News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by coldtea on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:04PM (#24085924)
I hope those now remote employees have access to some good issue tracking, repo hosting, and collaboration/documentation tools.

Else they'll be forced to use something like Jira, Confluence, Bit Bucket, and such, which suck...

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by Solstinox on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:41PM (#24086226)
You know what’s worse than having to work with JIRA/Confluence/Bit Bucket, and such? Working with people who keep changing systems every 6-12 months. A crappy system used fully is better than system surfing to find the Holy Grail™.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by dijit on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:54PM (#24086359)
Man, I’d agree with you if my experiences with these tools wasn’t _so bad_.

The current implementation of jira and confluence I’m using is worse than having _no_ ticket tracking and documentation system.

Because if it didn’t exist there would be the impetus to implement something. But we just kinda barely limp by with what we have.

It’s so barely functional that people actively avoid using it.

I’m fully aware that the company is to blame and not necessarily atlassian though, as we have a number of plugins and random custom fields.

One of the most dangerous things about jira is that it tries to be everything to everyone and people get carried away in the customisation believing they need it. It slows everything to a crawl and leaves you inundated with mandatory fields and a nightmare of matching stories with sprints and estimations in order to bring a bloody task in.

Life was better with rt and mediawiki.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by JoshuaDavid on Friday August 07, 2020 @05:01PM (#24086428)
I think you're underestimating how bad the "something" people can come up with is. Think "weekly status reports to describe how you're doing on fixing a problem that was described through email, or an in-person meeting with someone, or a phone call, and never entered into a ticketing system at all".

Also the mandatory fields are definitely a per-organization thing. At my org we have I think 3 mandatory fields, which are the project the ticket goes under, the title, and the description. In many cases, "migrating" from JIRA to JIRA but 90% of the features are disabled would probably be an improvement.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by stjohnswarts on Friday August 07, 2020 @07:27PM (#24087473)
If you don't have scripts that will fetch all your parameters and just have to fill in a couple of fields then you're doing it wrong.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by JoshuaDavid on Friday August 07, 2020 @09:26PM (#24088173)
I do in fact have such scripts :). Also to automatically tag my git commits with the ticket, transition the jira issues appropriately when the relevant things happen with those branches or pull requests, etc. I don't actually interact with JIRA-the-application all that much these days, but in the rare cases when I do it's because I'm doing something non-trivial, and in those cases the UI seems relatively straightforward.

... I suppose that might be the main difference between people who hate JIRA and people who find it a little bit clunky but generally acceptable: people who mostly have the baseline stuff happen automatically are fine with it, and people who spend a lot of time interacting with the web frontend in repetitive ways hate it.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by dijit on Sunday August 09, 2020 @03:46PM (#24102295)
Uh... I’m having trouble envisioning this, do you have any examples?

I ended up forcing my slack bot to issue POSTs to Jiras API out of frustration.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by JoshuaDavid on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @08:02PM (#24127333)
Yes, exactly that. Basically wire up very simple commands with curl and jq that do the transitions you need, pulling data from other rest apis as necessary.

The two workhorses of my integration are two methods named jira_get and jira_post.

    function jira_get {
        ENDPOINT="$1"
        PAYLOAD="$2"

        URL="https://your-org.atlassian.net/rest/api/2/$ENDPOINT"
        QUERY_STRING="$(jq --null-input --raw-output --argjson x "$PAYLOAD" '$x|[to_entries[]|((.key|@uri)+"="+(.value|@uri))]|join("&")')"

        curl \
            --silent \
            --request "GET" \
            --header "Content-Type: application/json" \
            --user "$JIRA_USER:$JIRA_TOKEN" \
            "$URL?$QUERY_STRING";
    }

    function jira_post {
        ENDPOINT="$1"
        PAYLOAD="$2"

        URL="https://your-org.atlassian.net/rest/api/2/$ENDPOINT"
        QUERY_STRING="$(jq --null-input --raw-output --argjson x "$PAYLOAD" '$x|[to_entries[]|((.key|@uri)+"="+(.value|@uri))]|join("&")')"

        curl \
            --silent \
            --request "POST" \
            --user "$JIRA_USER:$JIRA_TOKEN" \
            --header "Content-Type: application/json" \
            "$URL" \
            --data "$PAYLOAD";
    }
Then if you want to get the available transitions, and required fields for those transitions, you can do

    ISSUE=PRJ-1234

    ISSUE_JSON="$(jira_get "issue/$ISSUE/transitions" '{"expand":"transitions.fields"}'
    TRANSITION_NAMES="$(echo "$ISSUE_JSON" | jq '.transitions[].name')"
and then given the transition in question, you can look at the fields required for the transition, and figure out where you get the data that goes in those fields normally. Any time the data that goes in those fields is obtained through a rote process, you automate that process, and then prompt for any fields you can't get in an automated fashion (e.g. "signed off by" you can fetch the reviewer names from the github api for the associated pull request).

But yeah, a slack bot that issues requests to the JIRA api is a perfectly workable solution, and I think you'd be surprised at how much of a quality of life improvement you'll get by continuing to add capabilities to it that reflect your specific workflow.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by pc86 on Friday August 07, 2020 @05:52PM (#24086831)
> I’m fully aware that the company is to blame and not necessarily atlassian though

The problem is that this anecdote is not even remotely surprising. I've used JIRA and/or Confluence at three employers and all three had wildly different, and awful, configurations. I have never worked with any technical folks who loved either, although I think on the whole Confluence is slightly better than JIRA.

I thought the same thing for a long time - that Atlassian makes decent products that are often implemented poorly - but the problem is, at what point does it become Atlassian's fault for making products that seem so easy to implement so badly that developers will go out of their way to track work in Excel instead of JIRA?

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by user5994461 on Friday August 07, 2020 @08:12PM (#24087797)
Counterpoint, worked at a large well known bank who had a massive JIRA setup, and it honestly wasn't bad.

A couple of mandatory fields (department, team, application), that were manageable and that's about it.

They even the JIRA during my tenure there. Made user sessions last for a while instead of being disconnected every 15 minutes.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by bberenberg on Friday August 07, 2020 @06:31PM (#24087093)
For what it's worth, you get the pros and cons pretty well. A large part of our business is based on taking these types of messy systems and move them forward to support the user needs.

Feel free to email me if you think your company may be open to using outside help to clean things up.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by pc86 on Friday August 07, 2020 @05:49PM (#24086812)
Except for JIRA.

I'd rather learn a completely new system every 90 days than use JIRA.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by jrott on Friday August 07, 2020 @05:55PM (#24086853)
I’m never sure if it’s actually core JIRA that is bad or if the problem is how customizable the thing is. It seems like every organization has added a bunch of custom fields and required bits that make it so annoying to use.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by manquer on Friday August 07, 2020 @06:16PM (#24086994)
Even a vanilla JIRA core on their cloud is slow as molasses, while there is slight improvement over the last year, they seem to be using more react on the frontend in each update.

On a typical day moving tickets around , reviewing everyone's items and confluence with its WYSIWHG editor only approach is 20% of my day gone.

Just making the UI non blocking for every single action would double my productivity. Their mobile apps are definitely better than web, so it is not like they cannot build decent interface and application, The web app just smells of legacy and debt to me.

Even if its because of customizability they provide, it is really on them, to approve all sorts of plugins and for all straitjacketing they and/or AGILE ( as typically implemented) does to your development in the name of structure, restricting some of this customizability would not have hurt product more.

Ultimately like any other SaaS business they serve the buyer and not the user. They are interested in what sells more, more often than not it does not intersect with what the users need. Customization sells, saying NO doesn't in enterprise.

I guess we should be thankful they are not IBM or Oracle and build your kitchen sink and neighbours too

I am tempted at least once every few months to just build a better interface and frontend which isnt' crap. Management is not going change from JIRA. Developers / users would happily pay out of pocket for a saner interface which helps simply manage their items without fuss, most people don't really care about the backend and the fancy reports, burndown charts for the most part, those who do can use the official app .

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by steffan on Friday August 07, 2020 @06:47PM (#24087193)
What does WYSIWHG stand for?
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by krapp on Friday August 07, 2020 @06:50PM (#24087224)
What You See Is What You Get
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by petepete on Saturday August 08, 2020 @02:30AM (#24089561)
What You See Is What He Gets?
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by zargon on Friday August 07, 2020 @07:25PM (#24087449)
The new "next gen" Jira projects remove all the features, but the experience is just as bad. Seems to be a fundamental Jira problem.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by dnautics on Friday August 07, 2020 @06:13PM (#24086961)
yeah my feeling (this doesn't excuse atlassian of course) is that JIRA is fantastic if and only if you have a full time JIRA wrangling PM that is competent. Otherwise it's a dumpster fire.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by rad_gruchalski on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:46PM (#24086271)
So, like jira every couple of months? Festures removed, ui changed...
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by pvarangot on Friday August 07, 2020 @05:57PM (#24086862)
I've never worked for/with a company that used Jira that didn't change the way you were supposed to use Jira every six to eight months or with any leadership changes at the project management or TPM level. Also I've never worked with two Jira setups that were the same.

I'd rather use a tool that is flexible by default than use a rigid tool that you need to change every six months.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by Jare on Friday August 07, 2020 @05:21PM (#24086563)
I was saying a couple weeks ago that one just ok system is better than 5 good ones because with 5 you never know which one of them has the thing you're looking for.

Incidentally that conversation started with the suggestion to bring Jira into our already bloated set of services.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by hinkley on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:57PM (#24086388)
I have a tiny sliver of hope that they will see how it behaves on a slow network and fix some stuff.

One day I need to have a beer with these people who say Jira is fast. I've seen everything from "unremarkable" to "If we don't reboot the servers on Monday then nobody can work after 10 am on Friday". But never, ever, fast.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by dhbradshaw on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:33PM (#24086153)
Apparently I'm in a minority but I love Jira for remote work.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by dirtnugget on Saturday August 08, 2020 @01:15AM (#24089236)
I also don't get the hate. All other tools I had to use were garbage in comparison
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by wubbalerfa on Saturday August 08, 2020 @01:47AM (#24089382)
For anyone who is already used to Jira and considering switching, think again. Monday seems to be popular as the "much faster, responsive" competitor if the marketing is to believed.

I've used it for 6 months - it's garbage. At least, absolutely ZERO times better than Jira as an overall productivity tool.

I can't tell you how many times issues have never loaded (see: blank screen), painstakingly prioritised lists of HUNDREDS of issues that have had their ordering completely scrambled, to name two off the top of my head.

If you hate Jira, think about whether it's the thing you hate that you're used to. Because you're absolutely going to be trading for a NEW thing that you hate, and have to learn to use from scratch.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by stjohnswarts on Friday August 07, 2020 @07:26PM (#24087457)
All those things work fine as long as you don't penny pinch on servers. If you do ignore scaling, then yeah it's gonna be slow and horrible.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by sg47 on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:42PM (#24086243)
Thank God they discontinued Hipchat.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by Orou on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:46PM (#24086279)
I actually liked Hipchat. It did what it was supposed to do - provide instant chat with colleagues - without the overhead and frills of Slack. It was simple and reliable. I'm not sure why it was so disliked.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by babaganoosh89 on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:56PM (#24086378)
The memes were also better
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by laurent92 on Friday August 07, 2020 @05:03PM (#24086447)
Hipchat memes were the main upside of the product, differenciating it from the market. They were 500x500 squares, not tiny emojimemes like in Discord or Slack. You could truely express an opinion. It was heartwarming.

Then they decided that they wanted to look serious, and reduced the meme size to 32px. That’s when the product fell out of fashion, because it was just like Slack with fewer features.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by Nuzzerino on Friday August 07, 2020 @08:38PM (#24087923)
IIRC Hipchat had a lot of outages when Slack was becoming popular. I'm sure there was more to it than the meme image size.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by adrr on Friday August 07, 2020 @09:12PM (#24088103)
Thats why we switched from Hipchat to Slack. Slack's client for the Mac was so terrible at the time but we couldn't deal with the outages of Hipchat. I remember you could see the underlying browsers context menu if you right clicked in the original Slack app.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by somewhereoutth on Friday August 07, 2020 @05:35PM (#24086687)
Have we regressed back to drawing things on the (cave) walls??

Thousands of years of linguistic progress out the window...

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by umanwizard on Friday August 07, 2020 @08:31PM (#24087889)
What do you mean by linguistic progress? AFAIK there isn’t any evidence that human language was much different during the cave painting era than it is now.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by dirtnugget on Saturday August 08, 2020 @01:17AM (#24089246)
wat?
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by Izkata on Friday August 07, 2020 @06:36PM (#24087123)
On the flipside, "a picture is worth a thousand words"...
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by somewhereoutth on Sunday August 09, 2020 @02:31PM (#24101753)
I would say a picture is worth a thousand words for things that can be pictured. Most things actually can't, hence words.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by hevelvarik on Friday August 07, 2020 @05:53PM (#24086840)
Underrated point
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by hinkley on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:55PM (#24086365)
> It was simple and reliable.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by stjohnswarts on Friday August 07, 2020 @07:32PM (#24087506)
What is hard about slack? We use channels for the "group" stuff and IM for quick and dirty chats, otherwise just pick up the phone and call. I personally just prefer using email, but the kids like their slack/discord/whatever
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by hinkley on Saturday August 08, 2020 @03:02AM (#24089674)
I had a friend complain it was eating their battery, and my phone battery started acting weird around the time I installed it. Seems better now, did they ever confess to a problem?
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by drewg123 on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:43PM (#24086252)
Odd, that's the one atlassian product I like. I remember it as being better than slack..
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by entropea on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:14PM (#24085987)
I am directly responsible for Jira and Confluence admin/infrastructure on an enterprise level and once you know how at least Jira works, its a fairly powerful tool for PM's. I haven't run into many issues except during a migration where we knew we were going to run into issues.

Atlassian's documentation isn't that good however.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by JoshTriplett on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:17PM (#24086015)
> its a fairly powerful tool for PM's

That's the fundamental problem. Jira is sold to PMs and managers, not to developers, and it shows. Jira isn't an issue tracking tool, it's a work-tracking and developer-tracking tool masquerading as an issue tracker. The people who spend the most time with it aren't the customer.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by lemmsjid on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:33PM (#24086157)
Interesting how perspectives differ. Having used Jira for many years, I think it's straightforward for engineering work, but particularly hard for PMs and managers. Why? On the engineering side, it's pretty straightforward to integrate into a lifecycle. But for PMs and management it's a nightmare because they still haven't gotten their birds-eye-view roadmapping / bulk editing act together. The usual issue I have with Jira is that the engineering team gets it integrated into their workflows, things work ok, but it's a continual challenge getting global rollup views to the business at large. We keep ending up with Excel, Airtable, or what-have-you high level views that then point to particular Jira issues for details (yes, we've used Portfolio).

I think this actually might be a fundamental issue that is masquerading as design issues on Jira's side, because when you're doing roadmapping views you want to continually refactor them to reflect better metaphors and realities, whereas when you're doing issue tracking you want issues to stick around and be solid entities linked intimately into the history of the software application. So tools like Portfolio have to juggle both ends.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by Izkata on Friday August 07, 2020 @07:33PM (#24087515)
This is pretty much my experience as well - Jira is used almost entirely by developers (and we set up the statuses/transitions/etc in the ways we find useful), while product organizes their thoughts in Excel/Google Sheets and will create/watch/comment on Jira cases but mostly not otherwise use it.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by stjohnswarts on Friday August 07, 2020 @07:34PM (#24087522)
Can someone explain what is hard about Jira to me? I push bugs and pull bugs and spend maybe 20 minutes a day in it. What is hard about it? Am I just at a place that uses it sanely? Once a week we spend maybe 1 or 2 hours in it review/updating the Agile sprint buckets with the group.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by JoshTriplett on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:24PM (#24088674)
One of the other problems with Jira is that it's incredibly easy to create complex Byzantine workflows, dozens of required fields to file or update an issue, and reports based on those files. That makes it easy for a bad PM or manager to take their own hard questions to answer and turn them into endless bureaucracy for developers.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by user5994461 on Friday August 07, 2020 @08:20PM (#24087840)
You must at a place that is sane enough.

A non sane place would have 20 obscure mandatory fields per ticket, require the ticket to go through 10 different states that makes no sense, and last but not least, every click would take a full minute to load the page.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by fennecfoxen on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:43PM (#24086247)
> Jira is sold to PMs and managers, not to developers, and it shows

When you're working with Python, Jira will render __init__.py as an italicized version of _init_.py even when you put it in monospace with the {{braces}}. If you're talking more abstractly about algorithms, O(n) turns into the letter O followed by the thumbs down emoji.

It's a good thing no one uses Jira for software projects because that'd be really awkward!!!

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by marmaduke on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:21PM (#24086043)
I use Jira to track issues. It’s not as pretty and dumbed down as Github or as dandy as YouTrack but does the job fine over the last 8 years we used it.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by entropea on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:31PM (#24086133)
You can set it up to be an issue tracker or you can set it up to be work & developer tracking. It's really dependent on how your PM sets your projects up.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by pm90 on Friday August 07, 2020 @05:01PM (#24086429)
Both JIRA and confluence are slow and the UI's are horrible and incredibly unresponsive by modern standards. It shouldn't take several seconds to load my JIRA board. Fuzzy searching for issues should just work.

Collaborating over JIRA on a video conference is PAINFUL AF. A lot of time is spent just waiting for the UI to respond. It is completely unacceptable.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by skrap on Friday August 07, 2020 @07:56PM (#24087704)
Curious if you use self-hosted or cloud jira? My main problem with (cloud) jira is that it takes about 30 seconds from navigating to the site until I can start typing my issue comment or description or whatever. And that's without using search... It's just _so_ slow.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by triceratops on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:44PM (#24086262)
Jira is achingly slow. Confluence has the worst search in the world.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by Hamuko on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:31PM (#24086129)
>once you know how at least Jira works, its a fairly powerful tool for PM's.

I'm not a PM and I don't really want to get to know the ins and outs of an issue tracker.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by entropea on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:33PM (#24086154)
I'm not entirely sure why you'd comment this in the first place? If you're a developer you simply need to login and look at your project, not really know much else except how to click issue buttons. I'm talking from an administrator standpoint. Developers also aren't the center of the universe no matter how much we think we are.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by Hamuko on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:36PM (#24086183)
Most of the tickets in our JIRA are made for the developers, not for the PMs or the customer support.

Also, looking at my project is a pain since my tickets are outside the sprint and I either need to go into the backlog and scroll a bunch, or use a custom search.

Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by stjohnswarts on Friday August 07, 2020 @07:38PM (#24087561)
Unless you're a micromanager that's the way it should be. She see issues opening and closing and estimates on it. If those estimates blow up/linger on and on then the PM is needed to pull together resources and get it finished off. I don't see how it's a big deal. I've used it both as group lead and as a programmer and didn't have many issues with it either way. Sure it's a bit laggy but it's not that bad. It would be a lot nicer if they'd made a native client that has better queuing/caching of tasks to let you do many things at once.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by ergocoder on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:14PM (#24088629)
I raise you the issue tracker Google Chrome uses. it's bad in every way.
Re:Atlassian tells employees they can work from home forever by secondcoming on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:25PM (#24086078)
lmao, i don't mind jira, but bitbucket sucks all the balls