News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by umvi on Thursday August 13, 2020 @03:44PM (#24147622)
> I am just so confused why some people are acting like kids are a different species when it comes to covid.

Well, it's not that surprising when you have a disease whose harm factor is a function of your age. The vast majority of covid deaths are the elderly. The tiniest minority of covid deaths are young children. Their ability to spread to adults is their biggest risk factor, not the disease itself.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by _jal on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:17PM (#24148235)
> Their ability to spread to adults is their biggest risk factor

Others have mentioned this, but just for emphasis: you do not know that. Nor does anyone else. Repeating it is irresponsible, and you should stop doing that.

There have been a lot of lessons the epidemic can teach us. But one big one is that magical thinking is still accepted as a substitute for reason by a frightening number of people, and that's before you get to the outright grifters.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by stickfigure on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:45PM (#24148784)
> you do not know that

You also don't know that the virus won't give you superpowers, but you'd be foolish to act like it.

According to the best evidence we have, children are very very unlikely to suffer serious consequences from covid-19. Yes, it's possible that there are future complications we aren't yet aware of - but we don't presently have any reason to expect it.

We have to live based on probabilities, not possibilities. 800 kids drown each year in swimming pools. We live with the risk because swimming is great. So is going outside, seeing other humans, and getting educated.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by koolba on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:26PM (#24148409)
But we do know that. Or at least we can glean as much based upon the distribution by age for hospital admittance and death.

We don’t know what, if any, the long term consequences will be. But the short term death risk for young children appears to be minimal.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by tptacek on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:35PM (#24148612)
The difference in worry parents have over short term and "long term" death risks for their kids is marginal. In particular: if something could happen to jeopardize your kids lives while they are still kids --- which we do not know --- it's an overwhelming worry.

This is one of those conversations where message board logic stands a good chance of taking us far away from how real-world humans would reason.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by jacquesm on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:54PM (#24148951)
I think all it really does is that it highlights the difference between those who have children and those who do not. As a parent, I couldn't care less about the monetary impact of COVID-19 beyond the basics to survive and the years have taught us to be very frugal when we need to be.

Meanwhile, the thought of sending my kids back to school in two weeks has me sleepless (again). We have already seen different evidence surface in the last month or so but zero adjustment to the school plans. As much as I would like to approach this all in a dispassionate and rational way the parent 'module' in me tells me in no uncertain terms that I'm doing something irresponsible by not standing up for them more forcefully and trusting the experts on this.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by tptacek on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:57PM (#24148993)
My kids are going back to college in a couple days. They're adults! They're sharing an apartment this semester! And I'm a wreck. It's hard for me to fathom how this story is even news. What would be shocking is if the numbers had come in any closer between infection and work.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by jacquesm on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:01PM (#24149057)
Ugh. I feel for you. That's a tough position to be in, college is if possible even worse than grade school where mine are going. Even so in your case the risk is clear and present, and the University teachers are going to be a lot more likely to establish what their own risk appetite is than grade school teachers. This whole situation sucks. Way too many unknowns and too many people pretending there is no problem. I'm not looking forward to this winter. It seems like a perfect storm is brewing: COVID-19 resurgence, US Elections (which will generate a lot of friction no matter what the outcome), Brexit. This will be a rough ride. Hang in there.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by greedo on Friday August 14, 2020 @11:20AM (#24159042)
My oldest daughter left for college yesterday, living in a dorm. She's only 10min away, but between having her move out and worrying about COVID, I'm a basket case. I expect the campus to shut down in a month when cases numbers balloon, but I hope I'm wrong and they keep things under control.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by seunosewa on Saturday August 15, 2020 @08:34AM (#24168427)
You should strongly encourage your daughter to commute from home, since her college is only 10 minutes away. Students will take precautions during classes which will limit the spread, but in the evenings when they return to their dorms, they will let down their guards and the inevitable will happen. COVID spreads easily in dorms.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by gremlinsinc on Sunday August 16, 2020 @12:48AM (#24175214)
There's also the potential that they bring it home, causing the op to get sick/die. I'm a little more afraid of dying early, not because I want to live, but because : A. I don't want my kids to grow up w/out a dad, and B. I don't want to miss the important things in life. C. I'm hoping their chance of serious illness is less, but if I were wrong, I'd wish for death quickly afterwards.

I'm also sure things are easier when you have a parent to lean on for support, when a crisis comes up. (Lots of those on the horizon)...i'd rather be here to help them w/ that.

So part of me feels me living is important to their survival (mine are <4 yrs old - 2 boys, I'm 40). So, it might be safer and less traumatic if they stayed in the dorm, assuming they're healthy and have higher chances, and assuming they're good at social distancing / masking up to keep viral load down.

It'd be a hard decision to weigh, but I'd probably have a family council discuss the pros and cons and call a vote or something.

Basically commute or dorms, they can still catch it. At least in dorms maybe they don't infect older more vulnerable people or family members. Honestly, I'd probably teach them to code and say, hey work w/ dad till this is over then go to college :).

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by scarface74 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @07:14PM (#24150887)
As a parent, I couldn't care less about the monetary impact of COVID-19 beyond the basics to survive and the years have taught us to be very frugal when we need to be.

Did you ever think that some people with kids may not be in the position to work from home and have to go to work every day? I’m sure you’ve seen the statistics where a large percentage of Americans don’t have $400 in savings.

I also bet you have a job that allows you to work from home.

How many households are led by a single parent and/or two parents who have to go to a job where they can’t work from home?

I am not going to sit here tsk tsking all of the people who aren’t as fortunate as I am. Not only do I have a job where I can work from home. We were also in the financial position that we had the option of my wife not going back to work in the school system and just saying it wasn’t worth the risk.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by jacquesm on Thursday August 13, 2020 @07:29PM (#24151084)
> Did you ever think that some people with kids may not be in the position to work from home and have to go to work every day?

Yes, did you read the whole comment thread before asking that question? Because I specifically addressed it in another comment hours ago.

> I’m sure you’ve seen the statistics where a large percentage of Americans don’t have $400 in savings.

Yes, and as I've often said in other places and here as well: America is a country that has serious problems in terms of how the wealth is distributed. But that problem was there before COVID, and COVID is only going to make that problem worse. It is a systemic issue that won't be solved by how we deal with the virus and the associated disease.

Just like the 'war on drugs' impacts people from different social strata disproportionally, the same with three strikes laws and lots of other problems like that. It is a direct result of the laws you make and the politicians you vote for.

> I also bet you have a job that allows you to work from home.

That bet would work out, today. But six months ago that wasn't the case and as a result of that I contracted the virus at the end of the last job abroad and spent three weeks in bed. Fortunately I made it through and have decided that if I can't do my work remotely then I won't do my work.

> How many households are led by a single parent and/or two parents who have to go to a job where they can’t work from home?

Many. So, society should foot the bill there. It's only logical. This is how it is done in other countries.

> I am not going to sit here tsk tsking all of the people who aren’t as fortunate as I am.

Neither am I.

> Not only do I have a job where I can work from home. We were also in the financial position that we had the option of my wife not going back to work in the school system and just saying it wasn’t worth the risk.

Lucky you. But that is just you. For every you there are multiple people for who that is not the case. What are you going to do about that? Are you willing to pay increased taxes for a social safety net?

America is one giant study in the tragedy of the commons. And COVID just brings that out, it did not create any of it.

Take Lithuania or Latvia. Countries that suffered from being USSR satelite states for decades. Within a relatively short while their political structure and other infra put them on a footing solid enough to deal with this situation as it should be done, and many Western countries should look to them as examples of how you tackle a problem like this.

For those countries where it is worse - sometimes much worse - and which are substantially richer than Latvia and Lithuania you should be asking yourself what went wrong and why.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by elliekelly on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:04PM (#24149131)
If there is any group we should be most cautious about when it comes to the unknown long-term risks it's children because they have the longest term that they'll be stuck dealing with it. For a 60 or 70 year old when we talk "long-term effects" we're talking 10-20 years. When we're talking about potential long-term effects for a 10 year old it's an entire lifetime - 50, 60, 70, even 80 years of unknown physical and financial burden. I'm not a parent but it seems perfectly reasonable to me that parents would be very troubled by that kind of potential downside no matter how remote or unknown or unquantifiable the possibility.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by SpicyLemonZest on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:25PM (#24148385)
Nobody knows anything for sure, but "the virus might be causing huge hidden damage to kids" is in the same kind of unlikely tail risk as "social distancing might be building up so much social pressure it'll cause a violent revolution". Sure, it might be, but speculation like that can't be a primary factor in decisionmaking.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by bendotero on Thursday August 13, 2020 @03:57PM (#24147856)
> Their ability to spread to adults is their biggest risk factor, not the disease itself.

But that's one of the biggest unknowns. While children are at far lower risk of dying, according to data we have, we still don't know about long term health effects and we're finding out new information all the time. And much of that new information doesn't seem great.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by buhhh on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:01PM (#24147924)
Are you confusing harm with death rates? It's a novel virus and we still do not know the long term health impacts of it.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by renewiltord on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:29PM (#24148458)
Everything novel has this problem, and fortunately our epistemology is up to the task. We set our priors to a weighted linear combination of other similar things and then revise as evidence comes in.

For instance, MMR II was approved in 1978. How do we know that people who were given MMR II won't spontaneously die at the age of 60? Or perhaps to bring it closer to another problem, how do we know they won't spontaneously develop Autism Spectrum Disorder at the age of 60? There hasn't been time. It's a pretty novel vaccine.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by tptacek on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:38PM (#24148662)
There is no indication whatsoever that MMR has likely long-term health effects, and there are indications that C19 could have long-term health effects, and what we appear to learn month by month is more alarming, not less, with respect to the question of whether or not C19 is a "you either die of it in a month or you're fine" situation.

It also doesn't have to be a universal effect for it to generate effectively universal concern among parents. If it turned out that 1/20 kids suffered permanent kidney damage due to infection, most parents would keep their kids home. Look at the stats on school shootings and note that we pointlessly traumatize kids to assuage the concerns of parents. That's your figure of merit: that's how powerful the long-term C19 effect would need to be to change the behavior of the median parent.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by renewiltord on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:34PM (#24149632)
I agree with these (hopefully not incorrectly) restated things I think you believe:

* It is more likely that MMR has few significant long-term health effects than if COVID-19 does

* COVID-19 effects are unlikely to be binary outcome

* Effects need not be universal for them to affect parental behaviour

However, none of that agreement is important to the discussion I was hoping to have. My comment was solely on the epistemology. I suspect you also use the same methods I was talking about in my previous comment.

If that is the case, then perhaps some other day we can argue about what the priors are. If we're good about it, we'll end up with the Aumann Agreement Theorem (+ corollaries) result, and rapidly agree (through likely both of us shifting our priors as we exchange information).

I think we have no disagreement and am happy to conclude this here.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by jacquesm on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:55PM (#24148966)
Just to give you one possible side effect: sterility. There are plenty of viruses that when caught as a child do not give much in terms of symptoms but will make you sterile for life. That's not something that will come out in the next two months.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by renewiltord on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:22PM (#24149442)
True, and whether MMR 2 will kill you or your mind in 60 years isn't something that comes out in 42 years. We don't know that yet.

But if I had to guess, you're probably pro-MMR-2 (as am I), so the question is what epistemology permits that view?

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by jacquesm on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:30PM (#24149568)
It could, but we have a lot of data on those diseases and typically a weakened or reduced dose live virus shot has a known outcome with some outliers where the shot leads to the disease or something worse in the relatively short term.

For COVID-19 we are still guessing at most of this, hopefully the long term effects are not too bad and those effects of contracting the disease will get reduced over time.

But I would definitely not rule out some shocker long term effect at this stage that we are unaware of, especially not when taking into account developing organisms such as children, where effects can stay hidden for a long time.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by renewiltord on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:38PM (#24149689)
I think we're close to agreement, but not quite. We're not, after all, guessing at most. For instance, it's pretty unlikely that COVID-19 will cause you to grow three extra feet from your nose within the next 60 years.

There are some things we don't have high certainty on, but our epistemology would be faulty if we ignored how other coronaviruses behave, just like it would be faulty if we ignored how other attenuated viruses behave when we examine if MMR-2 will cause instadeath at age 60.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by jacquesm on Thursday August 13, 2020 @07:13PM (#24150873)
But there are quite a few examples of some pretty nasty effects that only show up when a person reaches maturity. So better to take this the slow and the sure way, more evidence is better.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by triceratops on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:27PM (#24148421)
Even if the kids are fine, if both parents get sick at the same time it's going to be hell taking care of the kids. Especially when you can't hire outside help due to social distancing requirements.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by roland35 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:33PM (#24148562)
That is my biggest concern as well. Plus the reality that if both parents come down with serious symptoms the kids likely have it, so it would not be ideal to send the kids to other family members to watch long term
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by ryanobjc on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:37PM (#24148631)
Also a lot of parents rely on... Grandparents to childcare when they are sick!

"Hey Grandma can you take care of my covid-kid while I am slowly maybe dying here?"

There is 0 societal support here.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by mnm1 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:01PM (#24149059)
> Their ability to spread to adults is their biggest risk factor, not the disease itself.

Even if this is true (we already have evidence it's not for some children), it's completely irresponsible to allow schools to open. We know children are infectious and easily spread the disease. There are other members of society besides children. Letting the virus run rampant in schools will lead to parents and other adults getting sick and dying. It's not ok for children to die but if their parents, grandparents, teachers, or parents' friends die it's somehow ok? What kind of logic is that?

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by chasd00 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:33PM (#24149617)
there's other forces at work with the rush to open schools than just covid19. Keep in mind, extended unemployment is expiring as well as a number of other emergency programs. School is the only place where many kids get a semi-square meal regularly. For many kids it's also a much safer environment than not school.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by mnm1 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @07:29PM (#24151075)
Then extend those programs. That should be obvious. Open up socially distanced food lines for kids and their parents that give out free food. None of this is impossible especially with the amount of wasted food we have. None of these problems lead to the conclusion that we should open schools when we can resolve these side issues in smarter, better ways that don't put the entire society at risk for covid. The House passed a relief bill 3 months ago. The failure of the Senate to do the same is simply inexcusable. That failure should not be the reason for even more people to die. This is so fucking absurd.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by UncleOxidant on Thursday August 13, 2020 @03:46PM (#24147646)
Sure, but they can pass it as easily as an adult can (saw a recent paper that said that children under 5 have higher viral loads than adults so they might actually be more infectious). There's a myth that kids can't pass it, but it's only a myth.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by mortehu on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:38PM (#24148655)
> they can pass it as easily as an adult can

Sounds like you're using a proxy result (viral load instead of shedding or actual transmission) in a single unnamed paper to make a pretty strong assertion?

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by ardy42 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:40PM (#24148708)
> Well, it's not that surprising when you have a disease whose harm factor is a function of your age. The vast majority of covid deaths are the elderly. The tiniest minority of covid deaths are young children. Their ability to spread to adults is their biggest risk factor, not the disease itself.

I think that's assuming that death is the only thing you have to worry about with this disease, and that if you don't die you'll recover and be no worse for wear. That may be a false assumption, and it could be that many children suffer from some kind of long term damage from the disease.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by nightski on Friday August 14, 2020 @09:38AM (#24157754)
I think a bigger problem is fear mongering like this without providing sources or data to back it up. People have become distrustful in general because frankly it's exhausting figuring out what is true and what isn't.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by inamberclad on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:26PM (#24148417)
We still have no idea what the long term effects of this disease are, or how they depend on severity.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by zaroth on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:29PM (#24148469)
We don’t know an infinite number of things. You can’t make decisions based on unknowns. You have to make decision based of evidence, not the lack of evidence.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by nend on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:43PM (#24148761)
>You can’t make decisions based on unknowns.

What? Of course you can. We know there's potential long term health effects in adults who get COVID-19, there's risk children face the same ones. We don't know how severe or how likely children are to get them (much like in adults), but we can absolutely decide not to take the risk anyway, and keep kids out of schools.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by zaroth on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:12PM (#24149267)
I should have said that you can’t logically make a decision based on unknowns.

Certainly many people make all kinds of decision based on irrational fear.

“We know there’s potential long term health effects” — without a percentage qualifier of how many people are affected, and a qualifier on the magnitude of the effect, this statement is utterly meaningless. There’s “potential long term health effects” (of some unspoken magnitude, to some unspoken percentage of the population) to everything.

“We don’t know how severe or how likely children”.... hundreds of thousands of children have tested positive for COVID. What we know for sure is that most will never know they ever even had it, and of those that do, less than 1% require hospitalization. 10-24 year olds are about 25x more likely to die of suicide than of COVID. (6,500 vs 175)

One thing we absolutely do know for sure is that social isolation will increase the suicide and overdose number in older kids. We also know that detected cases of children abuse and neglect are way down since lockdowns started, and it’s not because kids are being abused or neglected less. We know many kids primary source of good nutrition comes from school lunches. The evidence all points to closing schools being more dangerous for children than opening them. Particularly for children in low income households.

There may be an argument for closing schools, but it’s one that sacrifices children‘s social, mental, and economic wellbeing for the sake of potentially lower transmission among other truly at-risk populations.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by doorstar on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:05PM (#24149141)
Keeping kids out of school _is_ a decision, and not an easy one when having kids at home means the parents can't work.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by jacquesm on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:12PM (#24149282)
This keeps being trotted out but is actually a solved problems. For those situations where both parents have to work and both have to work out of home the schools can stay open and give a limited number of pupils regular lessons.

That way you cut down tremendously on a potential vector of transmission with as limited an impact as possible. We've done this here in NL successfully and in other countries besides.

Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by eirini1 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:22PM (#24149441)
maybe the solution is that parents shouldn't have to work during a pandemic if they can't.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by yblu on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:16PM (#24149342)
We absolutely can. We could be wrong and dead and we could be wrong and not dead. I'll pick the latter every time.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by kingkawn on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:26PM (#24148398)
There is absolutely no proof that children will not have long term health impacts that could reverberate for the rest of their lives. There are signs of chronic health repercussions for adults who have been infected. There is no telling yet what we can expect for children as they grow.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by zaroth on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:30PM (#24148491)
You literally cannot prove a negative.
Re:Parents are 5X as Worried about Infection and School than... by kingkawn on Friday August 14, 2020 @07:13PM (#24164360)
you can look at available data about chronic inflammation in people who have survived the initial infection. You can also look at data that a small number of kids are showing acute autoimmune reactions leading to severe illness and in a small number of cases death. You can then say, “we don’t know fully yet how big to expect this to be, but we should not risk exposing children to potentially life long health complications until we do.” Easy to reason through.