Re:Internet user arrested for linking to other websites
by tptacek on Monday April 04, 2011 @08:47PM
(#2409228)
It matters to the extent that one might want to build a case against the law by suggesting it could ensnare innocuous (or even accidental) infringement; the argument being, "look how easy it is to run afoul of (B) or (C)".
And that's an argument I have a lot of sympathy for, even if it isn't germane to this guy's situation.
Re:Internet user arrested for linking to other websites
by hugh3 on Monday April 04, 2011 @11:10PM
(#2409501)
Well I dunno. Part C seems to only apply to works being "being prepared for production", which most folks wouldn't even have access to. Part B would be the easiest for your casual pirate to run afoul of, but if you're pirating $1000 worth of stuff within a year then... yeah, you're moving out of "occasional vice" territory and into the "just watching lots of stuff without paying for it" territory.
So he's matching either ABC, or AC, either of which put him in the running for a free vacation at club fed.