News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by ddevault on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @02:07PM (#24123599)
Ah, yes, because it's impossible to store a contact list client-side. Or to encrypt arbitrary data like that to store server-side! Glad Moxie's looking out for us.
Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by tptacek on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @02:10PM (#24123629)
Please point to the mainstream secure messenger other than Signal that doesn't store a database of contacts serverside.
Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by dingaling on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @04:41AM (#24129802)
Take your SIM and install it in a clean phone. Install WhatsApp and verify the account.

Notice that when you open WhatsApp, only your group memberships are populated. Individual contacts are not, because they are held on the original device.

[dead]
Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by tptacek on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @02:21PM (#24123793)
I don't understand. You just claimed that it was easy for messengers to store contact databases clientside. Of course, it isn't, or everyone would. Asking you to provide evidence for your argument isn't "whataboutism". Not only that, but you're commenting on a thread about Signal's phone number requirement.

You can't inject snark into a thread and then assume some kind of moral high ground when you faceplant.

Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by ddevault on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @02:28PM (#24123903)
You've got to be kidding me.

The ability to store data on your device is a basic requirement of a software environment which is provided by all platforms. I'd forgive someone for not understanding that arbitrary data can be encrypted, but you claim to have some expertise in cryptography so you don't get a pass there. Someone like OWS, the developers of a privacy app, certainly don't get a pass.

It is possible, and it is easy, and you know this.

Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by tptacek on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @02:34PM (#24124015)
Support your claim with evidence, like I asked earlier. Not axiomatically; with an example of a mainstream messenger other than Signal that doesn't store a database of contacts serverside. For example: do either of the two messengers you formerly recommended manage to avoid this problem? After all, it's apparently super simple to solve this. Look at where this left Tox.
Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by Shared404 on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @02:54PM (#24124328)
> Support your claim with evidence, like I asked earlier.

You asked for specifically mainstream messengers.

Cutting out mainstream, I can think of Tox and Jami off the top of my head.

Update 0: remove Tox, as you mention it in your comment.

Update 1: add Tox back in because your reply is about it, and I made edit 0 before seeing your reply.

Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by tptacek on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @03:04PM (#24124466)
Until a couple years ago, Tox worked with sidecar services that existed solely to store this information serverside. That, and the fact that Tox is not a mainstream messenger, illustrates the point I'm trying to make --- which is about messengers, not about this post, which thankfully doesn't make this bogus but popular argument.
Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by Shared404 on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @03:20PM (#24124714)
> Tox worked with sidecar services that existed solely to store this information serverside.

So Tox is out. No contest.

> That, and the fact that Tox is not a mainstream messenger, illustrates the point I'm trying to make --- which is about messengers

This doesn't make sense to me. @ddevault stated that a messenger could store contacts client side. Jami clearly demonstrates this. What does it being mainstream or not have to do with this?

> thankfully doesn't make this bogus but popular argument.

What does this add, except a personal attack? We can see that you think this is a bad argument from the fact that you're contesting it.

Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by tptacek on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @03:23PM (#24124757)
You can do anything if you relax the constraint that people are willing to use your tool. By that logic, PGP is a perfectly cromulent secure messenger! That's the point of narrowing it down to mainstream messengers.

You misread my last sentence. DeVault's post does not make the bogus argument we're discussing. I'm trying to be explicit that I'm not criticizing his post for doing so. If it's an attack, it's an attack on an argument that he didn't make. (If it reads like a personalized attack on an argument that you believe in, I apologize, and will dial it back).

Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by Shared404 on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @03:32PM (#24124884)
> You can do anything if you relax the constraint that people are willing to use your tool.

I used Jami until I found Matrix. The only reason I shifted was Matrix was more interoperable with other protocols, and riot.im's interface was more like Discord, which is what my circle wanted to use but I refused.

Regardless, the threat model for this discussion is one where the targets have the option to use any messenger they want to communicate within themselves. I see no reason why they would be unwilling to use Jami.

> PGP is a perfectly cromulent secure messenger!

I recognize this is not what you are stating but...

PGP + Email + A nice client, yes I would agree, and it checks all of the security and privacy boxes.

Edit: Just saw

> (If it reads like a personalized attack on an argument that you believe in, I apologize, and will dial it back).

It's not that I believe in it per se, but that it reads more aggressively then seems appropriate for a board like HN. That said, I am still a bit of a noob here, so what do I know.

That said, I see no reason a messenger couldn't do this, I used one that did for a while.

Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by tptacek on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @03:34PM (#24124918)
If you'd like to know why PGP doesn't check those boxes, and why virtually everyone who works professionally in this space disagrees with you about its soundness, feel free to shoot me an email.
Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by Shared404 on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @03:41PM (#24125030)
I just sent one, thanks for the offer.
Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by ddevault on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @02:39PM (#24124095)
>Not axiomatically; with an example of a mainstream messenger

I don't have to provide the specific sort of evidence you're asking for in order to be right. I could write up a small script demonstrating the approach I'm talking about here, but it's rather obvious and based on simple, well-understood axioms. Unless you reject the axioms that (1) contact lists are representible as data, (2) applications can store data on your device, and (3) that data can be encrypted?

If you're just going to argue in bad faith then you can take it elsewhere, I'm not interested. Based on my past experiences with you, I don't have high hopes.

>do either of the two messengers you formerly recommended

Recommandations which have been retracted; I decline to answer.

Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by tptacek on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @02:46PM (#24124204)
You did not retract them. You ghost edited them out of your post to save face. A retraction would be useful, and you should add one.
Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) by ddevault on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @02:49PM (#24124259)
You might have preferred it if I had written up a retraction in the article itself, but nevertheless, the statement was removed over 2 years ago and has no bearing on the present-day discussion. Stop being a bully and leave me alone! I am tired of your harassment.