If this is the bank I think it is, once you inserted your card and entered your (valid) PIN, the teller was shown the color scan of your ID card that you presented when you opened the account. The teller then uses this to compare to you without you handing over a (possibly-faked) ID card.
That is why this bank will periodically ask you to provide a new copy of your ID.
In general - from my time working at a phone company call center some years back - it is a much better indicator of security to ask folks to verify some account information than to try to say someone is doing something fraudulent by judging whether or not the sound of their voice matches what I think it should sound like based on their name. Verifying information tends to mean that the person has permission to speak about it. A lot of companies will let folks 'authorize' someone to speak on an account, set up a password, or simply allow her to tell them to talk to you and hand the phone to you. If you call from her personal phone, that is another step to verify as well.
Trying to judge someone's voice doesn't add security, though. Some folks don't have voices that can be classed as one gender: Some folks voices simply are deeper or higher than expected. Not to mention that some folks are transgender, which does mean that sometimes the voice won't match outward appearance or perceived gendered name. Some folks have health issues that make their voices seem deeper or higher as well.
They could have just though you were old, too. Sometimes older voices are more unisex.
To complicate things even more, parents name their children non-gendered names and some names have switched genders over the years. And to add another layer: Foreign names can sound like they "belong" to a gender they aren't traditionally used for.
I'm not saying that it can be used as a tip-off for extra verification but the real solution is to use a strong authenticator in the first place and not worry about these "softer" details.
HSBC in the UK have a system they call "Voice ID" which claims to authenticate you by your voice: https://www.hsbc.co.uk/ways-to-bank/phone-banking/
I've not enrolled...
Fingerprints are fairly unique, but not necessarily special to you and only you. I really don't know if voice is even that special or if this is more like a car door lock: It's ok so long as there is enough verification.
If the bank in question has literally never dealt with federal funds (e.g. FHA mortgages) then they may be exempt but this does not apply to most consumer banks.
EDIT: The Equal Credit Protection Act and the Fair Housing Act explicitly covers gender and sex as protected classes. Very few consumer banks in the US are not covered by these acts.
Technically but not materially true, since gender identity discrimination, like other forms of conformance-to-sex-stereotype discrimination, has been found by the Supreme Court to be a form of sex discrimination.
This is what cryptocurrency people ignore. They see reversing as a bug, when it's clearly not.
Let's say you abuse linking, and you take money. Great. The tx is reversed and you go to jail.
Prevention is better, but it's not that the security isn't there.
Regarding 1, 2, & 4: You aren't taking the physical angle into account. In all of these cases it sounds to me like one US institution dealing with another. Wire fraud is a federal crime. All US institutions collect a fair bit of identifying information when you open an account. Good luck fraudulently transferring money into an account you control and getting away with it.
Regarding 2: They probably verified a picture of you that they had on file without you realizing it. Moreover, it's safe to assume the bank lobby was absolutely carpeted in cameras. I expect you would be unlikely to successfully commit fraud with this approach.
Credit reporting agency and data broker data. It’s legal and it’s used by the IRS to perform identity proofing so threat actors don’t defraud the US Treasury with fraudulent refund requests using bogus return data.
A friend that works on a call center for a US bank told me they are not able to ask about the caller's gender, like when the perceived voice/gender and name don't match. They may report the call to the fraud department if the conversation is suspicious though.
[1]: https://www.schneier.com/academic/paperfiles/Privacy_Threats...
I imagine many banks operate similarly, but I can't say that for certain.
Don't forget to account for physical enforcement.
This has been going on for at least a decade. There is approximately zero financial privacy in the US.
You implied both that there is no oversight and that it is bulk collection. Both are not supported by your source, which says there is some oversight by a judge and that the FBI manually requests data on specific individuals. It may be a violation of civil liberties, but it doesn't support your claim.
1. I have linked a non-joint account in my name at bank A to another (non-joint) account of my wife at bank B (accidentally) without any verification of any kind. I call BS on anyone claiming they magically checked the home address link or know we are married.
2. I have walked in to my bank and did a wire transfer of a large amount without any kind of verification. They didn't check my ID. I am not kidding. I did enter my ATM card and PIN. Then why do they have a $500 or $1000 limit at ATM. If someone did get my ATM card and PIN, they just had to appear confident and walk in to the branch. This is one of the largest banks in the US.
3. Because my wife doesn't like to deal with customer service of various financial items (credit-cards, 401k etc). I regularly call and just say I am her (clearly feminine name) and the conversation carries on as if nothing is surprising/suspicious.
4. On the other extreme, IRS's "MyIRS" site let us authenticate yourself (first time setup) using a security question that allows one to type any financial account number. CC, Bank, 401k, whatever. I mean how tf did they get all that data on me? legally? Why does IRS need my CC number?
IMHO, the only thing keeping us secure is that nobody from outside US has really tried to mess around with US banks.