News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by paxys on Thursday August 13, 2020 @03:50PM (#24147729)
Cool. I am also an iOS developer and get almost nothing for the 30% I pay Apple. It would be trivial to build my own in-app payments system using Stripe for like 3%.

Giving customers choice and encouraging competition is a good thing.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by Scottopherson on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:12PM (#24148102)
Will your trivial custom payment system come with counter-intuitive modal popups? Unclear subscription/unsubscription terms? Inaccessible or hostile refund or return policies?

I don't want to prematurely insinuate that you or other's solutions would all have such characteristics but as a consumer I don't care how developers get paid and I enjoy the benefits of Apple's integrated UX around iOS payments and subscriptions.

But I am also a developer and enjoy benefits of open-ness and choice in my work as well so I struggle with my opinions on this issue.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by paxys on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:24PM (#24148360)
Funny because I recently tried to cancel an in-app subscription I signed up for through Apple and it was borderline impossible. I'd much rather prefer to have a cancellation option in the app itself, but Apple doesn't allow that. In fact Apple's in-app payment/subscription UX checks every single box in your list.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by zimpenfish on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:57PM (#24148990)
I cancelled something the other day - got an email saying it was up for renewal in 90 days or thereabouts with a link to the subscription page and a set of options where "cancel" was afforded the same screen real estate as the continue options. Not entirely onerous, I think, two clicks?

But ok, you might want to cancel before you get the reminder email. Settings -> Your Name/Avatar -> Subscriptions -> Pick the app -> Big red "Cancel Subscription" button.

But ok, ok, you might not know that they're under your avatar which is fair, it's not entirely intuitive. Settings -> Search -> "sub" -> Subscriptions is the first result -> Pick the app -> Big red "Cancel Subscription" button.

But ok, ok, ok, you don't have your iOS device to hand. macOS Settings -> Apple ID -> Subscriptions: Manage... -> Edit the subscription (this is broken on the Big Sur beta, mind.)

If you don't have your iOS device(s) to hand, nor do you have a Mac handy, then I concede it's going to be a bit faff - https://support.apple.com/en-gb/HT211011

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by saagarjha on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:24PM (#24148364)
> Will your trivial custom payment system come with counter-intuitive modal popups? Unclear subscription/unsubscription terms? Inaccessible or hostile refund or return policies?

You mean like Apple's solution?

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by blub on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:03PM (#24149102)
WTF are you talking about? Subscriptions on iOS are the nicest, most customer-friendly I've ever seen on any computing platform ever.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by kanobo on Friday August 14, 2020 @12:00PM (#24159633)
I've never been able to get a refund on a purchase on iOS app or ever had a customer email to the App Store get responded. I think you might just be commenting on the UI? In that case - yes absolutely, it is visually pretty and easy to buy stuff.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by cullenking on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:04PM (#24149134)
Our small business could fund dedicated programmers and accountants to handle all that and still come out ahead compared to what we get hit by Apple for. 30% of annual revenue on Apple devices per year is millions for many small software companies. Money we used to get from direct web sales. And we have a nightmare time getting app updates released due to their opaque and unfriendly review process with no accountability. Not to mention their horrific tooling. Apple is a blight on the industry.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by valuearb on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:51PM (#24149878)
Yet you stay because the App Store brings you a steady stream of customers who are comfortable buying your app because of those App Review policies, the installation security, and its clear purchasing and subscription system and policies.

Perhaps you don’t have free versions of your apps, but Apple also pays to distribute unlimited free apps for no charge. And Apple spends roughly 50% of what you pay it on providing all these services, you can’t do them cheaper and you can’t do the most important on your own.

If I didn’t have to pay rent I could hire more developers, but my landlord isn’t holding me back, they are enabling me to close more business. You want lose sales on a worse App Store, I pray we don’t get waist you want.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by cullenking on Thursday August 13, 2020 @10:14PM (#24152427)
It does not cost Apple millions of dollars to distribute our app. The only viable choice to not releasing on iOS is not having a business, one that started on the web and due to customer demand, moved to iOS. I get the value they provide, but it’s clearly not in line with the cost they charge.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by ryanbrunner on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:30PM (#24148495)
I mean, all of these things are pretty straightforward with Stripe today. I guarantee if the ecosystem were more open there would be a drop-in replacement for Apple's system by Stripe available in practically no time.

If Apple wants to compete on offering a better, more seamless experience, there's nothing stopping them from doing so. I don't think anyone is arguing that Apple shouldn't offer payment processing altogether. A 30% cut and anti-competitive stance towards other payment methods don't feel like competing to provide the best experience to me though.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by valuearb on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:48PM (#24148855)
Who is going to paye for app distribution, app review, search, hosting infrastructure and all the other critical features developers and consumers need?
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by ryanbrunner on Thursday August 13, 2020 @07:41PM (#24151261)
All of these things exist and have healthy competition on the web, where competition is allowed to exist and there's no gatekeepers demanding a 30% cut of revenues.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by HatchedLake721 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:28PM (#24148450)
Are you then trivially going to monitor you're not breaching any tax reporting thresholds in 155 countries, register for VAT MOSS in one of the EU countries, implement IP geo-location for your European customers to make sure you charge them a correct VAT out of 27 options, and then personally do quarterly VAT MOSS submissions?

You don't know what you're getting from Apple for 30%. Which is fine. This is Apple's gross mistake that you and others are not aware of the benefits they get.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by paxys on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:38PM (#24148667)
Why assume what I know and don't know? Stripe and several other providers offer all of this for a much smaller fee. Plus, I already have all of the infrastructure running on the web, so the incremental cost to support iOS will be close to 0. In fact, even if you put aside the processing fee, not having to support Apple's terrible payments and subscription system will be a net engineering benefit.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by HatchedLake721 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:50PM (#24148888)
P.S. - You've edited your comment. My comment still stands

I cannot assume that a single person is not proficient in tax regulations in 155 countries around the world?

> Again, Stripe and others offer all of this for a much smaller fee.

I don't know who "others" are, but Stripe definitely doesn't offer that. https://support.stripe.com/questions/charging-sales-tax-gst-...

If you're using Stripe, you need to make sure you charge the correct tax, and it's your own responsibility to report it correctly in the countries that require it.

There are services on top of Stripe that can do that for additional fee (e.g. quaderno.io), but then again, it is worrying that you're not aware of your tax obligations taking worldwide payments via Stripe and also that you're not aware of what Apple provides you for 30%.

Not knowing either is fine, but I'd say both are Stripe's and Apple's faults that you are not aware of this.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by valuearb on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:47PM (#24148831)
why is Apple spending nearly 50% of those App Revenues on the App Store? You can’t do a good job at App Review alone for Stripes fee, and App Review is critically important for developers and customers.

You are completely clueless if you think payment processing is even a tiny fraction of what the App Store provides.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by valuearb on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:00PM (#24147899)
An in-app purchase system isn’t an App Store, and isn’t remotely similar. You get worldwide access to hundreds of markets in dozens of localized stores all in a system that makes billions of customers feel secure in purchasing from you. You also get Appleto distribute your apps for free as well! Spotify alone uses terabytes a day distributing to free users.

Opening up to other app stores would be a disaster for developers. Less secure, more scam are and malware, more confusing, lower consumer confidence, Balkanized app search, higher dev costs to support more stores, and for what? 20% fees at best?

Apples margins are publicly documented, no one could run a profitable app store for less than 20%.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by yulaow on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:23PM (#24148348)
> Apples margins are publicly documented, no one could run a profitable app store for less than 20%.

How can you say that if apple didn't allow the competition to exist? We cannot see if someone can innovate enough to cut that margin maybe even far more than what apple made you think is the "minimum to be profitable" because apple does not allow that

Isn't this exactly the startup playing field? When there is a market standard of which some pseudo monopolist says "well no one can do better than this" and then a innovative competitor joins in and distrupts?

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by valuearb on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:43PM (#24148760)
What are you going to cut? Security? App Review? Are you going to refuse to distribute free apps?

How come Google Play doesn’t cut their fees?

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by yulaow on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:05PM (#24149135)
Start giving the chance to competitors to enter the market, then if they cannot undercut apple you are right. Until they can't even try, we don't know.

Maybe they will even just "compete orthogonally" instead of just trying to work around the parameters you talk about. I don't know... maybe a store without IAPs will be born where games cost more but you get the full game and you know the author is not gonna try to gamify-casino you. Maybe someone will make a store which allows me to buy an app both for android and iOS in a single purchase at a lower price than buying both separately.

Maybe whatever, I don't know, but I for sure want to know what I could get.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by valuearb on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:54PM (#24149903)
I’m a developer and I don’t want alternate apps stores making the developer and customer experience more complicated, less secure and more confusing, all in hopes someone might charge me significantly lower fees.

Google Play is proof that lower fees isn’t going to benefit devs. No third party store has been able to use lower fees to take any significant market share.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by ac29 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @09:13PM (#24152042)
Do they break out specific App Store revenues and costs somewhere? I see Net sales for "services" (which presumably includes App Store) at $13.1B last quarter and the cost of sales for "services" at $4.3B.

If that was entirely off the 30% App store cut, they clearly would not need anywhere near the 30% to cover their costs (net sales are >3x cost of sales). But, lumped together with other services its hard to say anything specific about App store.

https://www.apple.com/newsroom/pdfs/FY20-Q3_Consolidated_Fin...