News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Debt collector profits soar with people flush and easy to... by awslattery on Saturday August 08, 2020 @08:07PM (#24096261)
In most states, this alleged debt would be outside the statute of limitations for contract originated debt (usually 6 years from day of default). Meaning that, unless you pay any amount to them, it is no longer a debt that can be pursued through legal channels.

With any debt collector or buyer, per FDCPA, they must stop calling if you notify them. Best way to do this is by a certified letter stating your name, your phone numbers, and that it is not permitted to call you regarding this alleged debt. Offenses here can net you a bounty in court, but worth noting most folks with valid debts, can't afford to fight the onslaught of robocalls from spoofed numbers, as is all too common in the trade

Requesting validity of a debt is also covered under FDCPA, but with some general stipulations. Legally, a collector or debt buyer is required to provide validation in the 30 days after the initial notification to you if requested in writing. Most will still send documentation out of this window if they have it, but it becomes less transparent under your civil protections for them to be mandated to do so.

Obligatory IANAL, but if you find yourself in a similar position here, doing a few minutes of research on your protections and common "gotchas" of dealing with these outfits is incredibly valuable.

Re:Debt collector profits soar with people flush and easy to... by rectang on Saturday August 08, 2020 @10:03PM (#24096705)
That such heroics are necessary to stave off illegitimate claims is utterly infuriating.
Re:Debt collector profits soar with people flush and easy to... by cwojno on Saturday August 08, 2020 @11:42PM (#24097083)
Agreed. This is 100% unfair to the innocent.
Re:Debt collector profits soar with people flush and easy to... by roenxi on Sunday August 09, 2020 @01:10AM (#24097419)
What part of the process don't you like? It actually seems pretty reasonable to me. It sucks for those who end up on a list due to mistakes - but there isn't going to be a scenario where that doesn't happen however the system is set up. Unless paying back debt is done on an honour system I suppose.

Corporations dedicated to, essentially, harassment is much better than the first obvious alternative, which is having officials involved. If the police think you've done the wrong thing they generally won't be dissuaded by a certified letter.

Re:Debt collector profits soar with people flush and easy to... by throwaheyy on Sunday August 09, 2020 @02:42AM (#24097798)
You think it’s perfectly ok for anonymous companies to extort consumers with fake debt?
Re:Debt collector profits soar with people flush and easy to... by chordalkeyboard on Sunday August 09, 2020 @03:48AM (#24098060)
my perception is that its less about it being "perfectly ok to harass" and more about it being a fact that mistakes happen, and the means for correcting such mistakes is not unreasonably difficult.

of course if you have an alternative idea please share.

Re:Debt collector profits soar with people flush and easy to... by rectang on Sunday August 09, 2020 @08:25AM (#24099138)
When "mistakes happen", the companies who make those mistakes should be penalized, and the pain should be severe enough that they are incentivized not to make mistakes.
Re:Debt collector profits soar with people flush and easy to... by raverbashing on Sunday August 09, 2020 @01:28AM (#24097467)
The alternative is what's done already: debt score penalty. And demanding payment for debts without harassment.

It's not hard.

Re:Debt collector profits soar with people flush and easy to... by roenxi on Sunday August 09, 2020 @01:59AM (#24097582)
> And demanding payment for debts without harassment.

That'll look pretty much the same as what they are doing now. People who take money on the basis that they will do a thing in the future should then do the thing. If they can decide not to do the thing and walk away with the money then the situation gets a bit silly.

Persistently asking for the money back is about as mild a recourse as possible. The hoop-jumping to make them stop is horrible for people who get caught up by mistake, but is not that terrible.

The alternative is magistrates and lawsuits. That would be much worse. Getting into to a fight with the tax office when they mistakenly think you owe them money would be much worse.

Re:Debt collector profits soar with people flush and easy to... by arp242 on Sunday August 09, 2020 @06:09AM (#24098530)
The problem isn't that they're asking for payments, it's that they're demanding payments when they don't actually have any evidence that any are due, which is why they simply disappear when asked for any evidence, for a while anyway.

The problem is 1) when people act in good faith and assume the debt is actually real and just pay, 2) people who might be afraid that things escalate and pay to "avoid trouble", and 3) the fear that it might negatively affect your credit score. The power imbalance is very real.

When a debt collecting agency sends you a bill, this is essentially it's an accusation that you didn't fulfil your responsibilities and duties. I don't know about you, but I tend to make pretty darn sure that I'm right when I accuse of someone, especially if it's a very specific accusation.

While mistakes can surely be made with the best of efforts, it's the debt collector's responsibility to correct any, rather than just shrug and ignore any rebuttals.

Of course, that's not in their financial interests (quite a few debt collecting agencies "buy" outstanding bills and try to make a profit from collecting them).

It's not my responsibility to prove I don't need to pay something; the burden of proof is completely reversed; eBay has been harassing me for years for an £18 alleged "debt" where I have already explained in great detail and with great patience why it's erroneous, but they don't listen: they simply don't reply and then send a new message as if I'm talking to a wall. I had to block a whole bunch of email addresses and phone numbers, instead.

> The alternative is magistrates and lawsuits.

"Oops, sorry, looks like I don't actually have a bill from AT&T which says you owe anything!"

Re:Debt collector profits soar with people flush and easy to... by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday August 09, 2020 @02:33PM (#24101768)
All DCAs buy past-due amounts for pennies on the pound/dollar. By the time they get to a DCA the sums have been written off by the original lender. So if the DCA can persuade a creditor to pay up in full, they're making a lot of money.

As for the law - in the UK debts are a civil not a criminal matter. So unless there's been obvious flagrant fraud they end up in county court before a judge, not a criminal court before a magistrate.

Consumer orgs like the Consumer Action Group (https://www.consumeractiongroup.co.uk/) and Legal Beagles (https://legalbeagles.info) who make it their business to offer free legal information for anyone being chased for debts, whether "reasonable" or not, with a view to avoiding a court case, getting the best possible result, or - in some cases - winning compensation for unfair/unreasonable claims and DCA/bailiff actions.

It's not unusual for lenders to have poor record keeping. People who keep original paperwork have found that some DCA "proof of debt" is entirely fake, assembled as required, with a creditor's signature copied from recent correspondence.

It's hard to feel any sympathy for an industry that operates like this.

Re:Debt collector profits soar with people flush and easy to... by arp242 on Monday August 10, 2020 @09:29AM (#24108992)
I found that consumer protection in the UK in general is pretty terrible or non-existent, and that organisations (both private and government) treat consumers/citizens rather harshly, to put it mildly. At least compared to my native country of the Netherlands. I don't know why there's such a culture of that :-/