron, or React?
Every time they've released something big as open source or on Linux (e.g. .NET/vscode) it's been something where they're losing ground quickly and fighting off irrelevance.
Moreover it's just as irritating as ever to get Linux installed on laptops (the OEM stranglehold is still there).
I am amazed that Microsoft did a PR push on how they've turned 5 or so years around and people bought it. They acknowledged some new realities but they didn't fundamentally change tactics. They still (correctly) view open source as a threat to their profits and act accordingly.
I know executive leadership sets trends and influences culture, but I don't agree with the idea that a corporation is nothing more than the extension of the leadership's ambitions.
I probably will move to MS SQL, too. I'm virtually obligated to use azure and it's the only non crippled database available on azure.
https://www.theregister.com/2001/06/02/ballmer_linux_is_a_ca...
I think it was especially against the GPL, but against a complete different Business model too.
Many of the TCP/IP utilities (telnet, nslookup etc) in earlier versions of Windows were based on BSD code.
EDIT: And i wrote "the made no mit/bsd code" but adapting it...just like Apple
(My memory may be fuzzy, it's been a long time after all ..)
Still a nice move. Other similar companies (Oracle, Amazon) are less kind with Open Source. So, kudos to the new Microsoft.
[1] https://opensource.microsoft.com/projects/explore/
[2] https://mran.microsoft.com/open
Edit: Just realized that's probably what you're referring to, didn't know they were officially calling it Windows Package Manager. I thought you were being sarcastic vis-a-vis the lack of a windows package manager.
I'm not that worried in the long-ish term about microsoft, but I worry that the new generation (my generation) have grown up post GPL in that there is an open source tool for everything now but generally under a corporate-friendly license - I worry the pendulum will swing back the other way.
So do I, but only moderately so. They're using open source projects to smuggle in proprietary things in their official builds (VSCode), collect data (dotnet telemetry) and get people into their proprietary offerings (Azure, LiveShare).
This is arguably not very nice, but the business case is obvious and they're pretty much only doing the same thing as the other big players. Additionally, since the core offerings really are open, people are free to build more user friendly versions of them (VScodium).
Strategically I think they're slowly entering the "Extend" phase. Let's not let them extinguish, ie don't start depending on their proprietary offerings. Getting it into peoples' heads probably requires EEE education.
> microshit
Yeah... that's some sophisticated humor.
And why should we compare? It's not a pissing contest...