News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by wombatmobile on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @10:45PM (#24128117)
> The organelles are ancient invaders — the remnants of symbiotic bacteria that integrated themselves into host cells about 2 billion years ago and specialized for energy production.

That's accepted as scientific orthodoxy now, but it wasn't always. In the 1960's, evolutionary biologist Lyn Margulis proposed the theory that cell organelles such as mitochondria and chloroplasts were once independent bacteria, which combined through symbiotic mergers of bacteria to evolve into eukaryotic cells. Ernst Mayr called this "perhaps the most important and dramatic event in the history of life".

Throughout her career, Margulis' work could arouse intense objection. One grant application elicited the response, "Your research is crap, do not bother to apply again", and her formative paper, "On the Origin of Mitosing Cells", appeared in 1967 after being rejected by about fifteen journals.

In 2002, Discover magazine recognized Margulis as one of the 50 most important women in science.

In 1995, Richard Dawkins said, "I greatly admire Lynn Margulis's sheer courage and stamina in sticking by the endosymbiosis theory, and carrying it through from being an unorthodoxy to an orthodoxy. I'm referring to the theory that the eukaryotic cell is a symbiotic union of primitive prokaryotic cells. This is one of the great achievements of twentieth-century evolutionary biology, and I greatly admire her for it."

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by amelius on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @05:53AM (#24130172)
How is the research going on the effects of antibiotics on these organelles?
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by DrAwdeOccarim on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:44AM (#24130531)
That's a great question. A lot of antibiotics are effluxed out so they don't build up to high levels within the cell. Also, a lot of antibiotics bind to part of the bacterial cell wall, which mitochondria lost over evolution. Antibiotics that inhibit protein synthesis actually do negatively impact mitochondrion but not as bad because of divergences in ribosomal structure compared to bacteria.
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by msla on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:48AM (#24141237)
She's a victim of Nobel Disease and said stupid things out of her field. How is that controversial?
[dead]
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by gbrown on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @11:22PM (#24128319)
I mean... maybe, but probably not. Science has also learned a lot since then, and most skeptics aren’t scientists. Plausible cynicism grade: C-
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by raxxorrax on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @02:29AM (#24129120)
Every scientist should be skeptical. Doesn't mean he should join some skeptics movement.
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by gbrown on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @01:16PM (#24134298)
I meant to put skeptics in scare quotes. It could also be replaced with “self-described skeptics”.
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by Proziam on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @01:16AM (#24128796)
Based on the debate currently raging over hydroxychloroquine and its uses/effectiveness I can totally imagine the typical Twitter reaction being of rather poor quality.
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by raducu on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @02:34AM (#24129151)
Is there any scientific consensus/studies showing hydroxycloriquine as effective?

As far as I know, the biggest impact right now seem to be: anti-clotting medication, steroids, turning the patient on his belly and avoiding intubation for as long as possible.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by Symmetry on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @09:02AM (#24131621)
The thing is you need people spreading ideas against the consensus because if they're good they might become part of the consensus. The consensus was very much against the public wearing masks in early March and against steroid use until fairly recently.
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by rsynnott on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @09:16AM (#24131738)
And both of those things are now considered valid approaches due to research establishing that, not because random celebrities promoted them on twitter.

Health authorities didn't change recommendations on masks and dexamethasone due to twitter lobbying; they changed them because evidence emerged that they were safe and and least somewhat effective.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by Proziam on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @04:09AM (#24129646)
As of right now, I believe the general consensus is that it's not effective (or at least not more effective than standard treatment). However, if you went back just a few weeks you'd have seen quite a few credible people claiming it could very well be a gamechanger. It says something that Trump was taking it, because even if you dislike the man it's hard to imagine there is any other human being on the planet with greater access to the world's best doctors and whatever bleeding edge technology could be used.

That said, I was really highlighting a recent example of how poor communication is, and how fast opinion can shift.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by gspr on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @04:23AM (#24129706)
> As of right now, I believe the general consensus is that it's not effective (or at least not more effective than standard treatment). However, if you went back just a few weeks you'd have seen quite a few credible people claiming it could very well be a gamechanger.

I'm sorry, does this address the comment at all? There was indeed, this spring, real scientific debate over the potential efficacy of hydroxychloroquine. But the raging Twitter wars over it did not constitute that debate.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by Proziam on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @04:46AM (#24129834)
No need to be sorry!

I was asked if there's consensus regarding the effectiveness of HCQ. Currently, there is not. Not long ago, medical professionals were recommending it and there was, at least publicly, a consensus of sorts based on the positive results of early studies.

I then pointed out how fast consensus shifted from 'this stuff is awesome' to 'this stuff is stupid' because I believe it's relevant for anyone trying to formulate their own opinion about how solid that consensus really is.

The twitter wars and the general terrible communication online is a totally separate topic, and the one I was originally commenting on because /u/gbrown seemed to have a more positive outlook than I do on the subject.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by rsynnott on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @09:14AM (#24131722)
I mean, he probably has unparalleled access to the world's greatest mechanical and hydrological engineers if he wants it, but still seems noticeably confused about how toilets and dishwashers behave. The issue with Trump isn't that he doesn't have access to expertise; it's that he ignores it.
[dead]
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by gridlockd on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:27AM (#24130408)
> Didn't Trump recommended people drink or inject bleach?

No, he didn't, listen to what he actually said.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=33QdTOyXz3w

It's not a claim, it's an arguably stupid question to some guy off-screen. Yet, the title of this video is "President Trump claims injecting people with disinfectant could treat coronavirus". The outlet is the presumably reputable "Telegraph".

Trump also never called Nazis "fine people". What actually was said:

"...you had very fine people on both sides..."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JmaZR8E12bs&feature=youtu.be...

"And you had people - and I’m not talking about the neo-Nazis and the white nationalists - because they should be condemned totally."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JmaZR8E12bs&feature=youtu.be...

The job of the media is to fabricate outrage and scandals, because that's how you get attention. Trump doesn't even mind, in fact he is taking advantage of it:

https://growth.me/book-summaries/art-of-the-deal/#3-being-bo...

Remember when he "accidentally" mistook WWI for WWII in some press conference? The headline: "Another dumb thing that Trump said!"

However, it's a mistake that anybody - particularly average Joe - could've made. It's not really that negative, in fact it could be endearing to some people.

More importantly though, that headline is going to take attention away from actually negative news, such as "over a thousand American Coronavirus deaths occuring every day".

So, if you think Trump is really that stupid, maybe you're not really that smart.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by skocznymroczny on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @05:08AM (#24129930)
No he didn't, you fell victim to the fake news media.

During one of the press conferences, he asked some scientist or doctor guy if disinfectants can kill viruses on surface, would it be possible to create an injection that works like a disinfectant cleaning the body. He never said people should do that on their own.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by rsynnott on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @09:11AM (#24131694)
The issue with hydroxychloroquine is that claims of effectiveness without evidence, particularly as a prophylactic, cause an immediate public danger (particularly given its promotion by certain public figures in an irresponsible manner; see "what have you got to lose?") This isn't purely theoretical; people have self-medicated and died.

At any given time there are thousands and thousands of unproven drugs under development or being evaluated for new applications. There are even many possible covid treatments being evaluated without similar controversy, because no-one with a large audience has suggested self-medication.

Hopefully the hydroxychloroquine thing is a one-off, and public figures will be more careful in future about public promotion of unapproved drugs. It would be extremely dangerous, and damaging to legitimate scientific investigation, if this sort of thing becomes common.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by duncan_bayne on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @11:46PM (#24128429)
Well, I assume that along with her would also be a bunch of genuine cranks, mystics, "skeptics" etc. She'd be collateral damage.

Similar case that springs to mind is the chap who had to infect himself to prove that stomach ulcers were caused by bacteria.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by wombatmobile on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @01:33AM (#24128869)
Barry Marshall can just wave his Nobel prize at any skeptic.

https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/2005/press-releas...

Lyn Margulis did not and will not ever have that pleasure, because, like Rosalind Franklin, (a) she was female, and (b) she's now dead.

[dead]
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by Proziam on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @04:54AM (#24129866)
I'm being downvoted for simply pointing out that there was/is a public 'debate' (if we can even give it that much credit) about hydroxychloroquine, and that the current state of online communication makes me able to imagine similar reactions to Lynn Margulis's work.

I wouldn't take it personally, anything political on this forum seems to experience high variance.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by wombatmobile on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:10AM (#24130284)
I don’t mind. It’s an expression of the mind of the moderator. I like to try to guess their age and gender. But they are invisible so I don’t get any confirmation.

I like this Hacker News. The discourse is civil and often informative.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by rsynnott on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @09:05AM (#24131646)
... Eh, no.

General rule: controversial theories, in a vacuum, are fine.

Promoting controversial theories in a manner likely to lead people to die (hydroxycloroquine self-medication, bleach-drinking, deliberate self-infection): not fine.

Twitter and Youtube are full of people promoting all sorts of nonsense, and also legitimate unorthodox theories (there is a difference; there's a huge gap between, say, "the earth is flat" and "dark matter isn't a thing") without any trouble. It's when you get into the realm of health advice that is likely to injure people that there's a problem.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by mhh__ on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @12:03AM (#24128499)
After all, Twitter mobs love nothing better than pouring through the annals of biology journal?
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by bloak on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @05:47AM (#24130140)
That should be "poring through", I think. (It's not an easy one to remember.)
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by stubish on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:31AM (#24130433)
For Twitter mobs I'd go with pawing through.
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by gspr on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @04:26AM (#24129718)
> These days she'd have angry Twitter mobs doxxing her for opposing the "scientific consensus", or YouTube shutting down her account for spreading "misinformation".

I would assume that this incredibly smart scientist (for all her HIV and 9/11 bonkers and disgusting lunacy) would not be using Twitter as the medium for her scientific discussions.

I'm fascinated by how especially conspiracy theory people equate fighting on Reddit/Twitter/YouTube/… with real scientific debate.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by adammichaelc on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @11:19PM (#24128311)
Haha probably true.
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by msla on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @11:42PM (#24128408)
Sadly, these days Lynn Margulis is better known for her AIDS crankery:

> Margulis said that "the set of symptoms, or syndrome, presented by syphilitics overlaps completely with another syndrome: AIDS," and also noted that Kary Mullis[a] said that "he went looking for a reference substantiating that HIV causes AIDS and discovered, 'There is no such document.' "

> This provoked a widespread supposition that Margulis had been an "AIDS denialist." Notably Jerry Coyne reacted on his Why Evolution is True blog against his interpretation that Margulis believed "that AIDS is really syphilis, not viral in origin at all."[50] Seth Kalichman, a social psychologist who studies behavioral and social aspects of AIDS, cited her 2009 paper as an example of AIDS denialism "flourishing",[51] and asserted that her "endorsement of HIV/AIDS denialism defies understanding."[52]

Also: 9/11 crankery!

> Margulis argued that the September 11 attacks were a "false-flag operation, which has been used to justify the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq as well as unprecedented assaults on ... civil liberties." She claimed that there was "overwhelming evidence that the three buildings [of the World Trade Center] collapsed by controlled demolition."[5]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynn_Margulis

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by wombatmobile on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @01:17AM (#24128805)
The complication with (incorrectly) labeling Margulis "an AIDS denialist", msla, is that you then make her responsible for a whole collection of unsubstantiated tropes that are targeted by that label. That's unwarranted, because Margulis was doing something quite opposite to "AIDS denialism"; Margulis, an esteemed scientist, was proposing an alternative causative factor that may explain AIDS, which isn't HIV, or more precisely, which isn't HIV in isolation.

This fascinating discussion will make your jaw drop https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/discover-inter...

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by msla on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:16AM (#24129397)
> Margulis, an esteemed scientist, was proposing an alternative causative factor that may explain AIDS, which isn't HIV, or more precisely, which isn't HIV in isolation.

She's not esteemed in the field of what causes AIDS. She's esteemed in a different sub-field. In terms of AIDS, the actual experts have come to the conclusion she's wrong, and one thing we should all have learned by now is that our ignorance is not equal to the knowledge of experts.

> This fascinating discussion will make your jaw drop

Not for the reasons you think it would, though.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by coldtea on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @07:52AM (#24131071)
>She's not esteemed in the field of what causes AIDS. She's esteemed in a different sub-field. In terms of AIDS, the actual experts have come to the conclusion she's wrong, and one thing we should all have learned by now is that our ignorance is not equal to the knowledge of experts.

The history of science also told us by now that experts are stubborn, and sometimes they have to first die, for the next generation to accept another theory.

It has also taught us that important new discoveries more often than not come not from established experts in a field, but by people from another sub-field or another field all together...

It has also taught us that scientists should continue challenging prevailing hypotheses all the time, because that's part and parcel of doing science...

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by msla on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @11:18AM (#24132897)
> The history of science also told us by now that experts are stubborn, and sometimes they have to first die, for the next generation to accept another theory.

It tells us too that cranks will be cranks regardless of the evidence against them, and that cranks are more common than true revolutionaries.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by jkhdigital on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @11:20AM (#24132923)
Exactly. An “expert” is a skilled practitioner of some domain of human endeavor; a scientist is a truth-seeker. Expertise is orthogonal to scientific truth.
Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by msla on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:47AM (#24141232)
> Expertise is orthogonal to scientific truth.

Expertise is the result of successful scientific seeking.

Re:Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health by ta17711771 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @10:13AM (#24132234)
Not seeing how these two are connected, equivalent, etc