Re:Internet user arrested for linking to other websites
by aaronsw on Monday April 04, 2011 @08:16PM
(#2409154)
You leave out (B) and (C) of that paragraph:
Not the "or".
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Internet user arrested for linking to other websites
by tptacek on Monday April 04, 2011 @08:41PM
(#2409216)
You're right. I misread it. And I note further that (B) and (C) were deliberately added to address people copying software electronically without profiting from it.
But we're quibbling over how I (mis)represented the law. The fact remains: this guy got busted for taking $90,000+ out of his infringement scheme. He hit (A), not (B) or (C). That, I think, is a pretty salient detail for the FSF to have provided. Don't you agree with that?
Re:Internet user arrested for linking to other websites
by benologist on Monday April 04, 2011 @08:41PM
(#2409214)
How does it matter? The retail value of the UFC/NFL live broadcasts would be several orders of magnitude more than $1,000 to the networks/stations licensing them, and even if you let that slide based on what the end viewer is paying instead of the licensees the guy still hits C face-first.
So he's matching either ABC, or AC, either of which put him in the running for a free vacation at club fed.
Re:Internet user arrested for linking to other websites
by tptacek on Monday April 04, 2011 @08:47PM
(#2409228)
It matters to the extent that one might want to build a case against the law by suggesting it could ensnare innocuous (or even accidental) infringement; the argument being, "look how easy it is to run afoul of (B) or (C)".
And that's an argument I have a lot of sympathy for, even if it isn't germane to this guy's situation.
Re:Internet user arrested for linking to other websites
by hugh3 on Monday April 04, 2011 @11:10PM
(#2409501)
Well I dunno. Part C seems to only apply to works being "being prepared for production", which most folks wouldn't even have access to. Part B would be the easiest for your casual pirate to run afoul of, but if you're pirating $1000 worth of stuff within a year then... yeah, you're moving out of "occasional vice" territory and into the "just watching lots of stuff without paying for it" territory.