Re:NSA Owns Everything (2015)
by Thorrez on Thursday August 13, 2020 @02:40AM
(#24140583)
What about Libreboot? Doesn't that allow booting x86 without binary blobs?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Yes, very old hardware that's no longer on the market. I don't consider that a solution. Eventually that pool of hardware dries up.
It's easy to find x200 etc. used. Flashing is another story.
> Flashing is another story.
They still need some parts of blobs to configure/initialize the system and that “some” now means full MINIX kernel along its userland
Re:NSA Owns Everything (2015)
by boring_twenties on Thursday August 13, 2020 @09:28AM
(#24143107)
That's not correct, Libreboot does not work on those systems that require any part of the ME to boot.
You might be thinking of me_cleaner[1], which removes most but not all of the ME blobs. This is unrelated to Libreboot though, it works on newer systems and is not needed when using Libreboot because the latter gets rid of the (very early versions of) the ME completely.
Are you saying a librebooted machine is still probably backdoored?
Precisely.
You are talking about Coreboot, not Libreboot. The latter has no blobs whatsoever.
Does that mean that a firmware backdoor is impossible or very unlikely?